On Tuesday, the Federal Communications Commission approved the first rules meant to guarantee equality for all users of the Internet and, in the process, managed to satisfy no one.

The two camps criticizing the ruling have been historically at odds.

On one side is the telecom industry (e.g., Verizon, AT&T) and the Internet service providers (Verizon, Comcast) who would prefer the government keep its nose out of how the Internet is run and let free markets decide.

On the other side are the free web activists, who also are a little nervous about government regulation but believe that something has to be done to keep corporations from pillaging Internet users in the name of profit and that the FCC has not done enough.

Advertise with us

Both sides believe the FCC has walked the line between them about as well as a drunk at a traffic stop after a Christmas party.

So what did the FCC actually rule that got everyone's nose so out of joint?

First, the rules prohibit Internet access providers from blocking lawful content, applications, services or nonharmful devices. Although lawful content is not defined, one can presume it does not include file sharing of copyrighted material.

Secondly, access providers must disclose the details of their network management techniques. This is in response to Comcast claiming that blocking BitTorrent file sharing was necessary to manage its network.

Thirdly, the rules prohibit unreasonable discrimination in transmitting lawful network traffic over a consumer's broadband Internet access service. This would protect against Verizon, for example, which is a provider of telephone service, from blocking or slowing traffic for Skype, which competes using Internet-based telephone service.

Advertise with us

But here's the rub: The rules only fully apply to desktop broadband.

The FCC said that wireless broadband, owing to the current limits of the wireless infrastructure and in order not to hinder innovation, is exempt from the discrimination rule. It is also subject to a more limited blocking rule.

That exemption is what particularly sticks in the craw of some.

The wireless exemption was proposed as part of a joint statement by Verizon and Google several months ago, leading to charges that the FCC merely rubber-stamped the industry plan.

That suspicion was bolstered by the justification of less stringent wireless measures in the ruling by recent moves toward openness, including the introduction of open operating systems like Android.

Advertise with us

MG Siegler, writing on the blog TechCrunch, points out that Android is a Google product and wonders what an operating system has to do with Internet access. And he notes that part of the FCC ruling sounds a lot like the Google-Verizon joint proposal. (To be fair, the Google-Verizon proposal wanted wireless to be exempt from all rules.)

The FCC guidelines were approved by the three Democratic members of the commission and opposed by the two Republican members.

Republican FCC commissioner Robert McDowell, writing in the Wall Street Journal, called the ruling jaw-dropping interventionist chutzpah as the FCC bypasses branches of government in the dogged pursuit of needless and harmful regulation.

That points to the biggest weakness of the FCC ruling -- it may not stand.

A judge ruled in a suit against the FCC brought by Comcast that the commission lacked the legal authority to regulate Internet service providers since they are not technically telecommunications companies as defined in the FCC charter.

Advertise with us

To remedy this, Chairman Julius Genachowski threatened to reclassify Internet providers as telecommunications companies. But he did not do that. He simply said he believed the FCC had the legal standing to make Net neutrality rules.

So the political battle already is heating up.

Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison, R-Texas, ranking member on the Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee, joined by seven Republican senators, introduced legislation to block funding for the FCC's Net neutrality efforts.

The FCC chairman's attempt to impose new government regulations on the Internet is unnecessary government overreach that will stifle future innovation, Ms. Hutchison said.

On the other side, Rep. Ed Markey, D-Mass., a longstanding proponent of Net neutrality, urged the FCC to move ahead with its rules.

Advertise with us

"The Internet's rules of the road should not create electronic 'E-Z Pass' lanes only for those who can pay, leaving others stuck in traffic or limping along at a snail's pace," Mr. Markey said.

There are those who believe the proper place for Net neutrality legislation is Congress. Others fear that in Congress, the telecommunication companies' robust lobbying and rich campaign contributions could carry the day.

So once the political dust settles, how did the American Internet user come out of the whole thing? Not bad, TechMan thinks.

While it would have been good to have more stringent rules for wireless, at least the FCC has started down the path of trying to ensure fair treatment for the Internet user. Getting Congress involved probably would not produce a win for the average citizen.

And the fact that the FCC ruling infuriated the extremes is par for the course these days when everything is so highly politicized.

Security tip: If you are using Windows XP, do not do normal business as an administrative user. If you have only one account, create another with limited user powers and use it for Net surfing and other routine tasks.