BERLIN -- The European Union's telecommunications commissioner threatened Tuesday to crack down on member states that allow powerful former telephone monopolies to charge steep fees that raise phone and Internet costs to consumers.

Neelie Kroes, the commissioner who oversees telecommunications, said she was prepared to open an investigation should some of the E.U.'s 27 national regulators ignore guidelines designed to lower the costs levied by the monopolies on rivals who need access to key national telecom grids.

Those charges add from €5.55, or $7.16, a month to consumer phone bills in Poland, to €17.68 a month in Ireland, according to the European Commission.

Mrs. Kroes said she was ready to use new powers included in a 2009 European telecom law that give the commission a broad mandate to compel compliance on telecom issues.

Advertise with us

The law, which takes effect in May, gives Mrs. Kroes the power to open a high-level investigation into the practices and methods used by E.U. national regulators in permitting the former monopolies to raise the rates they charge competitors for access to their grids.

In most European countries, former monopolies, like Deutsche Telekom, France Télécom, Telefónica of Spain and Telecom Italia, continue to operate the only nationwide networks and control the critical "last-mile, local loop" connections to most consumers.

"We are ready to use this new tool in our toolbox," Mrs. Kroes said in a speech Tuesday to the European Competitive Telecommunications Association, a group representing competitors to the former monopolies.

The warning, she added, "is not abstract. I can assure you of that."

The threat comes a month after rivals to Telecom Italia alleged that the Italian regulator proposed allowing the former monopoly to raise the monthly charges it imposes on competitors for leasing local-loop access to Italian consumers by 24 percent through 2013.

Advertise with us

In June, the Telecom Italia competitors FastWeb, a unit of Swisscom, and Wind, which is being acquired by the Russian operator Vimpelcom, filed a complaint with the Italian competition regulator over Telecom Italia's wholesale pricing demands, which they alleged were limiting competition and resulting in a direct subsidy of the market's dominant phone company.

Mario Calderoni, a spokesman for the Italian regulator Agcom, said the agency told Mrs. Kroes on Nov. 11 that it was amending its agreement with Telecom Italia to permit a maximum increase of 9.4 percent over the two-year period, not what was alleged by rivals.

Telecom Italia has also agreed to lower the charges it imposes on competitors for line rental and bit-stream access, which is a high-level leasing of core trunk lines, which will further mitigate the price increases to rivals, Mr. Calderoni said.

Despite attempts by Brussels to bring down these costs, former monopolies in Europe continue to charge competitors steep fees for access to nationwide landline networks used for broadband and other basic services.

The issue has been complicated in Italy by the regulator's plans to force Telecom Italia to separate the management of its operating business from its ownership of the national grid. Britain was the first E.U. country to require such a separation in 2006, when BT created a separate entity called OpenReach to lease access to competitors and BT on equal terms.

Advertise with us

In an Oct. 21 letter to the Italian telecom regulator, Autorita per le Garanzie nelle Comunicazioni, Mrs. Kroes endorsed the agency's push to take a similar step, but criticized Agcom for letting Telecom Italia raise its wholesale access prices.

In her letter, Mrs. Kroes said Agcom's decision did not follow its own published methodology.

Telecom Italia, a major employer in Italy, has struggled amid competition from mobile rivals. In 2007, a consortium led by the Spanish operator, Telefónica, and a group of Italy's largest banks and insurers, bought a 24 percent stake in Telecom Italia in a deal seen as a defensive move to stave off a hostile bid.

In 2009, the commission tried but failed to win support for a new E.U. telecom regulator with the power to overrule the decisions of domestic regulators. The resulting comprise was a new advisory group, the Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications, now based in Riga, Latvia, which has only limited authority to intervene.

But the same 2009 law gave the commission more power to take legal action against E.U. members states that do not comply with its dictates. The so-called treaty infringement proceedings can take three or more years to resolve, with the resulting penalties and remedies often being too paltry or too late to mitigate the unfair advantage gained by the former monopolies.