"Your TV just got smarter," Google trumpets on the website for its new venture, Google TV.
Whether Google's attempt to unite Web browsing, TV watching and applications -- with search perched on top -- revolutionizes the way you watch TV remains to be seen.
Although Google TV is new, some of its parts are not. Surfing the Web on a TV goes back to the mid-1990s when WebTV, later bought by Microsoft and renamed MSN TV, brought out boxes that allowed TV Web surfing. It went nowhere.
Searching for TV content also is not new since you can do it using most cable "guide" applications. Already on the market are TVs that have "apps" or applications you can run on them, such as Netflix.
What Google proposes to do is bring all this together in one place so that you can use its tried and true search engine to find content anywhere, be it on TV, on the Web or through an app.
You will access Google TV through a special box or using a TV or Blu-ray player with it built in.
Last week, Logitech announced its Revue, a $300 wired or wireless box that includes a wireless keyboard. There is also a $130 miniremote. The box, scheduled to ship by the end of the month, runs Google's Chrome browser.
This week, Sony is expected to announce a set or sets with GoogleTV built in.
The remote control for the Sony TV was shown last week, and reviews were resoundingly negative, saying it was confusing and poorly designed with a multitude of buttons -- that's in part because you need a full keyboard to operate Google TV.
But before we get into shortcomings, let's look at what Google TV will do.
First, it will let you search for audio and video content in many places -- the Web, cable, Internet radio, photo service Flickr, Web-based paid content providers and, of course, YouTube, which Google owns.
You can view both TV and Web pages at the same time in a picture-in-picture setup. For example, you could watch a movie while looking up the cast on the Internet. Some say that viewing a Web page from across the room may be less than satisfying.
Google TV will have apps, limited at first, that will customize the viewing experience. Google says the number of apps will quickly grow and, starting next year, apps from the Android Market will work.
You can use your Android phone or iPhone as a remote, including voice search on Android phones. For some applications, if you are watching video or viewing a Web page on your phone, you can "fling" it to appear on your TV with a press of a button.
Google TV also will have a home page where you can put shortcuts to your favorite content. A Google Queue will allow you to make a playlist of content you come across but want to view later.
Now, to what Google TV can't do.
Other than on Google partner Dish Network, you can't record a show on Google TV from the search box because Google has not negotiated the right to access cable DVRs. If you find a show you want to record, you'll have to switch to the cable DVR to record it.
Also, there won't be access to some video providers, such as free and paid Web site Hulu, which has blocked service. Google says it is in talks with Hulu, but other sites could decide to block Google TV.
So, will Google TV revolutionize the living room experience?
That depends on the answers to some questions.
Do consumers have a need or a desire to combine their TV viewing and Web surfing and do it from the living room couch?
Do TV viewers want to find content by search, rather than the venerable channel surfing?
Will a keyboard be given a place on the coffee table?
Will Google be accepted by the video establishment and sign up new partners, or will there be a move to shut it out, as Hulu has done so far?
Will consumers pay $300 for a box when competitors Apple TV and Roku are available for less than $100, although with more limited capabilities.
Depending on the answers, Google could have its newest hit or another WebTV, destined for a technology footnote.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.