The United States Court of Appeals in Washington, D.C., dealt a body blow to the Federal Communications Commission last week.
In FCC v. Comcast, the court not only ruled that the FCC had no authority to force net neutrality on Comcast, but that it had limited right to regulate Internet service providers, such as Comcast and Verizon.
This comes at a time when the FCC just unveiled its new policy for the future of the Internet.
Let's go back a minute.
In 2007, Comcast customers discovered that Comcast was interfering with use of BitTorrent, a program for moving very large files across the Internet. (Often used for stealing movies.)
The FCC told Comcast that doing that violated "net neutrality," the idea that all Internet traffic should be treated the same by Internet service providers.
Comcast stopped the practice, but filed suit against the FCC, saying it had no right to regulate how Comcast managed its network.
One of the legal problems for the FCC was that the Communications Act of 1934 specifically listed "common carriers" that fell under FCC authority -- telephone, television, etc. Cable was added later. But Internet service providers were never named in the act.
The FCC claimed "ancillary" authority over ISPs, which meant it could act in matters necessary in the execution of its functions.
But the court said the FCC did not prove that its actions against Comcast, dictating how ISPs run their networks, met the test for ancillary authority.
Or as David J. Farber, CMU professor of computer science and public policy and a former chief technologist at the FCC, put it, the court told the FCC it had no right "to play in this area. If you want power you can go to Congress."
According to Professor Farber, the FCC has three choices, none good.
It could ask Congress to change the law to put ISPs specifically under the FCC's purview. Professor Farber thinks there is not much chance of that, particularly in an election year.
The FCC could declare ISPs Title II carriers, in effect doing what Congress has not done, and then suffer the outcry and defend the lawsuits sure to come. Also unlikely.
Or the FCC could "punt" and say it will appeal the ruling without much chance of winning.
The FCC's plan for the future of the Internet in this country is basically a push for faster, cheaper service -- even in rural areas -- that would bring the U.S. up to modern world standards. To accomplish some parts of its plan, the FCC might have to require ISPs to do things they don't want to do. The court's decision makes that more difficult.
But Professor Farber says net neutrality is a "hazy" concept.
We need to extend broadband into rural areas. We need to make it cheaper so that more people can access it. And we need to make it faster. There is a public hunger for this. When Google announced a contest to pick a city to test superfast Internet service, more than a thousand cities applied, including Pittsburgh. Topeka, Kan., changed its name temporarily to Google to try to gain an advantage.
Pervasive high-speed Internet would open up a new world of innovation. And not just downloading HD movies in seconds.
It would allow doctors to direct surgery from a distant location. Or with the help of robots, doctors could even perform surgery at a distance. People could have productive doctors' appointments without leaving home.
Think of the possibilities in distance learning, communications and other fields.
The FCC must forge ahead on its mission -- faster, cheaper Internet access everywhere.
And Congress should ignore telco lobbying and change the law so the FCC has the clear authority to get it done.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.