In 2006, Internet entrepreneur James H. Rossell III was having financial problems. A bank sued him for falling behind on the mortgage of his Churchill home and a court froze his bank account to seize the assets for child support.

Even as those proceedings played out, a Greene County nonprofit organization -- oblivious to Mr. Rossell's woes -- planned to hand him a $500,000 state grant for his start-up company, Gravity Web Media.

Donald Chappel, executive director of Greene County Industrial Developments Inc., said that at the time he sought the grant money from the state Department of Economic Development he had no idea about Mr. Rossell's financial circumstances.

When he was turned down for trying to tap a nonprofit state fund on behalf of Mr. Rossell's for-profit company, Mr. Chappel successfully reapplied on behalf of his own corporation, which then struck a deal to put the money in Mr. Rossell's hands -- a deal that the state says should have been disclosed at the time but was not.

Advertise with us

How the grant was spent by Greene County Industrial Developments and Gravity Web Media is the subject of a new state audit launched because of questions raised by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. The state economic development agency anticipates auditors will complete that review this week.

Mr. Chappel -- who called the situation with Mr. Rossell "a nightmare" -- has been unable to account for $84,000 of the $243,000 spent through the grant.

"I'm human. I made a mistake," Mr. Chappel said last week.

A look at how taxpayer money funded Mr. Rossell's company shows lax oversight by the development corporation, poor record-keeping, and the influence of politics in delivering grants.

Mr. Rossell said Michael Manzo, former chief of staff for Democratic Rep. Bill DeWeese, first brought up the availability of state grant money for Gravity Web Media during a meeting at the Downtown Pittsburgh offices of Gravity Web Media's law firm, Tucker Arensberg. Then-Tucker Arensberg lobbyist Robert Vescio introduced Mr. Rossell to Mr. Manzo. Mr. Chappel was there, too, as Greene County is part of the district represented by Mr. DeWeese, the former House Democratic leader.

Advertise with us

"I was told that Don Chappel had some technology park they were looking to open. They just started asking me questions about what we were looking to do," Mr. Rossell said. "It was good publicity for them to help businesses, particularly technology-based businesses in Western Pennsylvania."

Mr. Rossell, who was seeking investors, said he presented a strategic plan for his company that would cost roughly $470,000 to carry out.

"That's when we were offered $500,000. It literally took me five or six minutes to catch my breath," Mr. Rossell said.

The idea was to tap a pot of state money meant for nonprofits. Grant applications are typically signed off by lawmakers and prioritized by party caucus leaders, who forward them to the state. In this case, Mr. Manzo and at least one other person working for Mr. DeWeese, Paul Reimel, played key roles.

A February 2009 memo by Mr. Chappel to the state identified Mr. Reimel, formerly a research specialist for the House majority leader's policy office under Mr. DeWeese, as someone who "did the leg work on getting grant approval."

Advertise with us

"It was suggested to Paul that we create a memorandum of understanding with Gravity Web Media so that funds can be [disbursed] to the company that was going to locate a branch office in Waynesburg," Mr. Chappel wrote in that memo. He would not say who made that suggestion.

Mr. Reimel could not be reached. Mr. Manzo declined comment.

Mr. Manzo has pleaded guilty to charges connected to the government corruption case known as Bonusgate and is now a star witness against other defendants. Mr. DeWeese faces charges in that case.

Testimony about Gravity Web Media has come up during the Bonusgate trial in connection with work the company did for the House Democratic caucus. And both Mr. Rossell and Democratic employees critical of his company's work testified about that work before a grand jury investigating Bonusgate.

At the time of his efforts to secure the grant, Mr. Chappel was trying to woo the Internet start-up from its 43rd-story perch on Grant Street to the EverGreene Technology Park in Waynesburg. Gravity Web Media was trying to expand -- and Mr. Chappel's group was to get a $10,000 cut to administer the grant.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rossell, 34, came across to Mr. Chappel as a savvy entrepreneur.

"You sit and you listen to him talk, very knowledgeable. He's represented by Tucker Arensberg, a Downtown Pittsburgh firm. He has an office in Oxford Centre. He said all the right things," Mr. Chappel recalled. "My first impression was he was very good."

Chuck McDowell, a Tennessee businessman and former partner, called also Mr. Rossell's computer skills "unbelievably good."

But Mr. Rossell had failed to impress the House Democratic caucus by doing little or no work on a $96,500 contract in 2006 to redesign the caucus's legislative website, and mediocre work on campaign-related sites, according to House employees.

Mr. Rossell disputed their accounts and said the Democrats postponed his work for various reasons -- none having to do with him -- during the run-up to the 2008 arrests of Mr. Manzo and others in Bonusgate.

Advertise with us

Another element that seemed to add to Mr. Rossell's aura, former associates said, was his contention of having an M.B.A. from the University of Pittsburgh. Mr. Rossell does not have one, however, and recanted a statement to the contrary after a lengthy interview.

"I don't have a degree from Pitt," Mr. Rossell said. "I lied."

Beyond the criticism in Harrisburg, Mr. Rossell had his mortgage troubles, two bank accounts frozen by the courts in 2005 and 2006, and several bench warrants issued for failing to appear at child support conferences.

His problems persist. Mr. Rossell is wanted on two bench warrants -- one for child support and the other stemming from charges of bouncing a $126.18 check in 2008 at an Oakland pharmacy and then not showing up for a hearing. His company is defunct. He said he is still living in his house in Churchill although he lost it in foreclosure and no longer owns it.

In interviews, Mr. Rossell and Mr. Chappel blamed each other for Gravity Web Media's failure to relocate to Greene County.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rossell claims no space was ever available at the technology park despite a requirement to move his company there under the deal with Greene County Industrial Developments. Mr. Chappel acknowledged that the park was full, but said Mr. Rossell did not act on an offer of space elsewhere.

Spotty documentation at Mr. Chappel's office sheds little light on how the grant was spent.

Gravity Web Media paperwork produced by Mr. Chappel contained no bills, receipts, canceled checks or formal invoices to justify money provided to the company. Mr. Chappel declined to answer specific questions about documentation and expenditures until he meets with the state.

Mr. Chappel and Mr. Rossell also dispute when and how much Mr. Rossell was paid.

The state cut a $500,000 check to Greene County Industrial Developments in May 2007. Mr. Chappel has a June 12, 2007 letter signed by Mr. Rossell asking for just over $100,000 to pay for salaries and two laser printers.

Advertise with us

But Mr. Rossell claims that Mr. Chappel gave him about $200,000 in May immediately after the grant came through and said he never sent Mr. Chappel a request in June for more money.

Mr. Rossell, described by those who know him as smart -- he says he has "a Pentium chip for a brain" -- had the pedigree to succeed.

His grandfather, James H. Rossell, taught accounting for 50 years at Pitt, where a plaque that bears his likeness typically hangs in Mervis Hall, home of the Katz Graduate School of Business.

"He was an old friend and colleague of mine," said Andrew R. Blair, vice provost for faculty affairs. "He was one of the most respected persons who ever taught at the business school."

Dr. Blair is one of six people listed as a member of Gravity Web Media's "advisory panel" in a document on company stationery found in the state's grant file.

Advertise with us

Dr. Blair called it a "phantom panel" and said he had never heard of Gravity Web Media until a reporter contacted him this month. Three other people listed also said they knew Mr. Rossell but were not part of the panel.

As for Mr. Rossell, Dr. Blair said he remembered meeting him a single time in the 1990s when the young man looked him up on campus.

Mr. Rossell said he gave the advisory panel document to Mr. Chappel the first time they met as part of a 60-page proposal but never intended it to be an official list.

He said the listed names were among many he was considering for his board of directors.

"It was a list off of the top of my head of individuals I thought I could get an audience with," he said. "These are people I thought might be able to help us."

Advertise with us

He acknowledged he never approached members of his prospective panel. And he said if he were Dr. Blair, he would have been "astonished, too, if I were him."

"I screwed up big time ... I found out about the meeting [with Mr. Manzo and Mr. Chappel] on short notice, and I wanted to be super prepared," Mr. Rossell said. "This was stupidity and was a huge mistake."

As time passed, Mr. Chappel said he grew leery of Mr. Rossell. Mr. Rossell said he came to believe Mr. Chappel would not aid him and was making it more difficult to tap into the grant, particularly after Mr. Manzo was arrested.

Eventually, Mr. Chappel closed the grant and sent roughly half of the money back to the state.

The state economic development department rejected a final audit done for Mr. Chappel's group because, among other things, it failed to account for $84,000. But the department seemed satisfied with a lengthy memo Mr. Chappel sent on Feb. 11, 2009.

Advertise with us

"I explained I feel the victim in this process because I have felt all along I was doing what Reimel explained to me that DCED wanted done with the grant," Mr. Chappel wrote.

A week later, Nadine E. Ibberson, director of DCED's audits and compliance division, closed out the grant and sent a letter to Mr. Chappel's boss, Ralph Sommers Jr.:

"Congratulations to you and others involved in this project for the successful use of funds provided through the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania."