You've probably heard the term NIMBY (not in my back yard). As a result of a recent column (TechMan, July 26), I am coining a new term, NOMKEY (not on my keyboard.)

In that column, TechMan stepped on his soapbox and suggested that keyboard makers update the PC keyboard by removing outdated keys. It seems that TechMan also stepped on a few readers' toes.

Wrote reader Joe:

"Dear Techman:

Advertise with us

"One of the handiest keys you want to get rid of, I use all the time. It's the ^ (a "circumflex" in French). The combo ^p [lowercase] will find/replace an Enter key in a search/replace. The combo ^t [also lowercase] will find/replace a tab key. Real handy for formatting Word documents you pasted in from another source like the Web.

"I also use Print Screen to capture screen dumps for my students and paste them into my handouts."

Dear Joe: You are correct. TechMan has erred. The caret key is used to help represent certain other keystrokes in search and replace. So I guess it can stay. Maybe a less prominent place on the keyboard than shift 6 would be better.

As far as Print Screen goes, notice I did not advocate killing it. Instead I would augment its function of printing the screen to the clipboard with a function on the same key to print the screen directly to the printer, the key's original use. That would replace SysRq on that key. I dare anyone to tell me he uses SysRq regularly.

Another reader wrote:

Advertise with us

"Regarding your column about deleting useless keys, I disagree with your suggestion to remove the Caps Lock key. I find it very useful at times. My objection is that if you forget to release it, an attempt to capitalize a letter gives you a letter in the lower case."

Again the reader is right. ("The reader is always right" is TechMan's motto.) The Caps Lock key can be useful. My objection is not that it is useless, but that it is annoying and in the wrong place. How many times have you pressed it by mistake? It should be moved out of its high traffic area to keyboard Siberia.

Reader Joe (are all my readers named Joe?) wrote:

"I must defend the | (pipe) key in your article about eliminating useless keys on the keyboard. There is so much power in piping in Unix/Linux! Maybe Windows users don't use it, or the command line in general, but piping is just too slick to remove the dedicated key for it."

Dear Joe: Of course you are right -- you are a reader. Let me just say that my overhaul of the keyboard would be for average users. If programmers or Unix users wanted to have specialized keyboards with such keys as the pipe on them, God bless their pointy little heads.

Advertise with us

Reader Pat wrote:

"I loved your column. It is a work of genius; simplify the keyboard, something that should have been done years ago. With one simple thought (eliminating useless keys like | and ~) you manage to stop programmers (who still exist) from introducing new bugs into the various systems we use. With this thought, we can become familiar with the bugs in our systems and work around them, without fear that those pesky programmers will add new problems for us to cope with.

"Indeed, the thought is of such genius that we should extend it to other keyboards. All normal people use only one or two octaves of keys on their piano keyboards, so let's get rid of all the rest. And, of course, those silly black keys are hard to hit, so we might as well get rid of them too. What a simplification this would be. Then, everyone could play the piano.

"Go for it; this idea is brilliant and should go far. Perhaps the farther the better."

Pat, Pat, Pat. Do I sense a note of sarcasm here? The "pesky programmers" could still have their pipes and Pause/Break keys on their keyboards. Just don't impose them on the rest of us.

By the way, TechMan took 10 years of piano lessons and never learned to play. I think it was those silly black keys.