It looks like I hit a sore spot with my recent column about how technology has reduced the risks for airlines and hotels, so they no longer have a reason to overbook flights or rooms.

In that column, I suggested that if somebody books a nonrefundable fare, the airline should have that seat available under any conditions -- and that Internet payments eliminate the need to overbook to make sure the airline gets paid.

The responses have been from several viewpoints. Reader Alan Schultz took my reasoning a step further with his response: "Overbooking by airlines amounts to fraud, fraud being a criminal action which should be prosecuted as such -- particularly with respect to nonrefundable tickets."

In that same column I discussed how airlines don't allow discount online travel brokerages to reserve seats automatically -- a policy that was revealed to me by a US Airways telephone support agent. So when we think we're reserving a seat through online travel brokers, we're only putting in our request for that seat, but not seeing a true confirmation by the airline that the seat is ours.

Advertise with us

Lawyer Larry Chaban suggests I missed a point by not putting at least part of the blame on the online brokers because they should be telling us they aren't reserving the seats. Just because the airlines don't allow them to reserve the seats as a policy doesn't mean the Web site doesn't have some duty to let us know our seats are not confirmed. We shouldn't have to hear from the airlines that the seats aren't ours as we had expected.

Other readers have shared stories with me about how they have encountered similar bumpings -- or near bumpings -- much more frequently as airlines have increased their yields. Others tell me they build in extra leeway in their travel plans because they expect bumping to happen more frequently. Some even plan to get bumped -- something that not every traveler can easily accommodate. And others have shared suggestions to smooth my next trip to Florida, including going into new airports such as Fort Myers, and using a discount airline, such as USA 3000 or Southwest.

Thanks to all readers who have offered suggestions. I'll keep them in mind for future excursions.

Hotel chains have similar problems. On that same trip, we reserved a hotel at 4 p.m. through Hotwire.com to stay in that same night. Hotwire didn't reveal the hotel name until after we booked it; but we knew its general vicinity. Based on the Hotwire session, we thought we were getting a nonsmoking room with two double beds; but when we arrived just 90 minutes later, we were told the rooms had been sold out for days, and that this hotel never allocates our requested room-type to be booked through Hotwire. We found out about the incorrect booking by opening the room door and finding a single king bed. Hotwire had confirmed a room -- but didn't give us a description on the confirmation, even though we had picked all the right options.

Again, we got lucky. Thirty minutes after we checked in the desk clerk called to say she had just received a cancellation for the correct type of room -- and switched us. Otherwise our only choices were to keep the wrong room or lose our nonrefundable payment to Hotwire.

Mistakes happen, but technology should virtually eliminate the type of mistake that happened twice to us on the same trip. The problem is not the technology -- it's the policies: Overbooking and not sharing accurate information are among the biggest culprits. Until the industry gets smarter or legislators crack down, the public will continue to lose.