Microsoft's courtship of Yahoo! almost seems scripted like a Rock Hudson-Doris Day movie -- with the players sharing their plans about the relationship with their buddies -- but never really talking to one another about it.
The script: Microsoft approaches Yahoo (a year ago); gets rebuffed; waits a year. After the fortunes at Yahoo drop, Microsoft chief Steve Ballmer warns Yahoo founder Jerry Yang that he plans to make a more public bid; then two days later announces his intentions to the world -- only to be refused by Yahoo's board.
Are they playing cat-&-mouse, waiting for Microsoft to raise the offer? Or do they have other options? Rock would hide his options from Doris as he tries to woo her in much the same way -- amid plenty of public scrutiny. We must remember one key plot point in all those old movies: The happy couple always winds up together in the end.
All this corporate romancing, with News Corp. now courting Yahoo as well, has filled my head with visions of future possibilities. What would I do if I were the king of a combined Yahoo-Microsoft empire?
First, I'd probably consider what the brands mean to the world. Microsoft is the software brand, and Yahoo is the Internet brand. That would prompt me to get rid of those other names, such as MSN and Live. Let the Yahoo brand live on as a continued Internet brand covering all the Microsoft online properties and advertising, with perhaps the only sign of the parent being "A Microsoft Company" at the bottom of key pages. The Microsoft brand would continue to be the brand for desktop software. I wouldn't want to buy a product called Yahoo PowerPoint. Would you?
Then I'd get rid of that exclamation point on the end of the Yahoo! name. It might look good on the logo, but it sets off my grammar checker every time I mention the company in one of my columns. Sure, I can add it to my dictionary, but I shouldn't have to. The "Bang" (that's what programmers call exclamation points) serves no useful purpose. Most people are smart enough to recognize the Yahoo brand, even without a bang.
With those two moves, I've accomplished the first goal -- of alienating executives and staff members at both companies. Now, it's time to work on the so-called "synergy" -- the part that marketers describe as adding one plus one to make three. It's not only mathematically incorrect; it's counterintuitive for this acquisition -- because synergy will undoubtedly be accomplished through layoffs. Thus, it would really be 1+1 = 1.5. Yahoo! (the original company with the bang) has already announced substantial work force reductions without Microsoft's help; so 1+1 = 1.25 may be even more accurate.
The combined company will have plenty of products and people to make the merged company proud. From the Windows and Office semimonopolies, to the second largest Internet advertising company, to lots of great core technologies. The challenge will be combining them to save money and create megabrands. Some combinations are natural. A combined Yahoo! Mail and Hotmail would allow significant cost savings. But others will be harder to merge.
As leader, I would be tempted not to consolidate too quickly. I would follow the natural progression from one technology product generation into the next -- where the mergers of technology and product lines happen at generation turnovers instead of pushing them to happen at unnatural points in the product cycle. After all, with the cash hordes already in place, there will be plenty of cash to allow parallel work in product areas without becoming strapped -- creating a best-of-both-worlds scenario.
Enough daydreaming. Time to write my column.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.