QUESTION: My room is not suitable for hanging surround speakers for a 5.1 channel setup. I am considering a soundbar. How does it provide the surround effect? Can I just get five speakers and put the surround speakers in front of my TV next to the left/right/center speakers?

K.Y. CHENG

San Francisco

A. Not all soundbars are 5-channel capable. I'll discuss the different types available as well as make a few recommendations.

Advertise with us

A soundbar is a long, thin speaker that is placed under or above a television. These speakers are often used with a subwoofer, as the size and shape of a soundbar cabinet does not allow much bass to be produced. Some soundbars are complete, self-powered systems; others are simply speakers that connect to the terminals of an audio/video receiver.

Given the poor sound quality of a typical flat panel TV, the improvement in sound quality and clarity can be quite dramatic, even when using a very inexpensive soundbar. You will hear fuller, more natural sound, clearer dialogue and room-filling volumes more easily.

Two-channel soundbars use electronic signal processing to create surround effects using only the left and right stereo channels. Your TV may have this signal processing available in the audio menus. If you turn it on, you can enjoy more spacious sound without connecting an external system. Look in the television's audio menus for settings like SRS, VSS or Virtual Surround.

Though you may hear a more spacious sound in your room with this kind of soundbar, you won't be hearing every bit of detail in the soundtrack as the rear surround channels contain unique sonic information. If this is what you want, the Vizio VSB200 is well regarded and sells for less than $100 without a subwoofer. Spending $199 gets you the Panasonic SC-HTB10, which integrates well with Panasonic TVs, and the top-rated Sony HT-CT150 sells for less than $300 including subwoofer.

The best soundbars are called surroundbars because they have speaker drivers for each of the five channels. The best are unpowered speakers that are driven by the speaker terminals of an audio/video receiver. Circuitry in the surroundbar, often in conjunction with additional drivers in the cabinet, work to creates a cancellation effect similar to that used in noise-canceling headphones. It affects the sound that actually reaches your ears, creating a soundfield that is enveloping and spacious. You won't hear sound behind you, but you will hear everything the director intended you to hear, and it will sound much more satisfying than mere stereo.

Advertise with us

A great self-powered unit is the Polk Audio SurroundBar 6000 IHT (Instant Home Theater) for $499 including powered wireless subwoofer. If you want the ultimate in good sound from a single speaker setup, check out the Definitive Technology Mythos SSA-42 or SSA-50 surroundbar speakers. They start at $799, and you must use them with an A/V receiver and a subwoofer. This makes it expensive compared with the others mentioned here, but the best rarely comes cheap.

Because surround speakers lack the circuitry or additional drivers of a surroundbar, placing them next to the left/center/right speakers as you suggested won't work. The sound field they will create could potentially be confusing.