Q: I recently went to a big chain store in search of a 42-inch TV selling for under $1,000. They really talked down plasma and pushed LEDs. I'm sure there are a variety of reasons, least of which is customer satisfaction (sorry for the sarcasm.)
While admitting superior picture for the plasmas, they noted weight, electricity use, potential burn-in, more reflective screen and potential gas leakage as the downsides. I really only saw the reflective screen as something of a concern, but this set won't get a lot of daytime viewing, so I'm not sure that really matters a lot. What are your thoughts?
PHIL SCHMELTZER
Pittsburgh
A. Ah, 'tis the season for misinformed, unknowledgeable big-box store salespeople to spread falsehoods about plasma TVs. Modern plasmas are almost impossible to burn in, and each individual pixel is a sealed cell with gas in it, and the gas doesn't leak out. Modern plasmas have energy usage very close to LCD sets, and even when they consume more power, the difference is minute. I wrote last year that the difference between the most power-hungry, 60-inch plasma and the most efficient, 32-inch LCD set was only a few dollars a month in additional electricity. Among same-size sets it would be much less than that.
Consumer Reports just published test results of the best 3-D sets on the market, and plasma was a clear winner. Plasma is still my favorite flat panel TV technology and the choice of videophiles, and at current prices is a tremendous bargain. In fact, profit margin may be one reason the stores are pushing LED-LCD sets so hard. (Please note what are touted as "LED" TVs are actually LCD TVs with an LED backlight, not TVs that use LEDs to create the image.)
Current plasma standouts in the $1,000 price range are the 42-inch Panasonic TC-P42G25, which sells for well under $1,000, and the 50-inch Samsung PN50C550, which sells for a bit more given its size.
Though the store employees themselves acknowledge the superior picture quality of plasma, it is still subjective; and some people may prefer the bright, punchy look of an LED-LCD set. One of my very favorite televisions at the moment is an LED-LCD HDTV that sells for less than $1,000. The 1080p 42-inch Panasonic TC-L42D2 lists for $1,299 but currently sells for between $849 and $899.
What I like about the TC-L42D2 is that it combines the best qualities of plasma TVs and LED-LCD TVs. It has the natural look and flesh tones of plasma combined the hypersharpness and bright, deep color of an LED-LCD set. To achieve this picture quality all I had to do is set the television on the Standard picture setting and the color temperature to warm. Motion rendition was very good as well and it had none of the slightly unnatural look I see in many flat panel LCD sets with strong motion processing.
The TC-L42D2 is a model I would strongly consider for myself vs. comparably sized plasma sets and is well worth checking out for shoppers for a sub-$1,000 television. I'm picky, so if I like it, I am betting you will, too. Be sure to adjust the picture settings for best results.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.