Question I am thinking of buying either Ohm Walsh 2000 or Walsh 3000 speakers, and I was hoping you could offer some advice. Given your experience with the Ohm Walsh speakers, would you go with the Walsh 3000 and skimp on the electronics by pairing them with an NAD 375BEE integrated amplifier, or go with the 2000s and get the NAD M3 amplifier, which has much better specifications, greater power and remote control features?

-- RANDY GRINC

Answer This is an easy one. I'd get the better speakers and the less expensive electronics, especially since you are getting an NAD amplifier, a top quality amplifier brand to begin with. Sonic differences between amplifiers are very small compared with the difference in sound between different speakers, even when comparing models within a speaker manufacturer's model line.

Whether building a sound system for surround or stereo, the speakers are always the first consideration. They convert electrical energy into sonic energy, which is far more difficult than creating or modifying an electrical signal. You will hit diminishing returns on amplifiers far, far sooner than you will on speakers. For the best results, allocate as much as your budget as you can toward the speakers, while matching them with an amplifier that will power them easily while suiting your needs and tastes. For example, if I had $1,000 to spend on stereo speakers and an amplifier, I would try and allocate $700 for the speakers and $300 for the amplifier. If I were spending $2,000, I would look to spend $1,500 on speakers and $500 on the amplifier. Surround-sound systems change the equation somewhat. But in short, the speakers are the No. 1 priority, and you should get the best that you can.

Advertise with us

I consult and recommend products and systems to people every day. And though following this formula has always worked to great success, there are some exceptions.

For example, I received an e-mail from a reader who had a huge digital music collection and an interest in owning a tube amplifier, for both the warm sound and the pride of owning something special and different. He ended up with a $799 Neuhaus Laboratories T-2 tube amplifier with USB connection and a pair of $499 Arx A3 tower speakers.

This setup made sense to both of us since he was able to achieve the goal of owning a tube amplifier, notably an amplifier designed to bring out the best in his large collection of digital music files and which pairs well with the Arx A3 speakers. The Arx A3 uses technology that mates well with tube amplification, and they sound much better than their $499 price would suggest. So in this instance spending more on the amplifier than the speakers made sense and led to a happy reader.

You may find it relevant that I drive all of my own Ohm Walsh speakers with NAD amplifiers. One of the pairings is a top-of-the-line pair of Walsh 5000s connected to an NAD 2200PE amplifier that is more than 20 years old. In the audiophile pecking order, my old amplifier corresponds much more closely to the 375BEE than the M3, so I am certain you will be very happy with the Walsh 3000/375BEE combination.