Question: Before going on an African safari, my wife and I each bought cameras.
Hers is a Canon digital SLR with an extra telephoto lens, plus a case for all the accessories for a bit under $1,500. The camera with lens weighs 5 to 7 pounds.
Mine is a Panasonic Lumix point-and-shoot with 12x zoom and 12 megapixels. It also shoots video and weighs maybe half a pound. It has a case that fits quite nicely on my belt, all for $250.
Looking at our pictures, I'm coming to the conclusion that cameras like my wife's Canon will soon be the dinosaurs of the photography industry. Yes, her photos are a bit sharper than mine when zoomed more than 16x or 32x, but not much sharper. I now see 14 megapixel & 14x zoom point-and-shoot cameras on the market. Before very long, the point-and-shoot cameras will have 20 megapixels and 20x zooms and more.
I think in the days to come the big SLRs will be only for very dedicated people who like using all the esoteric options available. But for the vast majority, maybe 95 to 99 percent of the market, a better point-and-shoot camera will be the answer.
I'd appreciate hearing your opinion on this.
JOHN GRIFFIN, Alamo, Calif.
Answer: I don't agree with your conclusion, though I have no doubt your pictures were nearly as good as hers in this application. Comparing the two types of cameras in one particular shooting situation does not do enough to show all the important differences.
An African safari with bright light is exactly the kind of situation where the differences between the cameras would be minimized. Use the cameras over a wide range of subjects and shooting conditions over the course of a year and the SLR's superiority will be readily apparent.
Though they may have lots of pixels, the sensors used in point-and-shoot cameras are very small. These small sensors perform poorly in low light and are no competition for a digital SLR or interchangeable lens camera, which have sensors with many times the physical area. Not only do you get better low-light performance, larger sensors always capture a wider range of tones from delicate detail in white highlights to nuances in shadow detail.
On shooting speed, namely quick focusing and immediate shutter release. In this competition the point-and-shoot is the dinosaur, and not a fast-moving velociraptor at that, but a slow, lumbering brachiosaurus. One of the biggest complaints I get about digital cameras is the seeming disconnect between pushing the button and the picture actually being taken. Using digital SLRs or interchangeable lens cameras could be the difference between that magic moment or missing it.
I have not even touched on the big, bright optical viewfinder of an SLR, the interchangeable lenses or the ability to use external flashes for much better flash pictures. I could rattle off even more differences, but not without making the column much longer than my editors would like.
Point-and-shoots have their place and are indeed adequate for most people. I am glad you have had such success with yours, but the best image quality and the best photographic experience still comes from large-sensor digital SLRs and interchangeable lens cameras.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.