Q: I asked your advice several years ago and you suggested I get a Canon 70-200mm EF L lens. It takes very sharp pictures and I am extremely happy with it. I am now contemplating a Canon 100-400mm EF L IS lens.

Looking at user reviews, I find very few pros happy with the sharpness. Would I be better off getting a 1.4x extender for my 70-200mm and would the sharpness be equal to that of the 100-400mm? Would a Canon L 400mm or 500mm prime lens be a better choice for tack sharpness?

G.L.

Eagan, Minn.

Advertise with us

A Before I make my suggestion, I will explain the differences between zoom and prime lenses. Zooms have become so prevalent that many consumers are unaware of prime lenses and the advantages they offer.

A zoom lens has a variable focal length, such as the 100mm-400mm lens you are considering. The focal length, and hence the magnification, can be set anywhere between 100mm and 400mm. With most zooms, the f-stop changes as you zoom the lens. For example, the Canon 18-55mm IS lens commonly shipped with their cameras changes from f/3.5 at 18mm to f/5.6 at 55mm.

Prime lenses have fixed focal lengths such as 50mm, 70mm or 200mm. Primes are smaller, lighter in weight and are usually better constructed than comparably priced zooms. Not only do prime lenses almost always deliver noticeably superior optical quality, they tend to have wider (lower numerical value) f-stops. Wider f-stops provide a brighter viewfinder, better low-light performance and allow use of higher shutter speeds.

Since you are looking for tack sharpness, I recommend getting the 400mm or 500mm Canon L prime lens. That said, the Canon 1.4x extender does a pretty nice job on the Canon 70-200. L lens. Please note this extender only gets you out to 300mm, not 400mm and that good technique and using a tripod and monopod is extremely important at such high magnifications.

I absolutely love prime lenses. I currently have a bagful of Pentax Limited primes, and Pentax's wide variety of excellent prime lenses is a big reason myself and others use the system. There is a purity and art to taking pictures with a prime lens. You use your feet to move back and forth to frame the image and generally take more time composing, which leads to better images.

Advertise with us

With zooms and automatic exposure, it is often too easy to just zoom and press the button without giving it much thought or effort. For a 10-plus year stint as a professional photographer, I did not even own a zoom lens and was able to complete 100 percent of my assignments using only prime lenses. Zooms are nice and I have quite a few of them, but primes are my first love.

If you do not have a prime lens in your bag, you really should try one. The ultra-sharpness and bright viewfinder will astound you.

Canon and Nikon's 50mm f/1.8 lenses sell for around $100 and are great for portraits and general use. Pentax users have a wide variety of choices, and Micro Four-Thirds users should check out Panasonic's 20mm f/1.7, which is a bit pricey at $330 but is a spectacular performer. Sony has a $150 50mm 1.8 and many used Minolta lenses will work as well.