Q: You recently wrote that 3-D TVs would cost no more than 30 percent more than comparable models from last year. The new1080p 3-D 50-inch Panasonic sells for well over $2,000, and I saw 2-D 1080p 50-inchers selling for around $1,000 around the holidays. Were you simply wrong, or have the manufacturers jacked up prices for 3-D?

THADDEUS MARK

St. Louis

A: The recently introduced 50-inch Panasonic plasma 3-D HDTV is from Panasonic's up-market V-series line, not the lower priced U-series, S-series, and G-series lines you usually see at big-box stores. Last year's V-series model, the TC-P50V10, had an MSRP of $2,299. The new 3-D model, the TC-P50VT20, has an MSRP of $2,499, a price increase of less than 10 percent. Not even taking a year's worth of inflation into account, the superior image quality of the TC-P50VT20 plus the 3-D capability represents good value for the additional cost.

Advertise with us

Lower priced models have been announced. In May you will be able to buy the Samsung LN46C750, a 46-inch 3-D LCD TV, for $1,699. As smaller screen sizes are introduced and more manufacturers release products, compete prices will drop lower still, especially when discounted at retail. Nevertheless, 3-D TV is a premium product, and if you want it you should expect to pay more for it under any circumstances.

Lately I've had an inbox overflowing with 3-D TV questions, so I am going to comment one more time before moving on to other topics for a while. The reader in the most recent question worried about his new TV being "obsolete a month after I set it up." If he buys a non-3-D model now, in a year or two when 3-D is much more prevalent and he sees 3-D demos in stores, more 3-D movies in theaters and 3-D Blu-rays on the shelves, all at lower prices, he is likely to be bummed he didn't get a 3-D set to begin with, especially if he is a home theater enthusiast. In his case it may be worth spending the premium now to get a 3-D-capable set so he can enjoy 3-D content in the future without having to buy a new television. If you aren't an enthusiast, lacking 3-D probably won't bother you as much.

A friend and colleague has aptly pointed out that though the 3D capability is there, there isn't much to watch yet. Several cable networks have announced 3-D channels and CBS will be broadcasting the Final Four in 3-D this year; but it could be a year or two before there is an appreciable amount of 3-D content available. Even the upcoming "Avatar" Blu-ray won't be a 3-D Blu-ray initially, which surprised many of us in the industry since "Avatar" did a lot to put 3-D into consumer consciousness.

Don't forget the expense of the glasses. At $149 per set they are about $50 more than I anticipated they would be. If you have a family of five you need to spend an additional $750 for the whole family to watch a 3-D movie together. Ouch. Of course, prices on these will go down, just like they will with the TVs.

To sum it up: if you do not need a TV immediately, you may want to wait a bit. Prices will go down, and 3-D content will go up.