U.S. Steel is suing Algoma Steel, a top Canadian producer, over a planned shipment of iron pellets that the northern company allegedly no longer wants.
Based in Ontario, Algoma is one of the largest Canadian steel companies by revenue, but its stock has plummeted since President Donald Trump took office, falling from $10 a share to below $4, as tariffs on Canadian imports have hurt revenue.
The decline was so sudden and severe that Canada’s government is now offering Algoma a $400 million loan to “continue operations, transition to a business model less reliant on the United States, and limit disruption to its workforce.” The Government of Ontario is providing an additional $100 million.
Tariffs have “effectively closed the U.S. market to Canadian steel,” Algoma said in a news release, outlining plans to shutter its blast furnaces and coke ovens in favor of electric arc steelmaking.
U.S. Steel had been on a similar trajectory, though the recent acquisition by Japan’s Nippon Steel, which promised to invest heavily in Pennsylvania’s blast furnaces, complicates those plans. Electric arc furnaces are more efficient and rely primarily on recycled scrap steel rather than iron ore.
Algoma agreed to buy “millions of tons” of iron ore pellets from U.S. Steel in May 2020, but now has “buyer’s remorse and wants out of the deal,” according to a lawsuit filed by U.S. Steel on Monday in Federal Court in Pittsburgh.
In a statement to the Post-Gazette, U.S. Steel said: “A contract is a contract, and we expect Algoma Steel to live up to its commitments as have we.”
A lawyer for Algoma did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
U.S. Steel makes iron ore at two facilities in Minnesota using taconite rock from the Minnesota Iron Range. The pellets are then shipped to mills in Western Pennsylvania and sold to other companies.
Algoma refused the latest shipment of pellets and told U. S. Steel that it will not accept any additional orders, according to the lawsuit, breaching a contract that runs through January 2027.
“A deal is a deal,” the lawsuit states. “Algoma owes U. S. Steel over $22 million for past (accepted) pellet shipments.”
“U.S. Steel’s lost profits due to Algoma’s repudiation will be in the tens of millions of dollars, and could approach one hundred million dollars based on market conditions.”
U.S. Steel also alleges that Algoma does not want to arbitrate the issue in Pittsburgh, as the contract requires, and instead plans to file their own suit in a Canadian court.
Algoma hopes a judge will rule the contract “is no longer binding and enforceable and the parties’ obligations under the [contract] are at an end,” according to U.S. Steel’s lawsuit. It’s not entirely clear what reasoning the company will give for that argument.
U.S. Steel is hoping to force arbitration, but if that fails, they are asking the court to at least find that the contract is still binding and enforceable.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.