David Burritt, the CEO of U.S. Steel, celebrated the closing of Nippon Steel Corp.’s $14.9 billion acquisition of the Pittsburgh steelmaker by cashing out all the stock he’d accumulated during his 12 years at the company.

It worked out to $108.8 million.

That doesn’t include the $13 million in cash he is entitled to receive if, at some point in the next two years, he’s no longer chief executive officer. Although he hasn’t been publicly dismissed, it’s likely that the 70-year-old executive will not be the new face of the new company.

Mr. Burritt’s payday was the largest of the corporate executives at U.S. Steel — as would be expected.

Advertise with us

Chief Financial Officer Jessica Graziano, who was two months shy of celebrating her three-year anniversary at U.S. Steel, traded her shares for $20 million.

Scott Buckiso, who started at U.S. Steel’s Irvin plant as a management associate in 1990 and finished as the company’s chief manufacturing officer, cashed out at $19.6 million.

Duane D. Holloway, general counsel, took home $18.5 million after seven years with the company. James Bruno’s decade at U.S. Steel yielded a $16.1 million final payout for the senior vice president of business development.

“To normal people, that’s a hell of a lot of money,” said Steven Balsam, who chairs the accounting department at the Fox School of Business at Temple University. “But when you talk about executives from publicly traded companies — not so much.”

Relative to the contract of Juan Soto — the Major League Baseball outfielder who last year signed a 15-year, $765 million deal with the New York Mets — “These numbers are relatively reasonable,” Mr. Balsam said.

Advertise with us

‘In the best interest of shareholders?’

The two companies on Wednesday announced that they’d finalized the $14.9 billion sale — first agreed on in December 2023 — and that Nippon had assumed control.

The deal delivers $55 per share to current U.S. Steel shareholders. The company’s stock stopped trading on Wednesday and is being delisted from the New York Stock Exchange. Share prices in U.S. Steel fell from an all-time peak of $172 in 2008 to as low as $7.50 in 2015; shares were trading as low as $30 at the beginning of the year.

Such payouts come with the entire structure of executive compensation, thanks to the era of the hostile takeover in the 1980s.

For most of the past century, Mr. Balsam said, “managers had the incentive to resist takeovers because they didn’t want to lose their jobs” — and their paychecks.

But that could put executives at odds with the best interests of shareholders, who might stand to gain on a sale of their shares.

Advertise with us

So companies came up with ways to remove the conflict by setting up “change-in-control” plans that paid out cash and accelerated the vesting of previously granted shares in the event of a merger or sale.

Beginning in late 2006, public companies were required to disclose how much executives stood to make in a change-in-control and subsequent termination scenario.

“Once companies start disclosing these things, it leads to other companies adopting that,” Mr. Balsam said.

Today’s change-in-control payouts are so hefty that some observers — see the letter that U.S. Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., and former Sen. Sherrod Brown, D-Ohio, sent to Mr. Burritt in 2024 — suggest the pendulum has swung too far.

The politicians and the United Steelworkers union which represents about 11,000 workers at U.S. Steel and opposed its sale to Nippon, were responding to a March 2024 merger proxy filed by the company. It revealed how much named executives stood to gain if the merger went through at the $55 per share price.

Advertise with us

Mr. Burritt’s total was around $72 million in cash, stock and benefits. The stock would be vested at the time of the merger’s closing, the cash disbursed after termination.

‘What everyone else gets’

U.S. Steel’s merger proxy contained the following caution to shareholders who were scheduled to vote on the sale to Nippon:

“USS stockholders should be aware that the executive officers and directors of USS have certain interests in the transactions that are or may be different from, or in addition to, the interests of USS stockholders generally.”

Those interests tend to amount to large payouts. But not in the way many people think.

For one, changes in control agreements — how much stock and cash are involved — are often negotiated when an executive assumes the rank that qualifies for such protection. This could be years ahead of any potential event.

Advertise with us

“These things were put together long ago, when people came to the company; they’re contractual,” said Charles Elson, who was a founding director of the John Weinberg Center for Corporate Governance at the University of Delaware.

Mr. Elson said he’s personally never liked the idea “because I didn’t think you should pay someone to exercise their fiduciary duty. But that is totally standard.”

According to a five-year-old study done by corporate compensation consulting firm Alvarez & Marsal, the average change in control payment to a CEO stood around $28 million.

Two thirds of that comes in the form accelerating vesting of equity awards, the study, which examined the compensation packages of 200 public companies, found.

These benefits are available not just to CEOs and CFOs, but to named and unnamed executives at the company.

Advertise with us

Like other aspects of executive compensation, these incentives are based on what other companies are willing to offer.

It’s a competition among peers, and it has driven up how much public company executives get paid across all industries.

“It all relates to what everyone else gets,” he said.