After years of disappointment, U.S. Steel shareholders are finally getting a payday — but only if they’ve hung onto the stock this long.

Nippon Steel — with President Donald Trump’s apparent greenlighting of the long-proposed $14.9 billion deal — is set to acquire the iconic Downtown-based steelmaker and pay out $55 in cash per share to investors when the deal closes.

But the stock has performed so poorly in the past decade that many long-term investors have already bailed out, according to Pittsburgh-area investment advisers.

Share prices fell from an all-time peak of $172 in 2008 to as low as $7.50 in 2015.

Advertise with us

As a result, the number of clients still holding United States Steel Corp. stock in their investment portfolios is much lower than it used to be, said Aaron Leaman, chief Investment officer at Signature Wealth, Downtown.

“We do have a decent handful of clients holding [ticker symbol] X stock — most of whom are former employees or people who otherwise did business with the company back in the day,” Mr. Leaman said.

However, he added, “the stock’s performance over the last decade or so has led most people who don’t have a sentimental connection to the company to sell. At this point, we don’t have any clients who are holding it because they think it’s actually a good stock.”

U.S. Steel shares were trading as low as $30 at the beginning of the year. The stock recently shot up to around $53 with the Nippon deal on the horizon.

The deal — which includes up to $14 billion in additional investments to existing U.S. Steel faculties — will keep U.S. Steel in America and its headquarters in Pittsburgh, according to descriptions from the companies and politicians who back the deal.

Advertise with us

The Japanese steelmaker’s plan to buy all outstanding X shares and take the company private will require all current U.S. Steel shareholders to liquidate their shares when the deal closes, since the historic Pittsburgh steelmaker would be delisted from the New York Stock Exchange.

“Anyone holding X shares will go to bed the night before the closing with shares in their account, and they will wake up in the morning with the shares gone and the cash there instead,” Mr. Leaman said.

Founded in 1901, U.S. Steel was once the world’s most valuable company, becoming the first billion-dollar corporation. The company earned an iconic status due to its pivotal role in shaping the nation’s industrial landscape. U.S. Steel’s products and workforce literally built America, producing about two-thirds of the nation’s steel in its first full year.

With U.S. Steel shares currently around $53 per share, some investment experts say — why wait for the deal to close? Why not cash in now and skip all the drama?

“I’d be a seller — of as much as half or more — if I owned it,” said David Root Jr., CEO of DBR & Co., Downtown. “I’d advise my clients who own it not to be greedy. The market is doing your heavy lifting.”

Advertise with us

There’s not much upside left in the stock.

The downside risk prior to the deal closing is bigger, said Michael Godwin, chief investment officer at Fragasso Financial Advisors in Sewickley.

“Betting on corporate deals is a risky activity, even for professionals,” Mr. Godwin said.

No corporate deal is risk-free.

And this one also comes with federal fingerprints.

Advertise with us

There’s even talk of issuing the U.S. government a “golden share” to keep a grip on the steelmaker’s future, per statements made by Pennsylvania Sen. Dave McCormick last week.

“A sticking point had been foreign control of a strategically and economically important company. But it now seems an arrangement will be made to ensure the U.S. government has a role in governing the company going forward,” Mr. Godwin said.

Another risk is that the deal might not go through — which would likely cause the share price to tank overnight.

Mr. Root noted that an activist hedge fund — Ancora Holdings Group — launched a proxy battle earlier this year aiming to block the Nippon Steel merger, replace CEO David Burritt, and pursue its own turnaround strategy for U.S. Steel.

At one point, Ancora claimed it could deliver $75 per share, according to Bloomberg Law News. However, the hedge fund ultimately suspended its campaign and stated it would not oppose the $55-per-share deal with Nippon.

Advertise with us

“Shareholders should absolutely sell now,” Mr. Leaman said, especially “if they can get a better price than $55 per share. Or, if they don’t think the deal will actually happen.

“If this does fall through, the stock will drop even more, as it’s only at $53 right now because people expect to get $55 when the deal closes.

“If the deal doesn’t close, the stock will fall from here, meaning selling at these current prices would have been the right move,“ Mr. Leaman said.