Cleveland-Cliffs posted another quarter of losses as the Ohio steelmaker continues to eye a takeover of U.S. Steel.
Cliffs reported a net loss of $434 million in the final three months of 2024, compared to a loss of $139 million for the same period in 2023. Overall revenue for the year was down to $19.2 billion from $22.0 billion the year prior.
That’s still a far cry from where the company was just a few years ago: in 2019, prior to its acquisitions of AK Steel and ArcelorMittal USA, Cliffs remained mostly an iron ore supplier and revenue was just $2 billion.
CEO Lourenco Goncalves blamed the performance — which was slightly below Wall Street estimates — on lower steel prices, calling 2024 the worst demand environment since 2010, excluding the pandemic. He said Trump administration shifts would raise prices and trigger a rebound this year.
“Since Jan. 20, President Trump has made clear that proper enforcement of our trade laws and a supportive industrial policy prioritizing manufacturing in the United States are both being implemented,” Mr. Goncalves said. “That should benefit Cleveland-Cliffs more than others.”
The CEO said Cliffs remains committed to fixing up steel mills in Butler, Pa., and Middletown, Ohio — which both benefitted from Department of Energy grants under the Biden administration — as well as converting a tinplate mill in Weirton, W.Va., into the company’s first transformer factory. The company set aside $700 million for capital expenditures in 2025, including those projects and improvements at Stelco, the Canadian steelmaker Cliffs acquired last summer.
Read More
U.S. Steel has not held quarterly earnings calls since December 2023, when it penned a potential merger with Japan’s Nippon Steel, which was then blocked by former President Joe Biden and has now triggered court cases in Washington, D.C. and Pittsburgh.
Still, earnings reports show U.S. Steel also saw a loss at the end of 2024, to the tune of $89 million. Overall revenue for the year was down to $15.6 billion from $18.1 billion in 2023.
One of the latest filings in the Pittsburgh case, which accused Cliffs and the head of the United Steelworkers union of conspiring to thwart the deal with Nippon, showed a call between Mr. Goncalves and one of U.S. Steel’s top shareholders. On the March 15 call, the steel CEO suggested splitting ownership of U.S. Steel’s assets between Japan and Cleveland.
“I was under the impression that Nippon Steel would listen to me and come to me and negotiate a deal. But they didn’t come,” Mr. Goncalves said.
In January, shortly after Mr. Biden blocked the sale to Japan, Mr. Goncalves said he was still interested in buying U.S. Steel, even promising to move Cleveland-Cliffs operations and his own office to Pittsburgh. He walked back those statements this month, after they had raised tensions in the town synonymous with Cleveland-Cliffs since 1847.
“I will have an office there but my main office will be here at 200 Public Square, Cleveland,” he told the Cleveland ABC affiliate this week.
On Tuesday, the United Steelworkers union said it filed charges with the National Labor Relations Board accusing U.S. Steel of a “months-long campaign to intimidate workers” to win support for the deal with Nippon. The case did not immediately appear on the NLRB website.
U.S. Steel said in response to the filing that it “prioritized keeping U. S. Steel employees informed about the transaction.”
“We engage employees in all business matters, making sure their questions are answered and that they have access to information. We have conducted ourselves with integrity and remain confident that the transaction is the best path forward to secure the future of U. S. Steel.”
U.S. Steel meanwhile remains engaged in a proxy battle with Ancora Holdings, a Cleveland-based activist investor that wants to topple the board and instate its own chief executive. USW chief David McCall told Bloomberg on Tuesday that he supported Ancora’s CEO pick, Alan Kestenbaum, who previously led Stelco.
U.S. Steel and Nippon have not wavered from their plan to finalize the $14.9 billion transaction first agreed to in 2023, despite renewed opposition from President Donald Trump, who said he would renegotiate the sale as an investment.
Nippon Steel President Tadashi Imai said Tuesday at a news conference with Japan’s prime minister that the merger remained “the starting point for our discussions with the U.S. government,” according to Bloomberg.
“From there, we will discuss with the U.S. administration on how we can get President Trump to approve of the deal,” he said in Tokyo.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.