Former President Joe Biden made a predetermined decision to block the sale of U.S. Steel to Japan’s Nippon Steel in January, leading to a “sham” review of the transaction by national security regulators, the two companies argued in a Monday court filing.

The steelmakers are hoping to win a fresh review of the $14.9 billion deal under President Donald Trump’s new administration, despite Trump’s own opposition to Japanese ownership of the iconic Pittsburgh company. Trump has argued that tariffs, like those issued over the weekend, are enough to make U.S. Steel “great again.”

“President Biden made and announced his decision before the statutorily mandated national security review began,” the Monday filing states. “The record makes clear that President Biden’s decision was driven by election-year politics, not national security — in particular his effort to gain a critical labor union’s support for his reelection campaign in the battleground state of Pennsylvania.”

The government has until March 17 to respond to the opening brief, which was filed in the District of Columbia Court of Appeals. Because presidential orders are not subject to judicial review, the companies are arguing that the process that led to Mr. Biden’s decision was corrupted by politics.

Advertise with us

That review was overseen by an interagency panel known as the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States, or CFIUS, which vets deals for national security threats.

The panel’s decisions are almost always final, but there was one meaningful precedent in 2014, when a court ruled that an American wind farm company with ties to China had been denied due process to engage with the government before its investment was voided by President Obama. That case resulted in a settlement with the government and the company was forced to sell its development rights.

People familiar with U.S. Steel’s legal strategy said the company would not settle unless it could revive the deal with Nippon. A separate but related effort is underway to convince Trump to rescind Mr. Biden’s decision.

The companies also sued rival steelmaker Cleveland-Cliffs and the head of the United Steelworkers union in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, claiming the two made an “unlawful agreement” to thwart the deal with Nippon.

The Monday filing included statements from a U.S. Steel executive and a handful of trade experts who argued the regulatory review “diverged” from standard CFIUS obligations and practices.

Advertise with us

“The conduct of CFIUS’s review of Nippon Steel’s proposed acquisition of U.S. Steel is so far outside the standards of my experience with the mandatory or customary process that these deviations appear to have been motivated by interests other than national security,” wrote Rick Sofield, a partner at Debevoise & Plimpton and formerly the Justice Department’s CFIUS representative, who said he participated in 1,500 reviews in that role.

Kevin Lewis, U.S. Steel vice president of finance and strategy, who was directly involved in the CFIUS review, wrote that the panel “consistently refused to engage with us in substantive negotiations on terms to mitigate the purported national security risks CFIUS had identified.”

He said the companies pursued CFIUS approval through three cycles of review and investigation from March to December 2024.

“The alleged trade ‘risk’ identified by CFIUS and relied on by the President as a justification to block the transaction on national security grounds is contrary to facts, prejudicial, and dangerous,” wrote Christopher Padilla, a former IBM executive who led the Commerce Department’s International Trade Administration from 2007 to 2008.

Among other issues, the panel found that a foreign-owned U.S. Steel might file fewer petitions for import relief, threatening the president’s ability to impose tariffs and protect domestic production, Mr. Padilla noted. He called the risk “entirely speculative” and said Trump has demonstrated even within the past two weeks that “he believes he has the power to impose a wide range of new tariffs on all U.S. trade under a wide range of legal authorities, regardless of what one private company may or may not do.”