Nippon Steel vice chairman Takahiro Mori managed to meet with his most ardent opposition, union boss David McCall, during his most recent visit to Pittsburgh in a rare face-to-face that resulted in the Japanese steelmaker’s firmest commitments to date to preserve jobs and blast furnace operations in the Keystone State.

The promises, outlined in a Dec. 2 letter shared with the Post-Gazette, appeared to have no effect on Mr. McCall, president of the United Steelworkers union, who released a video statement the next day echoing his consistent denouncements of the $14.9 billion takeover by Nippon of Pittsburgh-based U.S. Steel Corp.

“To realize the growth of U.S. Steel, it is essential for NSC to maintain its blast furnace operations,” Mr. Mori wrote to the union, repeating a promise to invest $2.7 billion for capital expenditure at USW-represented facilities. The Japanese executive plans to return to the U.S. this week.

Nippon Steel has continued its campaign to win over union members and Pennsylvania politicians as the transaction originally agreed to in December 2023 approaches the end of a contentious regulatory review. President Joe Biden could make a decision by the end of the year, before the second term of President-elect Donald Trump, who has promised to kill the deal.

Advertise with us

“Following continued constructive dialogue with Pennsylvania Governor Shapiro and others about the long-term needs of these facilities, Nippon Steel was happy to provide more specifics around our commitments in writing,” the company said in a second letter shared with U.S. Steel employees on Monday.

The pledges include: $200 million in expected added capital investments on top of the $2.7 billion, a focus on increasing blast furnace efficiency, “furthering environmentally friendly operations,” and twice a year consulting meetings with the USW. Nippon expects to finish two large projects — a hot mill replacement at Irvin and improvements at Gary Works in Indiana — by 2030. It will also consider reactivating the Gary tinplate mill, which was idled in 2022.

Mr. McCall was not swayed.

"It's time for this deal to be rejected," he said again last week, citing what he called "dire national and economic risks."

Gov. Josh Shapiro declined to take a public stance on the deal during a Dec. 3 event in Pittsburgh — highlighting how politically thorny the transaction remains, even after the November election.

Advertise with us

In response to the letter, Shapiro spokesman Manuel Bonder said the governor “will continue to be actively engaged in this process, working to bring the best offers to the table and strongly advocating for the interests of Western Pennsylvania and the workers of the region to ensure the future of American steelmaking runs through Pennsylvania.”

Mr. Bonder added that “the final decision on this proposed deal will ultimately be made by the White House alone.”

Analysts said winning the labor vote will be crucial to clearing regulatory approval, especially if that decision ultimately falls to Mr. Biden, who maintains a close relationship with USW’s leader. So far, nothing has shifted Mr. McCall, who continues to favor a partnership with Ohio-based Cleveland-Cliffs — a proposal U.S. Steel rejected last fall because of monopoly concerns.

“It looks like Nippon put in writing everything that Mr. McCall wanted, [but] it might not matter,” said Jason Zugai, president of the USW local in West Mifflin.

Negotiators for Nippon have been trying to break through Mr. McCall’s intransigence by winning over local union leaders and elected officials throughout Western Pennsylvania. A delegation last week traveled to Washington to meet with lawmakers and speak to a think tank about the benefits of foreign investment.

Advertise with us

Some were originally concerned about Japanese ownership but came around once they heard Nippon’s proposed investments and saw how the company operates existing factories in Pennsylvania and West Virginia.

Richard Tikey, vice president of the USW local in Clairton, told the Post-Gazette: “I really don't want a Japanese company owning us, but if they're going to keep job security and capital investments then yes, that's the way to go.”

At least one worker was encouraged by the letter and meeting with Mr. McCall.

“Certainly a positive step in the right direction,” said Andy Macey, maintenance technician at U.S. Steel Clairton and a member of USW Local 1557. “The rank and file continue on to help in the sale of U.S. Steel to Nippon.”