An early bidder in the process that led Pittsburgh-based U.S. Steel to a planned takeover by Nippon Steel has settled charges with the Securities and Exchange Commission for announcing a false tender offer.

The SEC said Friday that rival bidder Esmark Inc. and its former CEO James P. Bouchard lacked the financial means to consummate the $35-per-share offer it made in August 2023.

That bid came days after an offer from Cleveland-Cliffs that kicked off a bidding war that resulted in the ultimate $14.9 billion takeover U.S. Steel agreed to with Japan’s Nippon Steel — a deal that has since drawn opposition from both presidential candidates and President Joe Biden.

Esmark’s offer would have required $7.8 billion in cash to complete, the SEC said. Mr. Bouchard, who founded the Sewickley-based metals company in 2003, appeared on a cable news program the next day after sending out a press release with the bid.

Advertise with us

He claimed on CNBC that Esmark had $10 billion available in cash committed to the deal and would not put up any of Esmark’s assets as collateral.

"Statements in the press release and interview were false," the SEC found, because Esmark did not have the necessary cash on hand. Esmark had less than 1% of the required $7.8 billion in cash to complete the tender offer, the agency found.

“Bouchard and Esmark could not have completed the tender offer for U.S. Steel that they announced,” Antonia M. Apps, director of the SEC’s New York regional office, said in a statement.

“Investors should be able to trust companies’ and executives’ public statements.”

Esmark and Mr. Bouchard violated Section 14(e) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, which prevents “unlawful tender offer practices” including fraudulent, deceptive or manipulative acts, the SEC said.

Advertise with us

The Securities and Exchange Commission did not say specifically how Esmark’s bid impacted the process that led to Nippon’s winning offer. Documents previously showed that the competitive process drove up the price that Nippon Steel and Cleveland-Cliffs were willing to pay.

Esmark rescinded its bid a week after making it, the Post-Gazette reported. Mr. Bouchard said at the time that he dropped the bid out of respect for the United Steelworkers union, which had thrown its support exclusively to Cleveland-Cliffs. Two months later, he announced his retirement.

Mr. Bouchard could not be reached for comment Friday and his phone number appeared to be disconnected.

Esmark and Mr. Bouchard settled with the SEC without admitting or denying the agency’s findings, the agency said.

As part of the settlement, Esmark must pay civil penalties of $500,000 and Mr. Bouchard must pay $100,000. Both agreed to “cease and desist from committing or causing any future violations of these provisions.”

U.S. Steel and Esmark declined to comment.