A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by Cranberry-based nuclear tech firm Westinghouse Electric Co. against two Korean state-owned companies vying for some of the same multibillion projects across the world.
Korea Electric Power Corp. and Korea Hydro & Nuclear Power Co. Ltd. had licensed Westinghouse technology and incorporated it into their own nuclear reactor designs, which the Korean entities are now selling to other countries and, in some cases, competing with Westinghouse on those bids.
Last October, after Westinghouse learned that Poland was on the verge of signing a contract with Kepco, the U.S. nuclear firm filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. Westinghouse said that the kind of plant Kepco offered to build in Poland, the APR1400, is based on technology that the Korean company licensed from Combustion Engineering, which Westinghouse acquired several decades ago. That means APR1400 is, in part, an American nuclear export that first requires approval from the U.S. Department of Energy before it can be shared with foreign nations.
Kepco is also bidding on projects in the Czech Republic, where it is also competing with Westinghouse on a tender, and in Saudi Arabia.
Westinghouse brought the lawsuit because it said it was worried it would be in violation of U.S. export controls if Kepco did not submit to Westinghouse all the information necessary to file for U.S. government approval. It asked the court to prevent Kepco from submitting anything about its reactor design to other countries — including pending bids — and to declare that the Korean company has an obligation under the U.S. export control regime. It would be the same procedure that Kepco and Westinghouse had cooperated on when Kepco got a contract to build those reactors in the United Arab Emirates in 2009, Westinghouse noted.
But the judge in the case ruled on Monday that it’s not Westinghouse’s responsibility to enforce export rules. That falls to the U.S. government. Therefore, Westinghouse has no “private right of action to sue.”
Westinghouse’s David Durham, president of energy systems, said in a statement that the issue is far from over.
The company plans to appeal the decision, he said, noting at the same time that it has “no bearing on the ongoing arbitration proceeding against KEPCO/KHNP involving KEPCO/KHNP’s non-allowed transfer of Westinghouse’s intellectual property outside Korea.”
The arbitration proceeding in Korea, before the Korean Commercial Arbitration Board, aims to establish whether the Korean reactor design has Westinghouse technology and if the Korean companies can export that design under the surviving rights of the licensing agreement that governed the technology transfer.
A final ruling in the arbitration proceeding is not expected until late 2025, Westinghouse said.
The issue is bigger than the billions of dollars at stake.
U.S. government officials have long relied on Westinghouse’s commercial interests to further diplomatic goals, such as extracting nuclear non-proliferation commitments from countries that buy nuclear reactors from Westinghouse or that include other American technology.
Kepco’s pursuit of contracts in Saudi Arabia would be a potential place to insert such leverage.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.