The brick skeleton and cascading pile of charred rubble that once was home to three generations of the White family in Clarksville is as haunting today as it was on Halloween 2018, when the Greene County house exploded from a natural gas leak.

It stands as a monument — and as evidence in a court case against the companies whose leaked gas might have caused the explosion — to the antiquated infrastructure that supports modern life and to how difficult it is to lay the blame on a single source of leaking gas when there are many.

More than four years after that explosion, the same forces that met in the soil beneath the Whites’ home still dot the foundation of southwestern Pennsylvania — leaky pipes and leaky wells, some known and documented for years, others undetected still.

On the morning of Oct. 31, 2018, as Cody White’s 4-year-old son used the bathroom and the boy’s mother, Samantha, rested in the bedroom after a night shift at work, Mr. White went to the kitchen to prepare breakfast. Just as he turned on the stove, he saw “a ball of flames and was blown backwards across the kitchen,” according to a lawsuit the family and a neighbor filed against Equitrans Corp., EQT Corp. and Peoples Natural Gas.

Advertise with us

Mr. White regained his composure and ran to rescue his family. His son was trapped beneath a collapsed wall and Ms. White had been struck by a falling door and other debris. Something had punctured her hand. Mr. White managed to get them both out of the house as it “burned to its foundation destroying each and every possession of the family … and killing the family’s dog, Levi.”

The boy suffered burns on 30% of his body, including his face, the complaint says. The burns, which hardened into scars, “serve as a daily reminder of his childhood trauma.” His parents have them, too.

When pipeline and environmental regulators arrived to sort out whose gas had leaked into the home, they encountered a maze of suspects from the region’s industrial past and present.

There was the abandoned Gateway Coal Mine and the Freeport Mine, which had an active permit but wasn’t being mined at the time. And the Pratt natural gas storage field, owned by Equitrans, stretched below the area with four storage wells within 2,500 feet of the Whites’ house.

Deeper still, seven EQT Corp. shale gas wells snaked below the property, drilled from a well pad 1,100 feet away. Pipelines that carry gas to and from the storage wells, and a Peoples Natural Gas gathering pipeline on its notoriously leaky Goodwin/Tombaugh system were also in the mix, as was a natural gas service line that served the White residence, and a farm tap line — all within half a mile of the explosion.

Advertise with us

Above the lattice of gas sources underground was a corporate labyrinth at the top.

Ben Goodwin, the Whites’ attorney, said the case he filed in Greene County Common Pleas Court is still in the early stages, with the plaintiffs trying to clarify which entities they’re suing. The explosion occurred just weeks before Equitrans split from its former parent, Downtown-based EQT, the largest natural gas producer in the country.

Until a decade ago, the Goodwin/Tombaugh pipeline system also belonged to EQT, which at the time had a natural gas utility company, Equitable Gas. Peoples Natural Gas bought Equitable and the troubled pipeline system in Greene County in 2013.

Officials at the state Department of Environmental Protection, which took the lead in the investigation, said this is one of the most vexing cases the agency has ever seen. The department produced its findings only last year and has not released them publicly, although they are now part of the Whites’ lawsuit.

Regulators did not find the culprit — but they did identify the two most likely suspects.

Advertise with us

It’s all Marcellus gas

Typically, gas migration investigations rely heavily on the distinct signature of the gas to pinpoint its source.

In this case, investigators took samples of each of the sources near the house and compared their carbon and hydrogen isotopes to the signature of the gas found at the site of the explosion. The coal mine gas didn’t match; it was quickly eliminated as the culprit.

But then things got muddled.

Shale gas now is everywhere — not just in the wells that produce it but in the gathering pipelines that collect it, the transmission lines that carry it, the storage fields that park it, and the distribution lines that take it to homes.

Advertise with us
The remains of a house that was involved in an explosion in 2018 are seen on March 1, 2023, in rural Clarksville, Pa. Investigations have identified a gas pipeline leak and storage well as the culprits of the blast. (Timothy Robbibaro / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The DEP was able to rule out EQT’s shale wells, finding them “genetically distinct” from the gas at the explosion site.

That left the storage wells and Peoples’ gathering pipeline. Both came with their own baggage.

Peoples’ Goodwin/Tombaugh pipeline system was in such bad shape that corporate executives said it was the main complication in the $4.3 billion acquisition of Peoples by Bryn Mawr-based Essential Utilities in 2020. It had been documented for years that less than half of the gas that went into the more than 300-mile-long pipeline system actually made it to customers.

At the explosion site, the Peoples pipeline was leaking in several places. There was gas in the soil about 500 feet from the White residence, and other leaks nearby on fittings that connected other customers to the Peoples line.

The company knew about these problems as early as 2014, but the leaks were characterized as non-hazardous. They were in a rural area with low pressure, so Peoples prioritized more immediate dangers elsewhere in its pipeline replacement program.

Advertise with us

The closest leaking section of Peoples’ pipeline failed a pressure test in the field and in a lab, but the engineering firm hired to test it concluded that even though the line was clearly leaking, it wasn’t leaking enough to cause the explosion.

Plus, Mr. White said he didn’t smell gas before turning on the stove. Peoples’ gas would have been odorized with mercaptan, as is all utility gas.

Still, DEP investigators noted that the concentration of gas in soil around the home and nearby residences dropped in the months after a chunk of pipeline was removed for testing.

A question of integrity

It took a lot longer for investigators to tease out Equitrans’ potential involvement.

Advertise with us

Equitrans didn’t take samples of its gas after the explosion. Instead, according to the DEP report, it sent an employee to walk the surface and look, smell, and listen for hissing gas.

The company did not deploy gas detectors or flow meters or any other equipment to characterize gas concentrations in soil at the time, the DEP report said.

A DEP inspection a week after the blast of the AH Hupp 3660 storage well, which sits just a few hundred feet from the Whites’ home, also found no issues.

“The storage well appears fully functional. No hydrocarbon at or around the wellhead and lines,” the inspector noted Nov. 5, 2018.

But in July 2020, DEP inspectors found gas leaking from the well. That month, Equitrans ran a test inside the AH Hupp 3660 well and detected 826 spots where the 5-inch diameter pipe was corroded. In eight of those instances, more than 80% of the metal was gone, which meant any amount of pressure could cause the pipe to leak or burst.

Advertise with us

The DEP didn’t know that yet.

And it wouldn’t learn until October 2020 — a full two years after the explosion — that in the days preceding the blast, Equitrans ran a three-day shut-in test, during which all wells in the storage field were pressurized for 72 hours to test how they would hold such pressure.

It was the same kind of shut-in period that preceded the record leak at a different Equitrans storage well in Cambria County in November 2022. In that case, 1.29 billion cubic feet of gas vented into the air during the two weeks it took to control the blowout. The case is still under investigation by the DEP and federal pipeline safety regulators.

In Greene County, the DEP asked Equitrans to perform a test on its AH Hupp well in which it would be filled with an inert gas to about the same pressure (800 pounds per square inch) as it was during the explosion. Falling pressure would indicate leaks.

At first, Equitrans wanted to do the test at only 12% of that pressure, according to the DEP. Ultimately, the company’s consultants said it would be unsafe to do so at more than 431 psi.

Advertise with us

The state agency concluded that “the well lacks mechanical integrity.”

Equitrans placed temporary plugs into the AH Hupp well in September 2020. Three months later, as part of the investigation, it took a sample of the gas that would have come out of the well. It was a close match to the gas found at the explosion site.

Preserving evidence

None of the companies involved nor the agencies investigating the explosion would talk about the case, citing pending litigation.

North Shore-based Peoples Natural Gas noted that it had already fixed or replaced 115 miles of the 309-mile Goodwin/Tombaugh pipeline system that stretches across Greene and Washington counties.

Advertise with us

The company declined to specify whether that included the area of the explosion site.

The state attorney general’s office, which sent its chief deputy attorney general and the section director of the environmental crimes unit to accompany DEP inspectors on visits to the Pratt storage field last fall, declined to comment.

Equitrans is in the middle of a mandated review of all of its nine storage fields in Pennsylvania following the Cambria County leak in November.

In 2021, it asked the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission for permission to permanently plug the AH Hupp 3660 well, citing its lack of integrity, but Peoples Natural Gas and the White family objected — arguing that would cover up potential evidence in the explosion case.

The federal agency was already familiar with problems at the Pratt storage field — it had investigated gas migration problems there more than a decade before the explosion. (FERC regulates interstate energy markets, and its oversight of storage field integrity is based on its concern for rates: If gas was leaking, Equitrans customers would pay the cost.)

Advertise with us

In 2007, FERC wrote that the Pratt storage field lost about 1.9 billion cubic feet of gas over its lifetime.

The remains of a house that was involved in an explosion in 2018 are seen on March 1, 2023, in rural Clarksville, Pa. Investigations have identified a gas pipeline leak and storage well as the culprits of the blast. (Timothy Robbibaro / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“Equitrans states, and (FERC) staff agrees, that various wells in the field have developed integrity problems which have resulted in significant vertical migration,” the agency report stated at the time.

Equitrans said it would plug or repair the casing and cement of any wells that were leaking outside the storage zone. The company declined to provide a list of work it had done on the wells since then. DEP records show a handful have been plugged or shut in.

Mallory Toulouse, a spokeswoman for Equitrans, stressed last week that “there have been no findings that Equitrans’ operation of the Hupp Well caused or contributed to the [White explosion]. Instead, the DEP found that it was unable to determine the cause of the incident.”

The DEP’s report from last year said the agency “was unable to conclusively determine a single source of the gas that caused the incident. However, it presented two likely candidates that could have been the source of the gas or the source of the conditions that allowed gas to migrate.”

Advertise with us

The agency also said, “The 72-hour storage field shut-in test concluded Oct. 30, 2018, could have increased the likelihood and magnitude of gas migration from the 3660 well due to its lack of mechanical integrity.”

DEP officials, including Kurt Klapkowski, acting deputy secretary for the department’s oil and gas program, said in an interview with the Post-Gazette in December that they were looking at the impact of such pressure tests — and the ramping of pressure up and down during injection and withdrawal from these storage wells — on the integrity of the wells, many of which were constructed between 50 and 100 years ago and were designed as production wells. The wells were later converted to storage after the gas they pulled from the ground ran dry.

Whether the pressure test was a factor in the case of the 2018 explosion remains unknown.

It might be up to the Greene County Common Pleas Court to solve the mystery.

The White family wants to rebuild on their land.

Advertise with us

But they can’t do so until the case is solved, Mr. Goodwin wrote in an appeal to federal regulators.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com