Utilities aren’t where you turn for cutting-edge stuff. So when they start signing long-term deals for solar power, and their regulators don’t just permit it but praise it, you know that solar energy is no longer cutting edge. It’s mainstream.
Duquesne Light and West Penn Power, the two main electric providers in southwestern Pennsylvania, say they want to incentivize the buildout of new solar projects in or near their distribution areas.
Signing long-term purchase agreements gives solar developers a guarantee that the energy they produce will have a steady customer and a steady revenue stream. They can take that to the bank, literally, and get the financing needed to build new projects. The recently-passed Inflation Reduction Act, which gives cash or tax credits to new solar projects, will help as well.
But climate intentions aside, the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission isn’t in the business of helping the environment to the detriment of consumers.
Approving these solar agreements means the PUC deemed them to be the “least cost over time” — a statutory standard for the power that utilities must procure for their customers. The utilities themselves aren’t allowed to own generation assets, like powerplants, and when they buy electricity from other suppliers, their costs are passed on dollar for dollar to the consumer.
“Solar, as this point, is the cheapest utility generation you can build,” said Matt Kozey, director of community-scale markets at Cypress Creek Renewables, a North Carolina-based solar developer with several projects under development in Pennsylvania.
Read More
Most long-term solar contracts in the state have come from corporations.
To be fair, the amount of energy that Duquesne Light and West Penn Power are buying from these projects is miniscule compared to their load.
Then again, until recently, there haven’t been many utility-scale solar projects to buy from.
“Today, there’s 220 megawatts of utility scale solar” in Pennsylvania, said Scott Elias, director of state affairs for the Mid-Atlantic region with the Solar Energy Industries Association. “The vast majority came online in 2020.”
For comparison, the Beaver Valley Nuclear plant has a capacity of about 1,700 megawatts.
But Mr. Elias believes it’s the steep slide in the cost of solar energy that has brought utilities to the table.
It’s not a boutique or values-driven purchase. It’s the economics driving the train.
A complicated market
Pennsylvania electricity customers can choose to buy their power through their utility or through a third-party company.
Most residents stick with the utility, which has to buy that power through a competitive procurement process, with contracts ranging from a few months to two years in length — predicting power prices much further into the future is considered too risky with natural gas, the fuel that dictates the price of electricity in the regional grid, being a volatile commodity.
So it was a significant departure for Downtown-based Duquesne Light to sign a 20-year contract for power from a yet-to-be-built solar farm in Armstrong County and for regulators to bless the move.
Duquesne Light got bids from 15 different solar projects. The longer the term of the contract, the lower the price for electricity, “possibly because longer contracts enable project developers to obtain lower-cost financing,” the utility wrote in a regulatory filing.
Duquesne eventually picked North Carolina-based Pine Gate Renewables, which is building a 10 megawatt solar farm. The utility signed up for 7 megawatts of that for the next 20 years.
“Our thought was we’d like to incentivize the construction of solar facilities in Pennsylvania,” said David Fisfis, vice president at Duquesne Light. “We can’t own and operate generation. (But) we’re in a situation where we can use our contractual buying power” to give solar developers an incentive to build it themselves.
Akron-based FirstEnergy Corp., which owns the West Penn Power and Penn Power utilities that serve this region, is now in the process of getting bids for up to 20 megawatts of “new or in-development” solar with contracts ranging between four and 10 years.
Todd Meyers, a spokesman for FirstEnergy, said the company was taking this step to “support new solar projects through long-term contracts, support FirstEnergy’s commitment to environmental sustainability” and to satisfy its statutory requirements to have a mix of different contracts in its supply.
Across the border in West Virginia, where utilities are allowed to own generation, FirstEnergy has pledged $100 million to build 50MW of solar projects — the investment will be recovered through customer rates. The company has described this as part of its strategy to transition to a low-carbon future. FirstEnergy announced a goal to be carbon neutral by 2050.
Solar credits
Utilities aren’t entirely new to this bidding process. For years, they’ve been buying renewable energy credits from solar projects to meet obligations set by a 2004 law establishing the state’s Alternative Energy Portfolio Standards.
That legislation required utilities to buy credits equal to an increasing amount of their total demand. In 2021, that requirement plateaued at half a percent. A credit is issued for every megawatt hour of electricity generated by qualified sources.
The mandate was once ahead of the curve. But today, it is far below the solar energy thresholds set by some neighboring states. For example, in 2018, New Jersey had raised its requirement to 5.1% and achieved it two years later. Maryland’s requirement is 14.5% by 2028.
Solar advocates say Pennsylvania’s lower requirements have held development back.
But the credits are just one revenue stream for solar projects. They also make money by selling the actual energy and other services into the grid.
This is the first time that Duquesne Light and FirstEnergy are bundling the solar credits with the energy component.
Cypress Creek Renewables is supporting an effort to require all utilities in the state to do the same.
“I’m pleased to see that utilities are getting there on their own and assessing that solar procured at this scale could be way to save money for customers,” Mr. Kozey said. “I think the policy would have sped up that process.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.