When Stronghold Digital Mining Inc. bought two Pennsylvania waste coal power plants and built shiny new data centers with thousands of bitcoin mining machines to sap the electricity, the company expected that crypto mining would be the moneymaker supporting the old power plants, and by extension, the company’s remediation of waste coal piles in places like West Deer.
For now, the calculus has flipped.
Bitcoin has lost two-thirds of its value since last fall. Meanwhile, electric power prices doubled. In short, it’s now more profitable to sell electrons to the grid than to mint crypto coins.
Last week, the company told investors it had returned 26,000 bitcoin mining machines, or two-thirds of its fleet, to drive down its debt.
“When we went public last year, bitcoin prices were substantially higher and grid prices substantially lower than where they currently are,” Stronghold CEO Greg Beard told analysts during a call last week, which was postponed twice as the company negotiated deals with equipment vendors and lenders to restructure its finances. “So the economics of the power business represented a more theoretical downside protection.
“We didn't expect the power business to be a meaningful driver of value for at least a couple of years. But it's critical now.”
Read More
Stronghold’s initial public offering came only a few weeks before bitcoin reached the peak of its parabolic rise. In November, the currency reached as high as $67,000. The decline began later that month. At the end of last week, bitcoin was worth about $21,000.
Stronghold’s stock price had an even steeper trajectory, debuting at around $29 per share in late October and closing below $2 on Friday.
When the company’s delayed financial results came out last week, Stronghold reported a net loss of $40.2 million during the past quarter, compared to a $3.2 million loss during the same three months in 2021.
The electricity is needed to power Stronghold’s bank of miners — computers that perform calculations that verify and add bitcoin transactions to a global ledger, and as a reward for their work, earn bitcoin for Stronghold.
Leaning into the grid
The past several months have been rocky for Stronghold.
Its agreement with the regional grid operator, PJM Interconnection, obligated the Scrubgrass Plant in Venango County to provide more power than Stronghold was expecting, limiting its ability to mine bitcoin.
Major repairs at Scrubgrass and at the firm’s Panther Creek facility in Carbon County took them offline for extended periods and cost millions of dollars. A delay in the delivery of new mining machines risked Stronghold defaulting on its debt obligations.
The company has had to write down $12 million in the value of its own digital currency holdings and mining assets.
During the analyst call last week, Stronghold’s leaders said the debt restructuring deals they announced would rebalance the company’s revenues and obligations during a period of low bitcoin prices.
They tried to convey that while other bitcoin miners are hit twice as hard in this environment — having to spend more to power a significantly less lucrative mining operation — Stronghold can minimize its mining activities and ride the wave of high power prices by selling more energy into the electric grid.
Electricity prices have been averaging above $100 per megawatt hour in recent months, Mr. Beard said, with some peak time windows reaching even into the thousands.
Stronghold Chief Financial Officer Matt Smith explained: “It just happens to be the case that when the grid is vulnerable and calling for your electricity, it's also the most profitable to deliver it.”
So, the short-term plan is to lean into the grid.
Stronghold’s co-chairman, Bill Spence, estimated that the company has recently been selling about 70% of its power into the electric grid and routing the rest to the crypto yard.
“Now’s the perfect time to do that,” he said.
It’s what keeps the lights on, both on the grid and at Stronghold, he said.
“Without the financial position being what it is, these plants go away,” Mr. Spence said.
Congressional inquiries
Last week, Stronghold, along with three other publicly traded firms, received letters from the chairs of the U.S. House Committee on Energy and Commerce wondering if the plants shouldn’t just go away.
Burning waste coal produces more carbon dioxide emissions per unit of energy than burning regular coal.
“Given the existential threat posed by the climate crisis, we are deeply concerned about efforts that extend the operational life of aging coal power plants and leads to increased GHG pollution,” the letter reads.
Mr. Spence said the company’s lawyers are working on a response, which will probably look similar to the letter Stronghold submitted in response to an inquiry by Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., earlier this year. It will highlight that the waste coal that’s burned in Stronghold-operated plants has been dumped in communities where it is polluting water and contributing to blight, he said.
“Are we going to now say that CO2 is the only environmental problem we have to worry about?” Mr. Spence wondered.
He said he would welcome the House committee chairs to Scrubgrass or Panther Creek to show the tradeoff he believes creates an environmental benefit — and the crypto mining machines that are supposed to make it possible.
Stronghold has vowed to eventually restock its mining fleet — the depressed cryptocurrency prices have led many miners to abandon expensive machines that the company now hopes to buy at fire sale prices — but it’s in no hurry to do so.
“We’re going to replace these machines. We’re going to stay in this industry and stay in this business,” Mr. Spence said.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.