Forward Township supervisors on Wednesday voted to deny an application for a massive metallurgical coal mine.
Except the application was withdrawn days before the meeting.
The Australian-based company, Coronado Global Resources, wasn’t at the meeting and its attorney, Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney shareholder Shawn Gallagher, said on Tuesday that “Coronado will not be on the agenda.”
Except that it was.
“There is nothing to vote on,” Mr. Gallagher said.
But the vote was held just the same.
Read More
Bill Sittig, of Sittig Cortese & Wratcher, whom the township hired to work on the Coronado matter, said he advised the supervisors that they should get their decision on the record despite the withdrawal.
“So I said, while it’s a little unusual, we should deny it,” Mr. Sittig said after the meeting Wednesday. So they did.
“They sent the [withdrawal] letter but it’s really pretty meaningless,” Mr. Sittig said before the meeting. “That means they can come in tomorrow with a new application. And we’re not going to stand for that.”
While the coal company, which operates mines in Australia and Appalachia, has yet to apply for any environmental permits and is years away from actual mining, the Mon Valley Mine proposal has riled Forward.
Coronado has asked for a conditional-use permit to build a mine portal, coal preparation plant, rail and truck unloading facilities and coal waste storage on land that is mostly zoned for conservation and residential uses.
Forward’s 30-year-old zoning ordinance only allows mining in industrial zones. Coronado believes this makes the ordinance invalid because it excludes a “legitimate use” and interferes with its ability to access its minerals. If it can’t get a conditional use approval for its mine, Coronado said it wants the township to add a “curative amendment” to its zoning ordinance, creating a coal mining overlay district that would encompass Coronado’s proposed mine.
In August, at the first and only public appearance where Coronado presented its plans, the Forward Township Planning Commission rejected the company’s challenge to its zoning ordinance.
In September, the board of supervisors set Oct. 27 as the meeting date to take up the “Coronado Coal Company Issue.” The notice focused mostly on how many people attended the August meeting: 297 or 12% of the adult population of the township, the document said. More would be better this time around, it urged.
The notice bounced around Facebook as residents rallied their contacts to show up.
Then, on Friday afternoon, Coronado’s attorney sent the township a letter. “Please be advised that (Coronado) hereby withdraws the zoning application.”
Forward’s solicitor Matthew Racunas, of the Racunas Law Group, replied on Tuesday. The hearing would proceed as scheduled, he said, and “strongly recommended that you appear at the hearing to notify the board and the community of Coronado’s intentions.”
He called the timing of the withdrawal “unconscionable” and said the company had “elected to misguide the township at every opportunity.”
Coronado’s withdrawal of the zoning application doesn’t mean it’s dropping plans for the mine.
The company told investors last week that while work on the ground, such as drilling core holes, is still on hold, “permitting and design works continue.”
“It is expected that works will escalate in 2022,” the company wrote in its quarterly report, released Oct. 20.
Coronado wrote that it “commenced community engagement processes with the Forward Township Planning Commission to discuss the proposed project as part of its permitting process.”
Mr. Gallagher told the Post-Gazette that the company was considering residents’ concerns voiced at the August meeting and “we are currently evaluating a smaller footprint.” He confirmed that Coronado will file another application at some point in the future.
While Mr. Sittig called the delay a “bullying move” — “you can’t spend hundreds of thousands of dollars of taxpayer money, then pick up stakes and go another day” — he said the township will wait and see what Coronado decides to do next.
“If they come in with a different application, with a different scope,” he said, the township will take up the task.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.