If you are a homeowner and an insomniac browsing through the Public Utility Code in a last ditch effort to catch some sleep, you might have reason to think the safety of the natural gas pipeline that carries fuel from the curb into your house is in your hands.
Good luck getting to sleep now.
The Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission is working on taming your anxiety.
The state agency has taken up the issue of natural gas service lines — which are small-diameter pipelines that carry gas from the main line to the meter on a property or to the wall of a house. Utilities typically own a portion of those lines and customers own the remainder under their property.
The PUC’s current regulations give the impression, “albeit unintended, that the customer, and not the operator, is responsible for pipeline safety on part of the pipe between the [gas] main and the meter,” a newly issued request for comments explains.
Local gas utilities give the same impression on their websites. North Shore-based Peoples Natural Gas, for example, says that “in most cases, Peoples' maintenance responsibility ends around your property line — at the point where the company service line connects with the customer service line. Repairs to the customer service line, house line, and gas appliances are the customer's responsibility.”
Read More
Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania advises customers that “for your safety, have your natural gas lines inspected periodically for leaks and corrosion by a qualified professional.” This refers not just to the service line but also the pipelines inside the home and Columbia Gas’ spokesman Russ Bedell said that the Canonsburg-based utility inspects its own and customer-owned service lines every three years. If it finds something amiss, however, it’s usually the customers’ responsibility to find a qualified contractor and have the line fixed.
Columbia is following PUC regulations, which may conflict with federal pipeline safety rules. That’s why the state agency is proposing to clarify its rules to establish that the utility, not the customer, is responsible for the design, construction, operation and maintenance of a customer’s service line before it touches the meter or the wall of a house. The clarified rules also would stipulate that the utility can bill customers for the cost of upholding that responsibility — in other words, the costs of repairing or replacing the line.
How that cost will be determined is one of the areas where the PUC is looking to stakeholders for advice.
“Should the commission allow the utilities to establish repayment plans, with interest, for customers to pay the cost of repairs to their service lines? What is the maximum repayment period that should be allowed? What interest rate should be applied?” the PUC is asking.
What if a customer doesn’t stick to the payment plan to reimburse the utility for its work? Could service be shut off? And after how long?
“Communication with customers regarding notice, cost estimates, billing, work scheduling, and the like will be a significant issue to address as part of this initiative,” the PUC wrote.
But the PUC is also considering a different cost paradigm.
Maybe it would make sense to spread this cost among all ratepayers, the PUC is wondering, either through a surcharge now applied to fund repair and construction work or through rate increases. Could the customer who owns the line, perhaps, contribute some of the cost with all ratepayers chipping in for the rest?
It wouldn’t be unprecedented. For certain projects, the PUC has permitted People Natural Gas and Columbia Gas to replace customer-owned service lines and bill the cost to ratepayers in service of “system-wide stability” and safety, PUC vice chairman David Sweet recalled in 2018, testifying before the House Consumer Affairs Committee.
Peoples announced in 2016 that it got permission from the PUC to replace customer-owned bare steel pipelines as part of its 20-year infrastructure improvement plan.
Columbia Gas, according to Mr. Bedell, on occasion does the same. “There are times when we replace customer-owned service lines,” he said, “when we are doing a capital infrastructure replacement project. On those projects where we are upgrading our gas mains, new meters and service lines may be installed by Columbia Gas, but the customer subsequently owns that service line after the project is completed.”
The PUC’s Mr. Sweet was drawing on those examples when he testified before the legislature in 2018. At that time, lawmakers were weighing the same issues that the PUC is looking at now, but for water utilities.
After the lead-laden water in Flint, Mich., brought the issue of lead pipes into wide public consciousness, the Pennsylvania legislature wanted to make sure there was an expedient way to replace customer-owned lead service lines, not just the utility-owned portions of those lines. The bill, which passed and became Act 120, allows water utilities to perform the replacements and recover a rate of return on that work.
To give input on the current set of questions, stakeholders can submit comments at efiling.puc.pa.gov. The docket number is L 2020-3019417.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.