The only coal-fired power plant in Allegheny County will permanently close in September, its operator announced Wednesday.

The Cheswick Generating Station in Springdale, a 51-year-old facility that has long drawn the ire of environmental groups, will shutter on Sept. 15.

Houston-based GenOn Holdings said in a statement that in addition to the 565-megawatt power plant in Pennsylvania, it will also retire the 627-megawatt Avon Lake Generating Station in Ohio. Two units at the 1,229-megawatt Morgantown Generating Station in Maryland also will be retired in the summer of 2021, the company said.

GenOn said these retirements were “driven by unfavorable economic conditions, higher costs including those associated with environmental compliance, an inability to compete with other generation types, and evolving market rules that promote subsidized resources.”

Advertise with us

Cheswick is one of only six remaining conventional coal-fired power plants in Pennsylvania, down from 23 in 2004. All but three of the remaining coal plants have commitments to retire or transition to other fuel sources within the decade.

According to a 2019 economic impact analysis done on behalf of Cheswick and other Pennsylvania coal plants, Cheswick had 60 employees, spent $9 million annually on employee compensation and had annual operating expenditures of $56 million.

Cheswick is the state’s smallest operating coal plant, which puts it at a particular competitive disadvantage. At 51 years old, it has also reached the end of its expected lifespan.

In a December study in the journal Science, a Georgia Institute of Technology researcher calculated the expected closure date for every remaining fossil fuel power plant in the U.S. based on its typical lifespan. Cheswick’s was 2021.

Still, the news, which went through the union rumor mill a few days before the official announcement, was unexpected.

Advertise with us

“It took us by surprise,” said Shawn Steffee, business manager for the Boilermakers Local 154, which has been sending its members to do maintenance work at Cheswick for years.

“It’s a nice, clean facility. I just don’t understand why it needed to go.”

In fact, Cheswick is one of the largest polluters in Allegheny County, by virtue of its size and function. While Mr. Steffee acknowledged that closing it would improve the air quality in Allegheny County, he asked where the line should be drawn.

“Where do we stop removing emissions, removing electricity?” he asked.

In 2019, the latest year for which emissions data is available from the Allegheny County Health Department, Cheswick was second in the county in terms of nitrogen oxide emissions. U.S. Steel’s Clairton Coke Works was first.

Advertise with us

The coal plant is also among the top emitters of other hazardous air pollutants in the county, often just behind U.S. Steel’s Clairton or Edgar Thomson facilities.

In an analysis of emissions that the Health Department released several years ago, it said that the “total amount of industrial pollution in the County [is] highly dependent on the output of these two facilities,” referring to Clairton and Cheswick. It noted that much of the reduction in county pollution seen over the past decade came from Cheswick installing emission controls, although the facility doesn’t always run them.

Environmental groups have objected to the company’s nonconstant use of the technology during operations, while the power plant operator said it was meeting emissions limits even without them. That’s in part because Cheswick hasn’t operated at full capacity for years.

It has been used as a peaking plant — firing up only when the price of electricity on the grid was high enough to warrant it. Its operating costs have increased as the plant has aged and was required to comply with environmental permits that have gotten stricter. It is also competing against cheap natural gas — new, more efficient gas power plants are popping up all over the Northeastern grid, edging out coal.

According to the Pennsylvania Coal Alliance, Cheswick did not clear the recent grid capacity auction, which pays power generators to be online in case they are needed three years from now.

Advertise with us

“The capacity auction is a promissory note,” said Rachel Gleason, executive director of the Harrisburg-based trade group. It’s a promise from the operator that they will be available, viable and reliable if called to supply power to the grid in future years.

For this year’s auction, which was just completed, coal plants had to increase the prices that would keep them online by the anticipated cost of complying with the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, or RGGI.

Joining that multistate compact, as Gov. Tom Wolf has said he wants to do, would establish a price and a gradually declining cap on carbon emissions in Pennsylvania. The Coal Alliance has vehemently opposed this move, saying it would put the coal industry out of business in the state and, instead, would simply shift the jobs and the emissions to neighboring states that don’t join RGGI.

Ms. Gleason couldn’t say how much the anticipation of RGGI played into GenOn’s decision to shutter Cheswick, and the company’s general counsel did not respond to an inquiry from the Post-Gazette.

Recent modeling from the state Department of Environmental Protection predicts few, if any, of the state’s conventional coal power plants will remain operating past 2025, whether Pennsylvania joins the carbon-cutting alliance or not, because competition is forcing coal out of the marketplace.

Advertise with us

The coal that’s burned at Cheswick comes from two West Virginia mines — Shoemaker, which is now owned by the company that emerged from the bankruptcy of Murray Energy Inc.; and Tunnel Ridge Mine, owned by Alliance Resource Partners.

The outlook for coal producers is similarly bleak. Just this week, another mine that survived Murray Energy’s bankruptcy, the Monongalia Coal Mine on the border of Pennsylvania and West Virginia, said it would permanently close and lay off 180 workers. That mine supplied several power plants, including GenOn’s Morgantown station in Maryland, which is also slated to close a year after Cheswick.

The Sierra Club, an environmental group that has sued Cheswick over water and air pollution, celebrated the announcement.

“GenOn has finally come to terms with economic reality,” said Tom Schuster, the Sierra Club’s clean energy program director in Pennsylvania. “This aging coal plant has become too expensive and has polluted Allegheny County’s air and water for far too long. And it’s right to close a major source of pollution if it can’t afford to be compliant with federal law.”

He encouraged elected officials to find a way to redevelop the site so that communities impacted by the loss of the power plant aren’t left behind.

Advertise with us

Rep. Carrie Lewis DelRosso, a Republican representing the 33rd Legislative District, which includes the plant, said in a statement: “I promise to use my energy and business background to initiate and support any efforts with GenOn to work on new development or new business which will continue to supply infrastructure funding for Allegheny.”

She bemoaned the decision to close the plant as unmitigated bad news. “This closure does nothing but ruin our economy further and steal family-sustaining jobs from our citizens.”

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com; Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.