Days before a high-profile gender discrimination case against Consol Energy Inc. was due to start trial this week, Consol’s ousted president, Katharine Fredriksen, reached a settlement with her former employer.

The details of the agreement were not revealed, but the sudden break in the case came after Ms. Fredriksen’s attorney asked to add a new witness to the trial.

Eve Flaherty, a former executive assistant to Consol’s CEO Jimmy Brock, had told Ms. Fredriksen’s attorney that she had heard Mr. Brock say he planned to “get rid of that girl’s ass at his first chance.”

A Jan. 24 docket entry confirmed that the case had been settled without a trial.

Advertise with us

Mr. Brock was a central figure in Ms. Fredriksen’s complaint, which she filed against the Cecil-based coal company in March 2018.

He had fired Ms. Fredriksen just three weeks after Consol became its own publicly traded company, splitting with the oil and gas division now known as CNX Resources Corp.

Ms. Fredriksen said in the lawsuit that she was purposely excluded from meetings, called “girl” in front of subordinates and told that Consol’s male employees may have a hard time accepting her.

At first, she said in court documents, she was told her position was being eliminated and that she hadn’t done anything wrong.

Later, Mr. Brock admitted in a deposition to having conflicts with the former president of the company and said she wasn’t a team player. He recalled a conversation with then-CEO Nick DeIuliis in 2017 where, Mr. Brock claimed, he was asked what he would do if the coal company were structured so that he would report to Ms. Fredriksen. Mr. Brock said during a deposition that he would retire instead. He said Mr. DeIuliis then revealed he was joking.

Advertise with us

A steady stream of accusations went back and forth in the case, filed with the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, during the past two years, with Ms. Fredriksen calculating she was paid 20 cents for every dollar that male executives, including those below her in rank, received.

She believed she was eventually fired in December 2017 because she’d complained about the pay disparity multiple times.

Consol has denied her allegations and accused its former president of trying to game the legal system by introducing new exhibits and new witnesses at the last minute to disrupt the company’s ability to defend itself.

Ms. Fredriksen came to Consol in 2011 to serve as a senior vice president of environmental affairs. She made a name for herself at the company and, in July 2017, Mr. DeIuliis appointed her as president of the coal arm, which was preparing to spin out as a standalone company.

Ms. Fredriksen said in her filings that Mr. DeIuliis had originally promised her the top executive post of the coal company, but later gave the job to Mr. Brock, saying his decades of experience in the industry would make for a smooth transition. Mr. DeIuliis, in court filings, denied promising the promotion.

Advertise with us

Still, Ms. Fredriksen said, she was led to believe that Mr. Brock would retire within a few years and that she would be promoted to CEO of the coal firm.

When she was fired by Mr. Brock, she appealed to Mr. DeIuliis, who had become the CEO of CNX Resources. She asked to be considered for executive roles at CNX or one of its sister companies in charge of pipelines.

But Mr. DeIuliis said in a deposition that he thought it was prudent to wait until he knew that Ms. Fredriksen had resolved things with Consol before considering her for a post at his firms. She interpreted that to be retaliation for filing a complaint under the Equal Pay Act.

That’s according to documents in another lawsuit that Ms. Fredriksen filed against CNX Resources and its subsidiaries in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.

That lawsuit, which is a parallel effort to the federal case against Consol, is still active. Earlier this week, Ms. Fredriksen asked the judge in that case to move the matter to trial.

Advertise with us

CNX declined to comment on the case.

Ms. Fredriksen, who still lives in Pittsburgh and is on the board of an angel investing fund for women entrepreneurs, also filed a complaint before the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455