Two years ago just after Christmas, Patrick Koch, general manager of H&K Equipment Group, got a cryptic call from the White House. An advance team was scouting locations for a “high level visitor” from the administration.
H&K, which sells large industrial equipment like telehandlers and railcar movers, wasn’t politically active, Mr. Koch said. But the Western Pennsylvania business was honored to be chosen and agreed to host.
After a week of arrangements, it became clear that the visitor would be President Donald Trump, who would be using the venue to tout his tax plan.
Before the Secret Service descended on the Coraopolis warehouse, the White House asked Mr. Koch how he planned to handle employee attendance. All work would have to be stopped during the presidential visit, he was told.
“They didn’t try to steer us one way or another,” Mr. Koch said. “But they had asked if we were going to compensate people for lack of production that day.”
Everyone would be paid, he said. Those who wanted to see the president speak got to bring their spouses. Those who didn’t could stay home and still collect their wages.
Read More
“It wasn’t their fault that they were going to be not able to work that day,” Mr. Koch reasoned.
When Shell Chemical Appalachia, which is building a massive petrochemical complex in Potter Township, hosted Mr. Trump earlier this month, the arrangement was different.
Those who showed up on the day of the speech got paid and those who stayed home didn’t.
There’s no official playbook for when a president visits the shop floor. It happens so infrequently and is dictated to such an extent by Secret Service protocol that employers often have little reference for how to accommodate it.
Shell has said that the many labor contracts that govern work at its Beaver County site ruled the day. The contracts require employees to be onsite to be paid. It just happened to be that the only place they were allowed onsite during Mr. Trump’s speech was the cavernous building where he was speaking.
That sounded perfectly routine to Anthony Davis, a 25-year veteran of the Jeep plant in Toledo, Ohio, and a “third generation Jeeper” who has seen his share of presidents pass through the shop.
In 1996, Mr. Davis watched as President Bill Clinton drove the two-millionth Jeep (give or take a few) off the assembly line of the plant.
In 2011, he was one of a few employees chosen to show President Barack Obama how he does his job. The president wanted to touch everything, Mr. Davis recalled. A White House photographer snapped a picture of Mr. Davis showing Mr. Obama how to install a part on a 2011 Jeep Wrangler. Then he got to shake the president’s hand.
“It was a very exciting experience,” Mr. Davis said.
Then the Secret Service cleared out the assembly floor to do a sweep in preparation for Mr. Obama’s speech. The employees who wanted to see it were allowed to come back and were paid. Those who chose to clock out and leave the Jeep plant, didn’t.
“Whenever you leave the factory, you don’t get paid,” Mr. Davis said. “That’s life.”
In his experience, the opportunity to see a sitting president up close — and the excitement of such an event taking place in your workplace — often overtakes people’s politics.
At the end of the day, the Secret Service makes the rules, deciding whether an entire facility needs to be shut down — as it was at Gamesa’s wind turbine manufacturing plant in Pennsylvania where Mr. Obama spoke in 2011 and all employees got paid whether they showed or not — or just a part of the facility, as was the case with U.S. Steel.
When the Pittsburgh-based steelmaker hosted Mr. Trump at its Granite City Works in Illinois last year, workers were invited to attend the speech and were paid if they came. Those who chose not to could work in other areas onsite, said spokeswoman Meghan Cox. The same arrangement held for Mr. Obama’s visit to the Irvin plant in West Mifflin in 2014.
The fallout from how Shell handled Mr. Trump’s visit last week has tapered from a flurry of news stories to a behind-the-scenes grievance process.
A number of labor unions — and there are more than a dozen onsite — have notified the company they intend to file grievances over several aspects of the event, including that workers who chose not to come to the Shell plant for Mr. Trump’s speech on Tuesday also did not meet the threshold for overtime pay at the end of that week.
“If you don’t show up, you don’t get paid — that’s any job,” said Joe Podolack, who represents the Teamsters Local Union 341, with some 180 workers on the site.
“But the whole moral to the story is I say it was political. Other people are saying it was political. You should not be forced to come and listen to a politician running for office if you’re not interested,” Mr. Podolack said. “They forced a lot of people by telling them you’re not going to pay time and a half on Friday.”
Jordan Little, an operator at Shell’s Beaver County work site, said he saw the opportunity to see Mr. Trump as a “once-in-a-lifetime thing.”
Mr. Little estimated that the majority of the daytime workforce was in attendance and most were cheering for the president during his Aug. 13 visit.
There was some booing and complaining, he said, but “I think a lot of people went because it was an easy day to get paid and a lot of people down there actually do support Trump.
“I just thought it was cool for a 24-year-old to be within 20 feet from the president,” Mr. Little said. “And getting paid to do it.”
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.