Rob McNally, the CEO of the nation’s largest natural gas producer EQT Corp., wanted to stick to the talking points. The company’s “culture changes” over the past six months; its cash flow; faster drilling; better fracking.
And he mostly got his wish during the Downtown-based company’s call with analysts Thursday morning.
It took 45 minutes for someone to acknowledge that Toby Rice, former president of Rice Energy Inc. and current EQT shareholder/agitator, had announced a lawsuit against EQT just 10 minutes before Mr. McNally began reading the company’s achievements.
The complaint, filed in Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas, alleges that EQT is trying to give an unfair advantage to its nominees to the board of the directors as Mr. Rice, his brother Derek Rice and other former Rice Energy executives mount a proxy battle with their own slate of candidates.
Mr. McNally waved off the lawsuit just as he’s been trying to wave off the challenge to his leadership over the past several months.
“Much ado about nothing,” he said.
Read More
He was chief financial officer of EQT when the company bought Rice Energy for $6.7 billion in 2017, a transaction he strongly supported. Then, shortly after being named CEO in November 2018, Mr. McNally became a target of shareholder efforts to replace EQT’s leadership with former Rice executives. The face of the effort is Toby Rice.
Mr. Rice, with support from at least two hedge funds, believes he should take over as CEO and has put together a roster of nine director nominees who would make that happen. Shareholders will decide the direction of the company at EQT’s annual meeting, scheduled for July 10.
But shareholders must choose only one proxy card to cast their votes: either Rice’s white card which has nine nominees, including one current EQT board member, Danny Rice, or EQT’s proxy card which has yet to be revealed but is expected to include a 12-member board. They cannot pick and choose nominees from both.
Mr. Rice is alleging that EQT might try to include some Rice nominees in its proxy materials, thereby steering shareholders to its card and controlling the process.
The lawsuit also says that EQT’s agreement with lenders would deem a change of control at the company — e.g. a majority new board — an event of default, which could force the company to pay back $800 million earlier than expected. To avoid that, Mr. Rice is proposing that EQT approve the Rice nominees for this purpose.
Mr. McNally said that the language about default is open to interpretation and that the current board is still reviewing Rice’s nominees.
“Our board is going to do what’s right for the shareholders,” he vowed. “We’re not going to put the company in jeopardy. We’re not going to put our shareholders in jeopardy.”
Besides, he said, filing the lawsuit on the morning of earnings is a blatant attempt to divert the conversation from EQT’s “outstanding financial and operational performance.”
The Rice team, through a statement, snubbed the company’s results on Thursday.
“Even if EQT achieves its guidance for 2019, which it failed to do in 2018, it would still be the highest cost operator in the basin so nothing has changed the urgent need to replace leadership and institute the Rice Plan,” the statement said.
In its proxy, the Rice team said it has developed a plan for the first 100 days after its takeover and will be revealing that to investors over the coming weeks.
EQT, too, will be making the rounds in the near future. COO Gary Gould said on Thursday — his fourth day on the job — that he’s eager to “hit the road” and tell the company’s story to investors in the weeks and months ahead.
The company’s stock was down 3 percent in trading Thursday.
The water business
EQT reported net income of $191 million, or 75 cents per share, during the first quarter, up from a loss of nearly $1.6 billion, or $5.99 per share during the same time in 2018.
Since overspending its capital budget and posting a loss of $2.2 billion last year — factors that catalyzed the Rice-led shareholder campaign — EQT has been stressing its cost-cutting initiatives. It has 100 such ideas in the works, Mr. McNally said.
One big one would reimagine how impaired water — that is, flowback water from fracking and the salty brine that flows out of the well after it’s producing — is handled.
Today, the company trucks 75,000 barrels of this wastewater daily. If instead it could pipe the fluid, that would save around $5 per barrel, Mr. McNally said.
He was echoing a thread teased by Thomas Karam, the CEO of EQT spinout Equitrans Midstream Corp. during that company’s earnings call in March.
Produced water pipelines aren’t widespread in Appalachia, but EQT and Equitrans, which would most likely be the company laying these pipes in the ground for EQT, want that to change.
EQT already has rights of way for its natural gas gathering lines, Mr. McNally said, and could use those corridors to bury wastewater pipelines.
A system of underground pipelines would be particularly compelling in places like Greene and Washington counties, where EQT’s dense development makes permanent infrastructure economic.
“It’s a real benefit both from a cost perspective but also a safety and environmental perspective,” he said.
The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, which doesn’t currently regulate such pipelines but is preparing to draft best practice guidelines for their construction and operation, “appears to be supportive,” Mr. McNally said.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.
Correction, posted April 26, 2019: EQT’s CEO Rob McNally’s former title has been corrected.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.