CNX Corp. on Thursday laid out a “solid, minimum level of activity” for 2019 — a base to build upon as the oil and gas company gathers more data throughout the year.
If company management was expecting that to sound measured and prudent, the message didn’t quite connect as planned. That’s because its capital budget of at least $1 billion would outpace last year’s by up to 20 percent, while production at the end of the year would actually decline in comparison.
The Cecil-based company’s stock had plunged 10 percent by 2:45 p.m., despite CNX’s report that it pulled in $883 million net income for 2018, amounting to $3.71 per share, up significantly from $277 million, or $1.65 per share, in 2017.
While other energy companies also saw their stock prices decline on Thursday, their drops were less steep.
Responding to the stock movement, company spokesman Brian Aiello said the company is focused on long-term results and that “near term equity markets are hard to predict.
“It’s a prudent plan that we can scale to match changing conditions throughout the year,” he said.
The stock price drop means investors are assuming that CNX is doing less with more — less production with more capital in 2019, said Sameer Panjwani, an analyst with Tudor, Pickering, Holt & Co.
“They’re implying that they’re going to be outspending cash flow,” he said.
It could be that the money spent drilling and completing wells in 2019 leads to a substantial bump in production in 2020 — meaning the metrics could be a function of timing and not a capital efficiency problem, he noted.
But while several analysts tried to pry that explanation from company leaders during an earnings call Thursday morning, none were very successful.
“There wasn’t a real good answer that they provided,” Mr. Panjwani, one of the prodders, said after the call.
CNX management did say it can be misleading trying to tie the capital budget to the production expected in 2019, since large well development projects don’t fall neatly into a calendar year.
“Obviously, what we do in 2019 has effect in years other than just 2019,” CFO Don Rush told analysts during the call.
Time and time again, company leaders explained their rationale for setting a minimum bar: it’s better to start with a foundation and adjust than to over-project far into the future. The industry’s cost drivers change frequently, as does the data coming out of wells, and so the company’s plans must as well, they said.
“As we strive to be great capital allocators, we recognize the importance of making decisions real-time and fluidly versus annually or static,” CNX’s CEO Nick DeIuliis said.
Mr. DeIuliis boasted that CNX led its peers in the industry in buying back company shares, in an effort to drive up the value of shares outstanding. He said investors can look forward to more buybacks in the future.
He also said the company would continue making moves in the Utica Shale, but not at a hurried pace.
“We are on the cusp of making some major decisions with respect to the Utica,” Mr. DeIuliis said. “As the year unfolds and the data set expands,” the company will present a more real-time assessment of what activity will be like there.
Company leaders said they wanted to strike a balance between being one of the first companies to delve into the deep and dry Utica Shale in southwestern Pennsylvania and “getting it right” from the get-go. They don’t want to rush it until they’ve worked out the technical and logistical considerations, they said.
Downtown-based oil and gas company EQT Corp. was not named during the call, but the aura of its operational failures as it rushed to drill super long horizontal wells and ended up in a proxy fight over poor returns loomed over CNX’s Utica commentary.
Marcellus Shale wells still remain the company’s “bread and butter,” said Andrea Passman, CNX’s senior vice president of engineering and operations.
CNX also said it is building a water pipeline to slurp water from the Ohio River that will be used to frack southwestern Pennsylvania wells. That will be completed during the fourth quarter, the company said.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.