No company is an island and, these days, few can be sealed off by national borders, either on land or on paper.
It is with that dynamic in mind that American steel companies recently framed their financial results and forecasts for better times ahead.
Arguably the biggest disruption in the fabric of the steel trade are the anti-dumping tariffs that President Donald Trump placed on all steel imports into the U.S.
American steelmakers have welcomed these measures, which were first enacted in 2018, and believe they will create a more robust domestic industry in the long term. More immediately, though, both the steel tariffs and the prospect of others are tugging on both sides of the scale.
Take the example of Ohio-based Cleveland-Cliffs.
In 2020, Cliffs bought most of the U.S. assets of European company ArcelorMittal. As part of the deal, Cliffs also signed a five-year contract to supply steel slabs to a finishing facility in Alabama co-owned by ArcelorMittal and the Japanese company Nippon Steel (yes, that Nippon Steel).
Read More
Cliffs’ slabs would be made at its facilities in the U.S. and delivered to Alabama. But their price was pegged to an index in Brazil. That’s because the South American country is a major producer and exporter of steel slab — it supplies 60% of U.S. slab imports, for example. Large trading hubs are considered to be the most real-time pricing mechanisms for a commodity.
This was all well and good while the Brazilian benchmark followed the same trajectory as the price of flat-rolled steel in the U.S. But the two diverged sharply in March when Trump imposed 25% tariffs on all imported steel.
Cliffs’ CEO Lourenco Goncalves said the move was absolutely necessary. But the domino effect took money out of the company’s pocket — to the tune of $500 million in the first quarter.
“With that [tariff], the buyer universe for their slabs in the U.S. has shrunk, and the Brazilian slab mills have had to look elsewhere for buyers in other markets, which led them to dump their slabs at lower prices,” he explained during a call with analysts on Thursday.
“So while the domestic flat rolled prices have gone up, our realized prices under this particular Brazilian price-linked arrangement have declined, leaving us with a significant negative margin on this product.”
That one contract has accounted for about 10% of Cliffs’ sales volume, the company reported. Mr. Goncalves said he plans to let it run out in December. While “onerous,” this is the type of short-term pain that the CEO says will make the payoff of Trump’s tariffs worth it.
Cliffs reported a $483 million loss during the first three months of this year and announced a series of facility closures, impacting about 2,000 employees.
Pittsburgh-based U.S. Steel Corp. posted a loss for the first quarter of $116 million.
In a statement, U.S. Steel’s CEO David Burritt kept it vague: “While markets remain dynamic, our dedicated teams are successfully navigating current volatility through optimizing mix, executing with efficiency, and growing shipment volumes in our Mini Mill segment.”
The company plans to idle one of its three blast furnaces in Slovakia “until demand improves.” Its European sales volumes were down 20% year over year.
The company has not held a public earnings call with analysts in more than a year because of its embattled pending sale to Nippon Steel. The sale was rejected by former President Joe Biden in January, but Trump ordered a new national security review that’s due for completion by May 21. He is then expected to make a decision about the $14.9 billion sale by June 6.
Nippon, which also reported earnings this week, is eager to get the deal done. In a presentation to investors, the company said “global steel demand remains in an unprecedented state of crisis.”
The company blamed China’s oversupply of the market for the turmoil. Trump’s desire to protect the American steel market from Chinese dumping comes from the same place.
But Nippon also said that U.S. tariff policy is “beginning to have a significant impact on the global economy.
“There are concerns about the enormous impact on the steel industry both domestically and internationally, including indirect effects,” it warned. “It is difficult at this stage to quantitatively grasp the impact on the entire supply chain.”
America’s largest steelmaker, Nucor Steel Corp., sounded the most optimistic about the future of the U.S. steel industry during its call with investors late last month. Nucor’s backlog for orders of structural steel — the kind used to build things like manufacturing plants and bridges — is at a historic high, the company said.
Asked about the impact of the steel tariffs on Nucor specifically, the company’s CEO Leon Topalian said he can’t pinpoint a number but said the impact is “consequential.”
“We're seeing, again, a drop below 20% imports for the first time in many years.”
Mr. Topalian also praised Trump’s imposition of tariffs on not just steel but products made from it — like nails, tacks, staples — calling it “a move in the right direction.”
Just as these tariffs apply downstream of the steel, they also touch the upstream raw materials imported to make that steel. Last month, Trump imposed a universal 10% tariff on pig iron, ferrous scrap and direct-reduced iron — all inputs for steel production and all things Nucor buys. The company said it is in contact with the administration about such things, but mostly brushed off their impact encouraging analysts to zoom out instead.
“The small impact potential of higher raw material prices is much smaller than the impact of the overall macroeconomic trends in the industry,” Mr. Topalian said. “A healthy, vibrant steel industry and having a critical national defense and the pro-American policies that you're seeing adopted by the administration trumps all of that, pun intended.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.