When Phil Romagni opened his men’s clothing boutique Vestis in Lawrenceville in 2015, stocking the store with clothing made in the U.S. was a priority.

Around that time, there was “movement” within the menswear industry to source domestically, Mr. Romagni said, prompting him to invest in American-made clothing despite the challenges — the fashion industry overwhelmingly relies on overseas labor.

It “was an ideal that a lot of people had,” he said.

Back then, he built relationships with suppliers in places such as New York City’s garment district, offering custom American-made pieces alongside a curated selection of clothing produced overseas. But as Vestis approaches its 10-year mark, the store offers increasingly fewer American-made items because of rising costs and suppliers’ limited capacity.

Advertise with us

“As time went on, it got harder and harder to do, and more and more expensive,” said Mr. Romagni, who sells clothing from around 25 brands with most manufactured in Europe and Asia.

Now tariffs are presenting new challenges, for Vestis and others in the fashion industry.

When President Donald Trump came into office this year, Mr. Romagni anticipated the looming tariffs and purchased inventory in January for the fall and summer seasons.

“I tried to prepare as best I could, but nothing was basically announced when I had to buy stuff,” Mr. Romagni said.

Now, more than 100 days into the Trump administration, he has no more clarity on the tariff policy than he did in January.

Advertise with us

“I’m very, very uncertain about how the fall is going to work,” Mr. Romagni said. “And I think a lot of other people probably are, too.”

A fragmented global supply chain

It’s not just clothing boutiques that have been uncertain about where the trade wars will take the fashion industry.

Companies who lean on foreign manufacturing are watching closely, trying to determine which tariffs will hit hardest and how to fit the increased costs into business plans. Major retail chains, such as South Side-based American Eagle Outfitters, have said proposed tariffs are likely to increase costs and have seen their stock prices take hits.

With the rise of fast fashion in the early 2000s, clothing companies increasingly moved their supply chains abroad to lower labor costs and produce lower-priced items. Today, only 2% of clothing sold in the U.S. is manufactured domestically.

In recent years, the success of Chinese ultra-fast fashion retailers like Shein and Temu, have put major retailers at a significant competitive disadvantage.

Advertise with us
Vestis men's clothing boutique in Lawrenceville is approaching its 10th year in business. (Samara McCallum / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

During the pandemic, Shein’s annual sales tripled, making it the biggest online retailer in the world, Bloomberg reported. From November 2022 to November 2023, Shein introduced 1.3 million new fashion items — 37 times more than Spanish retail chain Zara and 65 times more than Swedish chain H&M, Reuters reported.

Many of those items come to the U.S., where consumers purchase more clothing now than at any point in history.

On average, Americans buy 53 new clothing items each year, four times more than in 2000, according to research group PIRG.

The Trump administration has said tariffs will be used to revive American manufacturing and level “unfair trade” practices, while raising revenue for the federal government. And some companies, from carmakers to pharmaceutical companies, have signaled plans to invest in U.S. production facilities.

On April 2, Trump signed an executive order ending the “de minimis” exemption, a loophole introduced in 2016 that allowed importers to avoid levies on items $800 or less. This order has already led to price increases at Shein and Temu, The New York Times reported.

Advertise with us

One chapter of a complex journey

U.S. retail conglomerates have maneuvered through tariffs before, but it has been challenging.

During Trump’s first term, he imposed up to 25% tariffs on China on $200 billion worth of goods. Several fashion companies moved manufacturing out of China to avoid levies, said Debajan Das, a fashion professor at West Virginia University in Morgantown.

“We saw a lot of businesses — factories [from] China — that went to Bangladesh, went to Vietnam, and set [up] factories there,” Mr. Das said. “So China’s exports declined, and Bangladesh and Vietnam’s exports increased in that period.”

Still the realities of today’s global fashion supply chain make it hard to fully avoid the world’s largest clothing manufacturer. That’s in part because the “Made in” label often reveals just one chapter of a far more complex journey.

Take a single dress from the European brand Zara sold in 2017. According to the BBC, its material, lyocell, began with trees grown in Austria. The fibers were spun into yarn in Egypt, then shipped to China to be woven into fabric. That fabric traveled to Spain for dyeing, and finally to Morocco, where it was cut and sewn.

Advertise with us

The tag? It says “Made in Morocco.”

“The amount of time the products [in the] supply chain, the materials … travel for your clothing items, [it] has traveled more than you will ever travel,” Mr. Das said.

Back in Lawrenceville, Mr. Romagni said even the American-made clothing he purchases for his store often comes with some level of production overseas.

Vestis offers a curated selection of “contemporary menswear” with an emphasis on natural fibers. A T-shirt made from 100% cotton and manufactured in Japan costs $89. A pair of trousers made from 100% Irish linen costs $368. A blue American-made button down costs $238.

An industry on edge

Following the April 2 announcement of Trump’s “Liberation Day” tariffs, fashion stocks immediately plunged.

Advertise with us

Levi Straus was down 8.15% for the year as of May 1; Ralph Lauren was down 1.83% and Nike dropped 23.21%.

Trump later rolled back plans for most of the tariffs he had announced earlier, and has since placed a baseline 10% tariff on all imported goods — with the exception of items from China, whose tariff rate is 145% — for 90 days.

That 90-day window is critical for the fashion industry. A typical trend cycle — from design conception to production — usually spans 90 to 180 days, Mr. Das said.

With all the uncertainty, Mr. Das predicts the fashion industry will play it safe with their designs — and that Americans will soon see rising costs.

Vestis, a men's clothing boutique in Lawrenceville, pictured on Thursday, May 1, 2025. (Samara McCallum / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“With [the] tariffs, it will change consumer behavior … as well for the fashion items,” he said. “It will definitely have a huge role.”

Advertise with us

American Eagle Outfitters, for one, gets products from more than 300 factories around the world, with 20% of its manufacturing in China. The company doesn’t own or operate any factories.

In its Q4 earnings report released in February, the company cited “global economic conditions” and declining consumer spending as having had a “material adverse effect on our business, results of operations and financial condition.” The report covered the period ended Feb. 1.

“Proposed tariffs or other tariffs on goods shipped from China would likely increase the cost of our merchandise and negatively impact our operating results,” the company said.

American Eagle stock price was down 36.57% at the start of May. A company spokesperson declined to comment.

Meanwhile, Dick’s Sporting Goods, headquartered in Findlay, reported its fourth-quarter results in a March call, and unlike American Eagle, the company expressed less trepidation over the impact of tariffs.

Advertise with us

While the company’s stock price dropped (17% as of May 1), Navdeep Gupta, the company’s chief financial officer, told analysts in March that the company had “limited to negligible exposure from Mexico and Canada” in terms of tariffs, and that many of the brands it sells in the store have “significantly diversified away from China from an apparel perspective over the last several years.”

“There is some exposure associated with the hard lines,” Mr. Gupta said. “But nothing significant to call out.”