Joe Mack has seen significant change in the six years he’s worked for U.S. Steel.

He used to run a larry car at one of the batteries at the Clairton Coke Works, but that battery closed in the spring amid scrutiny from environmentalists and health officials. In 2021, a planned $1.5 billion renovation of the region’s blast furnaces evaporated as CEO David Burritt instead poured capital into modern mini-mills in Arkansas.

Now the entire company could sell to any number of serious bidders, ranging from Ohio steelmaker Cleveland-Cliffs to rumored interest from the largest steelmaker in Europe, ArcelorMittal S.A., based in Luxembourg.

“I’m not sure how much longer this place will keep running,” Mr. Mack said outside the Clairton Works on Tuesday, toting a battered red lunch box adorned with a “Keep It Made in America” sticker.

Advertise with us
Workers line up outside of U.S. Steel's Clairton plant in Mon Valley after finishing their shifts on Aug. 30. Several were concerned about what a potential sale of the 122-year-old manufacturer could mean for jobs. (Evan Robinson-Johnson / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

U.S. Steel’s significance in the region looms much larger than who ultimately owns the company’s shares. Its 3,700 workers and the businesses that serve them are on the line, as are entire communities that surround the aging plants in the region. Some worry about changes a new owner would make. Others are eager for change.

"No matter what happens as far as U.S. Steel, ongoing pollution issues that cause harm to the community must stop in the Mon Valley and the Pittsburgh region,” said Matt Mehalik, executive director of the Breathe Project, a clearinghouse for information on air quality in the region.

Nationally, analysts foresee antitrust barriers and, given steel’s role in defense applications, even national security concerns.

A deal with Cleveland-Cliffs — which in July offered company shares and cash worth $7.3 billion for the entirety of United States Steel Corp. — would almost certainly prompt antitrust challenges from the Federal Trade Commission, and analysts say a lawsuit from the Department of Justice would be likely.

The joint operation would consolidate almost 100% of the nation’s iron ore and electrical steel manufacturing. It would place America back in the top 10 of global steelmakers and would offer “a lower-cost, more innovative, and stronger domestic supplier,” according to Cleveland-Cliffs CEO Lourenco Goncalves.

Advertise with us
U.S. Steel's Clairton plant in Mon Valley as seen on Aug. 30. The 122-year-old manufacturer is considering selling itself to multiple credible bidders. (Evan Robinson-Johnson / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Some distributors worry that Cleveland-Cliffs would use its control of 80% of the auto steel supply to drive up prices.

Further consolidation of steel, a key defense and infrastructure expense, could also be seen as a national security threat. It would be “highly unusual,” however, for national security advisers to push for an antitrust case against U.S. Steel, said Adam Hickey, former deputy assistant attorney general of the Department of Justice's National Security Division. He now is a partner at Mayer Brown LLP, an international law firm whose clients include leading corporations and financial institutions.

“In an ideal world we’d have a thousand flowers blooming and a lot of fully independent steel mills, but that’s not where we are,” Mr. Hickey said. “So the question is, is it better to have one big company, all in the U.S.?”

A more likely challenge would come if U.S. Steel chose an international suitor, he said.

Sen. J.D. Vance, R-Ohio, urged U.S. Steel in a letter last month not to consider offers from overseas buyers. At the same time, U.S. Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., said on X, formerly known as Twitter, that “any new steel acquisitions in the U.S. must be led by American companies.”

Advertise with us

For Randy Johnson, a maintenance tech at the Clairton Coke Works, it doesn’t really matter who wins the bidding war, as long as operations remain in the region.

“Whoever buys it, just keep it open,” he said. “I’ve put 14 years in, I need 16 more.”

Cleveland-Cliffs has promised to honor United Steelworkers’ current labor agreement, which lasts through November 2026. Its CEO has also made a personal commitment to U.S. Steel’s workers.

“I have your backs,” Mr. Goncalves told them in a letter last month.

U.S. Steel's Irvin plant in Mon Valley as seen on Aug. 30. The 122-year-old manufacturer is considering selling itself to multiple credible bidders. (Evan Robinson-Johnson / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Cleveland-Cliffs has said it is confident it can clear any regulatory hurdles needed to acquire U.S. Steel. But if Mr. Goncalves wants a chance to make that case, he first will have to win over the company’s board of directors.

Advertise with us

So far, they don’t seem convinced.

Mr. Burritt didn’t give the rival CEO the face-to-face meeting he requested. The company’s stock has already risen to nearly match Cleveland-Cliff’s original offer and appears to have drawn other serious bidders into the game, according to U.S. Steel’s public filings.

United Steelworkers President Tom Conway said he had received “countless calls” from potential purchasers, though so far the union has exclusively supported Cleveland-Cliffs.

A firebrand in his industry, Mr. Goncalves was one of the most anticipated speakers at last month’s Steel Market Update summit in Atlanta.

But at the last minute, the CEO bowed out of the influential conference, apparently out of concern that every word he uttered would be documented in federal filings as part of his pursuit of U.S. Steel.

Advertise with us

“It was too bad,” said Josh Spoores, principal analyst at CRU Group, which hosted the summit. “He couldn't do what he wanted to do.”

The hosts told Mr. Goncalves he didn’t need to mention the takeover bid, and at one point offered to livestream his presentation so his lawyers could write Securities and Exchange Commission reports on the spot. Shareholders from both companies are closely watching SEC reports to gauge the progress of the bidding war.

But ultimately, the sensitivity of the negotiations proved too fraught, Mr. Spoores said, adding that it was a disappointing miss for an executive who has captivated the industry with his bravado.

Many still hope the ambitious executive is successful in taking center stage at U.S. Steel.

U.S. Steel's Clairton plant in Mon Valley as seen on Aug. 30. The 122-year-old manufacturer is considering selling itself to multiple credible bidders. (Evan Robinson-Johnson / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

With a shared history of iron ore mining and an existing plant 50 miles north of the Mon Valley, the former AK Steel plant in Butler, Cleveland-Cliffs has the potential to save union jobs and maybe even pour new investment into the region.

Advertise with us

Forty years ago, U.S. Steel employed 34,000 in the region. Today that number is down to just 3,700.

“I don’t think this place is in U.S. Steel’s future,” Ron Fordyce, a 19-year-employee, said last week outside the Clairton plant. “They’re going more toward electric arc stuff and selling us down the river.”

However, he added: “I think if Cliffs buys it, it might be here longer.”

Stefani Pashman, CEO of the Allegheny Conference on Community Development, hopes that if U.S. Steel is sold, the new owner will consider more than just its shareholders.

“We have to remember these are citizens of our community and there are lives and family at stake,” she said. "We obviously hope that whoever comes in will make capital improvements in the Mon Valley, in the future of that plant, and in the people.”

Advertise with us

At Carnegie Mellon University, engineering professor Chris Pistorius said he hopes that any new owner will continue to support the region’s universities. Several of his graduate students have gone on to work for the steelmaker.

In October, he hopes to gain Department of Energy funding for several experiments — including a process to make iron using cleaner hydrogen instead of coke — that would be conducted at U.S. Steel's research and technology center in Munhall.

“If a takeover were to change the relationship with the university, that would not be something we’d be keen on,” he said.

Like the Steelworkers union, Mr. Pistorius has hope for Cleveland-Cliffs. He said the company kept its research labs in the region when it took over AK Steel.

“From the interaction that I have with their engineers there, the level of their work is just as high,” he said.

Evan Robinson-Johnson: ejohnson@post-gazette.com