There is very good news on the Pittsburgh-area labor market, with the unemployment rate at 4.1% in December 2022. Outside of the 4% rate in November, this is the lowest unemployment rate in the history of the series from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, going back more than 30 years.
But while the historically low unemployment rate is a positive, there is still a big hole in the Pittsburgh recovery. Local employment is still a very large 3% below its pre-pandemic level, while national employment is 2% higher than it was in February 2020, right before the pandemic decimated the labor market.
The problem in Pittsburgh is not that businesses don’t want to hire, but that workers are in extremely short supply. And that shortage of workers — a long-standing issue — will continue to hold back the Pittsburgh recovery.

When the pandemic hit
Pittsburgh, like all parts of the U.S., experienced enormous labor market disruption when the pandemic came to the nation in early 2020. The number of jobs in the area fell by almost 230,000 in March and April 2020, or 19%, compared to a 14% decline nationwide. The larger job losses in the Pittsburgh area were due in part to more severe restrictions on economic activity locally, compared to other parts of the country.
The national and local labor markets have improved remarkably since then due to efforts to contain the pandemic, government financial support for households and businesses, and very low interest rates after the Federal Reserve moved quickly to reduce borrowing costs at the beginning of the pandemic. Nationally, employment is now almost 2% above its pre-pandemic level.
Read More
But in the Pittsburgh area employment in December 2022 was 3% lower than it was before the pandemic, a loss of 36,000 jobs compared to February 2020.
Why the slow recovery here?
Why has the jobs recovery in Pittsburgh been so much weaker than in the rest of the U.S.? The problem is not that businesses don’t want to hire; anecdotal reports and surveys find that local firms would like to employ more workers. And they have been raising pay in an attempt to attract new employees, with the average wage in the area up 10% at the end of 2022 compared to before the pandemic.
Instead, the biggest problem is that there are fewer potential workers available.
The labor force — the number of people working or looking for work in the Pittsburgh area — is 3% smaller than it was before the pandemic, not coincidentally the gap in jobs compared to before the pandemic.
Nationally, the picture is different; for the U.S. overall, the labor force is about 1% larger than it was before the pandemic, even as some workers have left the job market post-pandemic.
We can see the impact of this labor shortage in many ways in the Pittsburgh economy. With the demand for employees strong in many industries and wages rising, workers are leaving lower-wage industries such as restaurants, hotels and personal care for better-paying opportunities in industries like manufacturing, warehousing and transportation.
As a result restaurants are reducing their hours or even closing, and hotels are cutting back on daily room cleaning. Wait times are longer in many industries as fewer employees deal with more customers.
And even with a slowing in the housing market as mortgage rates have moved higher, homeowners are still finding it very difficult to hire contractors or repair people.
This labor shortage will force Pittsburgh-area firms to rethink many aspects of their businesses. Leaders will need to review their staffing needs, human resource and pay practices, and investment spending so they can use their existing workers more effectively and find the workers they need over the longer run.
Pittsburgh’s enduring problem
Although the pandemic greatly exacerbated the labor shortage in the Pittsburgh area, this is actually a long-term problem.
With its older population, inability to attract international immigrants, and declining population, the labor force in greater Pittsburgh was basically flat from the mid-1990s up until the pandemic, even as it was steadily growing nationally. This lack of labor force growth discourages business investment in the area, and this in turn encourages out-migration, so the process feeds on itself.
The area does have some major advantages, in particular its education and healthcare institutions that provide cutting-edge research and attract highly skilled students and employees from all over the U.S., and the world.
But unless there is a deeper pool of labor to draw from, employment in the Pittsburgh metro area is unlikely to ever return to its pre-pandemic level.
Gus Faucher is senior vice president and chief economist of The PNC Financial Services Group. He shares his insights on the regional economy each month.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.