The relocation of ATI Inc.’s headquarters from Pittsburgh to Dallas last week is a hit to the region’s civic pride, but for now, the specialty metals company’s move appears to be largely a symbolic blow rather than a financial one.

“Assuming ATI’s core production facilities remain in the region, the loss … due to just their headquarters relocating I’d expect to be limited,” said Chris Briem, regional economist at the University of Pittsburgh’s Center for Social and Urban Research.

“I think the real impact will be in the long term if this move reflects where they expect their investment or expansion to be in the future.”

ATI spokeswoman Natalie Gillespie said last week that the company was “committed to maintaining a strong presence in Pittsburgh” and that the headquarters move would have little impact on the company’s 1,500 employees in Western Pennsylvania, none of whom are being asked to relocate, she said.

Advertise with us

“The CEO [Robert Wetherbee] and his direct reports are formally based in Dallas,” Ms. Gillespie added when pressed. “Thanks to travel and technology, they’re engaged and connected with our employees across the company.”

Ms. Gillespie wouldn’t specify the factors in the decision to switch the specialty metals company’s headquarters designation, other than to say it was tied to a “desire to formalize independent locations for our headquarters and our business operations.”

ATI has manufacturing facilities around the country and overseas, but none in Texas. Other than the executive office in Dallas at 2021 McKinney Ave., it has a warehouse/sales office in Houston.

Its manufacturing operations are concentrated in the Pittsburgh region, where it maintains nine facilities in Brackenridge, Latrobe, Monaca, Natrona Heights, Oakdale, Rochester, Vandergrift, Washington and Zelienople.

A financial issue?

Advertise with us

Late Wednesday, the CEO of the Allegheny County Conference on Community Development, Stefani Pashman, issued a statement saying she was disappointed with ATI’s move to the Lone Star State and seemed to imply that Pennsylvania’s corporate net income tax — one of the highest in the country at 9.99% — helped drive ATI away.

“In light of this news, it is more imperative than ever that Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf and the legislative body of the Commonwealth focus on creating a more business-friendly climate in Pennsylvania,” Ms. Pashman’s statement said. “This includes a material cut in Pennsylvania’s corporate net income tax, which remains a flashing red light that often deters companies from doing business here.”

As part of his final budget proposal, Mr. Wolf has proposed a reduction to 7.99% on Jan. 1, 2023, as well as further cuts in future years.

Regardless, ATI’s move would not affect its bill for the corporate net income tax: The tax applies to profits from operations conducted in Pennsylvania, regardless of where companies are headquartered.

When asked to clarify Ms. Pashman’s statement, Allegheny Conference spokesman Phil Cynar said she did not mean to suggest that the tax was a factor in ATI’s decision.

Advertise with us

“The point around it in the statement was meant to underscore, not define,” Mr. Cynar said. “We know that this rate deters business investment” in the state.

ATI declined to comment on the matter.

One area that could suffer from ATI’s headquarters departure is charitable giving. Corporations generally spend more philanthropically in their hometown.

“Gulf Oil was once considered a model corporate citizen locally because of its local giving and other impacts locally, all of which went away when it left the region” via its merger with Standard Oil of California in 1985, said Mr. Briem, the Pitt economist.

Fortunately, he noted, “this region has an incredible base of philanthropy outside of the corporate sector, so I can’t imagine [ATI’s move] will have a large impact.”

Advertise with us

ATI declined to comment on its corporate giving programs.

The past and the future

If nothing else, ATI’s headquarters move — an announcement made discreetly in a filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission last week — is a blow to Pittsburgh’s historical self-esteem. The company’s roots trace back to the 1700s as a caster of cannonballs to fight the British in the American Revolution.

ATI’s predecessor company, Allegheny Ludlum, was incorporated as Allegheny Steel & Iron in 1901 — the same year that U.S. Steel was founded — during an era that witnessed the creation of many Pittsburgh industrial stalwarts such as H.J. Heinz, PPG Industries, Gulf Oil, Westinghouse and Alcoa. (Alcoa made a move similar to ATI’s in 2006, switching its headquarters to New York, only to relocate its base back to Pittsburgh in 2017. Observers speculated that part of why Alcoa left Pittsburgh was that the Big Apple better suited the cultural and social tastes of then-CEO Alain Belda.)

The modern version of ATI — which employs about 6,000 worldwide — was formed in 1996 through the merger of Allegheny Ludlum Corp. with Southern California-based Teledyne.

Advertise with us

ATI has struggled through the COVID-19 pandemic — posting a loss of $38.2 million in 2021 and $1.6 billion in 2020 — but, due to a restructuring and the recovery of the commercial aerospace market, is projecting a return to profitability in 2022.

Along with the headquarters switch, ATI noted in the SEC filing that it had shortened its name from Allegheny Technologies Inc. to simply ATI Inc.

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.