A cloudy and drizzly backdrop to Black Friday with changes wrought by COVID-19 restrictions did not deter some bargain hunters on what is traditionally one of the year’s biggest shopping days.
People lined up early Friday at the Target store at The Waterfront in Homestead with small crowds at other retail locations around the Pittsburgh area.
It’s not exactly the Black Friday tradition she’s used to, said Jan Jones, who arrived at the Waterfront at 8 a.m. with her daughter.
“My sister always goes, too,” Ms. Jones said, lamenting her absence this year.
Their usual post-Thanksgiving ritual was to hit the stores around 10 p.m. on Thursday. They would start at Toys-R-Us and make their way through the mall, hitting Macy’s and Target.
“But most of the stores weren’t open” Thursday night, Ms. Jones said.
Read More
No matter, the mother-daughter duo had already managed to do “some damage” by 10 a.m. and were planning to do some more at the next stop: Dick’s Sporting Goods.
Although some stores had adjusted their maximum capacity to accommodate social distancing, none appeared anywhere close to reaching it.
Bed, Bath & Beyond would need hundreds more people to bump up against its 533-person limit. Even the 12 people allowed in at a time at Scrubs & Beyond weren’t there.
‘So many unknowns’
How will the day pan out for customers and retailers? While consumer spending has edged up in recent months, analysts say, it is unclear exactly how this holiday season will play out, especially at a time when COVID-19 cases are rising at an alarming rate.
“There are so many unknowns — the economy, COVID, unemployment — that could impact how willing customers are to spend this year,” said Scott Stuart, chief executive of the Chicago-based Turnaround Management Association, a group that represents restructuring professionals.
“We can’t lose sight of the fact that, fundamentally, everything has changed. Will there be more stimulus money? Will people be shy about spending? We just don’t know.”
The National Retail Federation this week projected healthy gains in holiday spending — 3.6% to 5.2% compared with the 3.5% average recorded the past five years — driven in part by grocery sales. The estimate suggests Americans will spend $755 billion to $767 billion. Online sales are expected to grow as much as 30% from last year, to $218 billion.
But despite the rosy outlook, the trade group acknowledges there could be some bumps for an industry that was hurting even before the pandemic.
Dozens of major brands have filed for bankruptcy this year, and many more have announced sweeping store closures and layoffs. Apparel stores and mall chains, which typically rely on holiday sales for a major chunk of their profits, have been among the hardest hit.
“It’s hard to quantify such uncertainty,” Jack Kleinhenz, chief economist at Kleinhenz & Associates Inc., said on a call with reporters this week. The latest forecast, he said, is “part science, part judgment and, of course, part luck.”
Still, retailers are pinning their hopes on an early online shopping season to help make up for months of lost sales. Walmart and Target kicked off holiday sales earlier than ever, in October. Others, such as Best Buy, Amazon and Nordstrom, started offering Black Friday deals online as early as Sunday.
As for online spending, Thanksgiving Day hit a new record with consumers spending $5.1 billion, an increase of 21.5% year-over-year, according to Adobe Analytics data. Close to half (46.5%) of all online sales came from smartphones on Thursday, a new record.
And as the pandemic inspired more retailers to lean into curbside pickup, it turned out that retailers offering the service benefited from a 31% higher conversion rate of traffic to their sites, Adobe found.
Adobe expects Black Friday and Cyber Monday 2020 to still become the two largest online sales days in history. The firm expects Black Friday to come in between $8.9 billion and $10.6 billion.
’I try to space it out’
At Ross Park Mall in Ross, Morgan Dehner said the stores, parking lots and lines to check out were smaller than she predicted.
Ms. Dehner, 28, from Mt. Washington, planned to spend all day Friday shopping for holiday presents for her family but she didn’t get started until later in the morning, hoping to wait out the rush of people in the opening hours.
After a few hours of shopping, the mall was less crowded than she expected.
“Compared to last year — there was nowhere to park, you couldn’t get in and out of any store — and now, I had no problem weaving in and out,” she said. “The lines even to check out were so small.”
Ms. Dehner had purchased a tic-tac-toe set for her niece, a sweater for her mom and a pair of earrings for herself.
A seasoned Black Friday shopper — she had been going since she was in high school — Ms. Dehner had a handful of stores she knew she wanted to visit, including Macy’s, Nordstrom and J.C. Penney.
At the mall, Ms. Dehner said she felt safe. Though there were “stragglers” who didn’t seem to care about following health and safety protocols put in place to prevent the spread of COVID-19, most people were wearing masks and keeping their distance.
The mall was Ms. Dehner’s main stop of the day but not her only one. She was planning to visit Kohl’s, Target and T. J. Maxx.
“I try to space it out so I’m not dragging by the end of the day,” she said.
Getting some culture
At the Culture Shop — a jewelry, accessories and clothing store on Carson Street on the South Side — owner George Andrews said the rush usually starts Friday afternoon and continues through Small Business Saturday.
Black Friday, particularly the morning, is generally reserved for shopping at malls, he said, “but we’ll take you any day you come down.”
On Carson Street, there have been a lot of challenges amid COVID-19, Mr. Andrews said, noting the limits on bars and restaurants and, in particular, a temporary ban on alcohol sales Wednesday evening.
“People are doing the best they can,” he said. “We’re just encouraging people to shop local.”
This holiday season, Mr. Andrews said it’s hard to predict what to expect. The Culture Shop, which was celebrating its 27th birthday Friday, saw an uptick in business this month that he expects to continue.
Making online deals more enticing
In an effort to keep customers shopping from their computer, CBD store Hippie & French offered customers 25% off online sales, higher than what they would find in person, said owner Lindsay French.

With a small store in upper Lawrenceville, Ms. French said she can only accommodate four people at a time these days to keep up with health and safety regulations amid COVID-19.
But even with an online promotion, she saw a steady stream of customers Friday afternoon. Within one hour of being open, she had a customer waiting outside.
“It’s been busy,” Ms. French said. “It hasn’t discouraged people from not coming in.
“I think it’ll be more lucrative for us online this year, or we’re at least encouraging it and people are certainly respecting that,” she said. “Our in-store sales are nowhere near what our online sales are.”
Overall, online sales have increased while in-store sales have dropped about 20% during the past several months of adjusting to COVID-19, Ms. French said.
In the CBD business, online shopping can have different challenges than, say, a clothing or book store.
“You always want to talk to the customer about what’s best for them,” she said. “But a lot of this is trial and error, so you just buy and try something and see what works for you.”
Not a typical year
By mid-morning on Black Friday, parking lots surrounding South Hills Village mall appeared to be about half full. Traffic on Route 19 leading to the shopping complex was light. There were the usual shopper enticements, like a large banner hung from Bed Bath & Beyond on Oxford Drive in Bethel Park proclaiming “25% off entire purchase.”
At Best Buy, a large blue and white sign near the entrance spelled out store expectations: “We wear face coverings, so you stay safe. And in the store, we require customers to wear face coverings so we stay safe.”
Beside it was another sign that read, “Come on in. We’re now open for in-store shopping.”
The Washington Post contributed.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.