WASHINGTON — The promotional video shows Chinese President Xi Jinping smiling next to a shuttered American factory and a montage of workers in black and white. A voice-over by former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee warns that “this iconic American industry will slowly die” if unfair trade practices from China continue, as he calls for penalties on Chinese imports.

The message mirrors that of U.S. steel companies, which have a long history in shaping American trade policy and are enjoying a peak in their lobbying power under the Trump administration.

Yet the unfair trade practice case filed this year — one of the largest of its kind in history — was brought by U.S. manufacturers of kitchen cabinets, a $9 billion industry employing 250,000 workers. The case argues that companies are losing business to much cheaper, ready-to-assemble kitchen cabinets and vanities from China.

Cabinet-making is among dozens of industries that have sought to tap into President Donald Trump’s support for the steel industry, which has enjoyed 25% tariffs on steel imports from China and other countries and duties imposed on a variety of types of foreign-produced steel.

Advertise with us

Since Mr. Trump took office, the U.S. Department of Commerce has commenced 179 investigations on behalf of American industries, more than double the rate of cases brought by the Obama administration, and often finds that import penalties are warranted. The industries include producers of uranium, refillable steel kegs, quartz countertops, hardwood plywood, utility-scale wind towers, copper-based alloys, glycine and acetone.

________________

________________

The cases, while individually small in the grand scheme of global movement of goods, are quietly pushing to reshape trade policy.

To supporters, they have the potential to provide a lifeline to struggling manufacturing sectors. To opponents, the cases are an opportunistic ploy that undermines the bulk of American factories, which they say rely on low-cost movement of goods into the country.

Advertise with us

Decades of trade power

Trade cases have been playing out in Washington long before Mr. Trump’s fixation on tariffs.

Concerns about trade’s effect on American manufacturing grew in the 1980s, amid the rise of Japan and trade spats with Europe, said Paul Rosenthal, a law partner with Washington, D.C.-based Kelley Drye & Warren LLP.

When Mr. Rosenthal joined the firm in 1981, he helped represent Pennsylvania steel producers like Allegheny Ludlum (now Pittsburgh-based Allegheny Technologies Inc.), Bethlehem Steel and the United Steelworkers union in trade cases before the Reagan administration.

In 1984, President Ronald Reagan, though a firm believer in free trade, caved to the steel lobby and called for voluntary agreements with foreign producers to limit their shipments to the United States.

Advertise with us

Reagan used section 232 tariffs, which are imposed on national security grounds, on imports of machine tools from Japan and Taiwan and Section 301 tariffs on imports of pasta from Europe. Mr. Rosenthal was representing the Hershey Pasta Company, then the United States’ largest pasta producer.

“Everything you’re hearing about today — all these statutes that are being criticized as controversial — were being used in the ’80s by Reagan, a so-called free trader,” Mr. Rosenthal said.

Two decades later, President George W. Bush, also a free trader, imposed tariffs of 15% to 30% on steel imports coming from countries like China, Japan and South Korea, using yet another statute: the Section 201 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1974.

But Mr. Bush, facing a flagging economy in the early 2000s and the threat of retaliatory tariffs, backed down from a possible trade war and removed tariffs less than two years later.

A surge in imports

Advertise with us

Today, the steel industry is seen as powerful once again, with a White House eager to take on China’s trade policies.

“The president and the people around him came in with a different perspective on steel trade issues,” said Kevin Dempsey, senior vice president of public policy and general counsel for the American Iron and Steel Institute, the predominant steel industry organization in Washington.

Rising U.S. steel demand following the Great Recession had been met largely by a surge of low-priced Chinese imports, Mr. Dempsey said. The industry hit a bottom around 2015, a year when U.S. Steel lost $1.6 billion and Mr. Trump’s campaign started gathering steam.

While individual trade cases had long been the “bread and butter” of steel companies, Mr. Dempsey said, the industry lobbied for something bigger. The steel import tariffs of 25%, based on Section 232’s national security grounds, were imposed in March 2018 on most countries.

“The administration came in with somewhat fresh eyes and said, ‘What we’re doing by itself is not enough,’” Mr. Dempsey said.

Advertise with us

Steel-making companies spent $12.3 million on lobbying expenses in 2018, more than any year on record at OpenSecrets, which has lobbying data going back to 1998. The industry is on track to come near that mark again this year.

The steel tariffs launched Mr. Trump’s broader trade war with China. Last year, Mr. Trump slapped 25% tariffs on $300 billion of Chinese imports and 10% on another $250 billion, and he imposed additional tariffs Sept. 1.

A debate over dumping

A growing undercurrent of the trade war can be seen in trade cases filed by U.S. companies seeking protections from what they claim is Chinese dumping of government-subsidized products.

They form organizations that lobby in Washington — the American Coalition for Acetone Fair Trade, the Coalition for Hardwood Plywood, the Wind Tower Trade Coalition.

Advertise with us

They square off against lawyers who have long represented American firms that import steel and who argue that U.S. manufacturing benefits from low restrictions on the global flow of goods.

“Who’s buying rolls of steel? It’s industry — it’s companies who also employ a lot of people,” said Matthew Nicely, a trade lawyer with Hughes Hubbard and Reed.

Mr. Nicely, the lead counsel on the kitchen cabinets case who has also represented steel importers, said importers can struggle to gain a cohesive political message because they are spread out across large and complex supply chains.

For years, policy-makers have made “the choice to support steel mills at the expense of a huge portion of the economy whose voice gets drowned out, I think, because they’re so disparate,” he said.

More recently, the battles seen in steel have carried over to other products. The Commerce Department has issued a slew of determinations that assess penalties based on how cheaply foreign companies are selling their products.

Advertise with us

Prices of refillable steel kegs from Mexico are 18% cheaper than fair competitive value, the agency found in August — a win for the American Keg Company, based in Pottstown, Pa., which brought the case.

In the past two months alone, the department also found dumping margins for acetone from Spain as high as 172%; magnesium from Israel as high as 193%; glycine, a food additive, from Thailand as high as 227%; metal filing cabinets from China as high as 227%; utility-scale wind towers from South Korea as high as 331%.

“The way we have approached trade has sent a message to American industries that we are acutely concerned by unfair trade circumstances and willing to take action to offset those circumstances where warranted,” said Kevin Manning, a Commerce Department spokesman.

In at least one recent case, Mr. Trump has sided with importers for fear of supply disruptions.

In July, the administration declined to impose import quotas as requested by two U.S. uranium mining companies who wanted a guaranteed market share on national security grounds. That case was fought by nuclear power plant operators, who use uranium for fuel and warned that electricity prices could rise.

Advertise with us

A new line in the sand

The next major trade battle is being served up in America’s kitchens.

In March, the American Coalition for Kitchen Cabinets, a group of about 50 cabinet manufacturers, filed a case seeking duties on Chinese imports of wooden cabinets and vanities.

In August, the Commerce Department preliminarily imposed duties on three Chinese companies ranging from 11% to 22%. A final determination is expected early next year.

The cabinets case is being argued by Tim Brightbill, a longtime trade lawyer for Washington, D.C.-based Wiley Rein LLP who has represented Charlotte, N.C.-based Nucor Corp., the largest American steel producer.

Advertise with us

In an interview, Mr. Brightbill said other industries were not simply piggy-backing on steel. In trade cases, he said, the government reviews the facts: volume of imports, the pricing of foreign products in the United States, and the magnitude of injury to U.S. firms — measured by lower profits or sales, declines in productivity or market share, among other factors.

“Part of the reason for the surge in cases has been the surge in harm to these industries from China,” Mr. Brightbill said. “This pattern, particularly on China cases, has become evident in a variety of other sectors.”

Mark Trexler watched the decline of furniture production in North Carolina before becoming president and CEO of Texas-based Master WoodCraft Cabinetry and an executive with AC Products Inc., which has two facilities near Harrisburg.

Mr. Trexler estimated that his companies have lost $40 million in jobs to Chinese companies, which bid prices as much as 60% lower.

“We could have made our cabinets with robots and had no labor costs, and they still would’ve beat us,” he said. “We have to win this case for the American worker.”

Advertise with us

But American companies that import Chinese cabinets, represented by the the American Coalition of Cabinet Distributors, say they have innovated to offer customers an affordable alternative to expensive custom-made cabinets.

Tony Laurinaitis founded Choice Cabinet near Cleveland after seeing customers swarm a warehouse of marked-down furniture.

Thirteen years later, his company has grown into a 170,000-square-foot facility employing 50 people that ships cabinets across the country in one or two days. He imports all his supply from China in a ready-to-assemble format, an option that allows landlords to quickly swap out cabinets before a new tenant moves in and home remodelers to save time and money.

“You can put an entire kitchen on one or two pallets,” Mr. Laurinaitis said. “It met a price point.”

If duties are assessed on Chinese imports, he added, “you’re handing out a death sentence.”

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore