The dire warnings began in March, shortly after the Trump administration imposed penalties on imports of steel and aluminum that U.S. manufacturers purchase for use in a wide range of products.
One research group, the Washington, D.C.-based Trade Partnership, predicted nearly 20,000 manufacturing jobs would be lost as a consequence of the March tariffs combined with other countries’ retaliatory tariffs imposed on U.S. exports.
Nine months after the first round of tariffs, the impact of the 2018 trade war is looking far less conclusive.
For the most part, grim predictions by free-trade economic models have not borne out in jobs data. Meanwhile, the renaissance promised by tariff proponents may not be coming as fast as expected.
Instead of losing jobs, the U.S. added 176,000 manufacturing positions from February to October this year, according to an analysis of federal data by the Economic Policy Institute, a Washington, D.C.-based research organization that has advocated for tariffs as job-friendly policy.
“It’s having a tiny, tiny impact” on companies buying steel and aluminum at higher prices, said Rob Scott, EPI’s director of trade and manufacturing policy research who authored the report released this month.
Read More
Mr. Scott found that aluminum producers and processing companies have invested to restart or expand at 26 facilities across the country, promising to spend $3.4 billion and create more than 3,000 jobs. The restart and expansion of four smelters will boost U.S. aluminum production by 67 percent in 2018, he found.
(Mr. Scott’s study of investments covered only the aluminum business, and he plans to issue a report early next year on the steel industry.)

The investments that his report cited included some done by local companies: Pittsburgh-based Alcoa spent $30 million to restart a smelter in Warrick, Ind., creating 275 jobs and adding 160,000 tons of annual capacity.
On the processing side, Arconic, the aluminum products manufacturer that split from Alcoa in 2016, announced the restart of a rolling mill in Nash, Texas, for $14 million that created 285 jobs. Ellwood Group Inc., an Ellwood City-based company, said in September it would spend $60 million to expand a billet casthouse near Youngstown, Ohio.
The EPI study represented a sharp rebuke of the Trade Partnership’s earlier analysis, Mr. Scott said, which used a model based on a “faulty understanding of how trade affects the economy.” It also wrongly assumed the broader economic conditions were worse than reality, he argued, which was a result of “bending over backwards to torture a negative result out of your model.”
Joseph Francois, professor of international economics at the University of Bern in Switzerland who co-authored the Trade Partnership study, acknowledged that jobs had grown over the year but he defended his earlier assumptions.
In an email, he provided an analysis that showed since the tariffs were put into place, manufacturing job growth has slowed, beginning in June. Fabricated metal products, a subset of manufacturing that involves transforming metal into end products, lost jobs in October, he pointed out.
“Different people see different things in the same numbers,” Mr. Francois said.
“Overall, we have a general expansion consistent with energy production and the tail end of the trend lines from the Obama recovery, and no clear pattern of a manufacturing renaissance since the tariffs ... The devil is actually in the details.”
One reason that manufacturing has not suffered a bigger bite could be that the government removed some of the teeth from the tariffs for a number of companies that claimed inescapable hardship.
The U.S. Department of Commerce had granted 12,814 exemptions from the 25 percent steel tariffs as of Dec. 17, according to a Bloomberg Law analysis of filings. The agency granted 896 exemptions from the 10 percent aluminum tariffs, according to the analysis.
Still, there remained 42,978 requests for steel tariff exemptions and 12,814 requests for aluminum tariff exemptions waiting for a ruling.
Last week, the Government Accountability Office announced plans for an audit into how the Trump administration approves or denies exemption requests, an unusual administrative process that has been criticized as opaque. Republican Pennsylvania Sen. Pat Toomey, a vocal critic of the tariffs, asked for the GAO investigation along with Democrats Tom Carper of Delaware and Doug Jones of Alabama.
Around Pittsburgh, the biggest impacts of the trade war may have yet to be felt.
The pace of job growth in the region has, for the most part, stayed in line with the year before, and unemployment remained near historic lows. In the most recent workforce report, manufacturing jobs grew by nearly 2 percent over the year, consistent with job growth seen prior to the tariffs.
But Allegheny Technologies Inc., the Pittsburgh-based specialty metals producer, is still waiting on a request it filed in April to exempt imported steel shipments to its Midland mill in Beaver County.
That plant was restarted last year as a joint venture with a Chinese company, creating 100 local jobs. ATI warned the government that tariffs could jeopardize operations at the plant.
Other companies — ranging from bicycle shops to nail distributors to the makers of water pumps in Point State Park fountain — have warned of longer-term struggles if the tariffs persist through next year.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.