As U.S. Steel blamed cheap imports for hundreds of millions of dollars of losses in recent years, the troubled Pittsburgh steel producer simultaneously touted hundreds of millions of dollars of savings from its Carnegie Way efficiency campaign.
Could the seeming irreconcilability of those numbers be explained by a federal lawsuit filed against U.S. Steel, its current and former CEO, and others?
The lawsuit — the merger of shareholder complaints filed after U.S. Steel stock tumbled 27 percent on news of a stunning first quarter 2017 loss — was filed in federal court in Pittsburgh in October. It alleges that “the Carnegie Way was a sham” based on “fabricated cost savings.”
Citing accounts from 11 confidential witnesses and former U.S. Steel chief operating officer John Goodish, the lawsuit contends the efficiency initiative — advertised as including employee engagement and a disciplined, proactive approach to maintenance — was nothing more than ruthless cost cutting backed by questionable math.
The calculations included recording the difference between the lowest and highest bids from vendors as savings. Other witnesses said savings from some projects were counted before the projects were completed. There was also a tendency to deem projects completed near a quarter’s end so the savings could be included in quarterly results, according to the lawsuit.
Vrakas v USS, Longhi Et Al (PDF)
Read More
Vrakas v USS, Longhi Et Al (Text)
The rebuttal from the folks at 600 Grant St. is no harm, no foul, based on the stock price and other factors.
U.S. Steel’s attorneys say the 168-page complaint is based on “off-the-record kvetching from a handful of employees.”
The lawsuit makes no claims that any of the company’s financial statements were false. Moreover, U.S. Steel’s stock price, earnings and cash position all improved over the period that shareholders claimed they were defrauded, company lawyers said in a motion to dismiss the lawsuit.
“There is something odd about a complaint alleging a stock swindle over a period in which the subject stock tripled in price and outperformed every relevant index,” the company’s lawyers told the court.
The period covered by the complaint began in January 2016, when U.S. Steel reported that — a $1.6 billion 2015 loss notwithstanding — the company had “achieved sustainable cost improvements through process efficiencies and our investments in reliability centered maintenance.”
Then CEO Mario Longhi, identified in the lawsuit as “the brainchild behind the dismally failing Carnegie Way initiative,” cited $815 million in savings from the campaign in 2015. Another $745 million in Carnegie Way benefits were realized in 2016, when losses narrowed to $440 million. More than 1,000 Carnegie Way projects were completed during the period covered by the lawsuit, U.S. Steel’s attorneys said in a court filing.
That period ended in April 2017, when every other major steel producer posted hefty first-quarter profits except U.S. Steel, which lost $180 million.
Mr. Longhi announced his retirement a short time later and was replaced by then-CFO David Burritt, who is also being sued. Shareholders allege the loss was proof that the Pittsburgh company had crippled its mills by breaking its pledge to maintain them and was relying strictly on cost cutting.
That’s not what Mr. Longhi and other company officials were telling shareholders, the lawsuit states.
“We continue to implement our reliability centered maintenance process. … The benefits are starting to be reflected in fewer unplanned outages and lower maintenance costs,” U.S. Steel said when reporting first-quarter 2016 results.
In reality, the lawsuit argued, U.S. Steel was putting off much needed maintenance through a policy of “don’t buy, get by.”
Maintenance budgets were reduced, requests for spare parts were harder to approve, and thousands of experienced workers were laid off and replaced by inexperienced, poorly trained workers, which caused more operating problems and jeopardized safety, the lawsuit states. Consequently, output fell and the company failed to capitalize on improving market conditions, the lawsuit claims.
Shareholders also claim the false narrative about the Carnegie Way infected disclosures that the company made when it raised $482 million through a secondary stock offering in August 2016. So they also are suing the Wall Street firms that were underwriters for that offering.
U.S. Steel’s motion to dismiss the complaint is currently before U.S. District Judge Cathy Bissoon.
USS, Underwriters Motion to Dismiss Vrakas (PDF)
USS, Underwriters Motion to Dismiss Vrakas (Text)
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.