Three suburban Pittsburgh apartment complexes were part of what a federal indictment describes as a multifamily knockoff of the fraudulent mortgage scams that contributed to the 2008 financial crisis.

A federal grand jury in western New York has indicted four men on charges that they provided false information to secure loans on three Western Pennsylvania apartment complexes as well as multifamily units in Buffalo, Syracuse and Avon, N.Y. All of the complexes are owned by Morgan Management, a Pittsford, N.Y., real estate company headed by Robert Morgan.

Named in court documents are Rochester Village Apartments at Park Place and Eden Square Apartments, both in Cranberry, and Reserve at Southpointe in Cecil. Spokespeople at the three complexes declined comment.

The May 22 indictment said the loans would never have been issued, or the apartments would not have received as much financing, if the men had been truthful about the apartments’ income. One of those indicted, Frank Giacobbe, owner of Aurora Capital Advisors, a Buffalo mortgage broker, received more than $1.6 million for brokering loans for the apartments, according to the indictment.

Advertise with us

Leading up to the 2008 financial industry crisis, mortgage lenders falsified income and other information that was used as a basis for issuing mortgages on single-family homes. The loans were subsequently packaged together and sold as low-risk investments. When borrowers defaulted, investors holding the loans lost billions of dollars.

According to the indictment by the New York grand jury, a similar process was used at the apartment complexes in this case.

The fraudulently obtained mortgages were packaged and sold to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, two lenders that purchase mortgages made by other lenders to increase the amount of financing available to home buyers. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were seized by the government in the summer of 2008 after suffering spectacular losses during the mortgage crisis.

In addition to Mr. Giacobbe, the grand jury indicted Patrick Ogiony, who worked for Aurora; Kevin Morgan, a nephew of Robert Morgan; and Todd Morgan, Robert Morgan’s son.

The indictment followed Buffalo News reports that loans at Morgan Management properties apparently exceeded the purchase prices listed on government documents or were for more than 80 percent of the appraised value of the property.

Advertise with us

How did the four men do it?

At Rochester Village, they inflated income that the complex was generating from storage units, falsified spreadsheets indicating which apartments were occupied and how much rent tenants were paying, and reported that certain units were occupied before government officials issued occupancy permits, according to the indictment. Mr. Giacobbe received $460,000 from a $45.8 million loan issued by Berkadia Commercial Mortgage in May 2015.

But they didn’t stop there. The indictment indicates the four men dressed up one apartment to make it look occupied, and turned on radios and left mats and shoes outside apartments to make inspectors think tenants were living in the units.

According to the indictment, at one point in the scheme, Mr. Giacobbe sent an email to the other three defendants stating: “Guys now is not the time for the TRUTH!”

At Eden Square, three of the defendants provided Berkadia with falsified occupancy data and altered leases that misstated rent and fees tenants were paying, according to the indictment. Mr. Giacobbe received $210,000 when the lender provided a $42 million loan in December 2016.

Advertise with us

About three months later, the company servicing the loan received information from an Eden Square employee that the complex was less than 70 percent occupied, the indictment states.

At the Cecil apartments, the four men inflated the number of storage spaces and parking spots available, inflated income from storage units and other sources, and falsified rent rolls.

An appraisal of the complex, based in part on the false information, valued the property at $60.5 million. Arbor Commercial Mortgage subsequently provide a $45 million loan in June 2016, with Mr. Giacobbe receiving $337,500 of the proceeds, according to court documents.

Lawyers for Mr. Giacobbe, Mr. Ogiony and Kevin Morgan did not respond to an email seeking comment.

David Rothenberg, who represents Todd Morgan, said his client has pleaded not guilty.

Advertise with us

“We maintain not only that the government cannot meet its burden, but that Todd Morgan is innocent of the charges,” Mr. Rothenberg said.

Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.