The derailment of a Norfolk Southern train near Station Square this week gave Pittsburghers a rare peek inside ubiquitous freight trains that rumble through the region: Seven crumpled rail cars dumped piles of Pampers diapers, cat food, Hanover Snyder snacks, detergent and mouthwash.
The derailment — which was cleared Wednesday but has shut down Carson Street and badly damaged the T commuter rail line — was also a highly visible reminder of safety concerns that had largely fallen off the radar after politicians and advocacy groups sounded the alarm a few years ago.
Those concerns could emerge once again as U.S. freight rail companies rely more on shipping consumer goods using double-stacked trains and put more tankers of crude oil, petroleum products and hazardous materials on the rails.
Such conversations have proven difficult to sustain, given the nature of the risk and the enormity of the railroad business.
For one, a derailment is a remarkably rare event, especially given the volume of rail traffic. Federal statistics show a continued decline in both the number of derailments and the derailment rate — a fact the rail industry frequently points out. Derailments dropped to 1.74 for every million train-miles in 2017, down from a rate of 8.98 per million train-miles in 1980.
Regulators also tend to give the major rail companies — in Pittsburgh, Virginia-based Norfolk Southern and Jacksonville, Fla.-based CSX Transportation operate the two interstate main lines — flexibility with their operations.
Read More
Companies carry out their own track inspections and decide when to dispatch trains, for example, and federal and state rail regulators can’t possibly check all the logs. Pennsylvania alone has about 5,000 miles of track. Any regulation that would result in higher costs for rail companies could raise wholesale prices on a wide range of products, the industry has argued.
Still, when derailments do occur, they can cause extensive damage and put lives at risk.
4,000 derailed freight trains
Derailments are most often caused by track defects and human error, according to statistics from the Federal Railroad Administration. And some track inspectors have reported that the more traffic on the rails, the harder it is to get time to find flaws and repair tracks.
Since 2015, more than 4,000 freight trains have derailed across the country, causing $761 million in damage. In Allegheny County alone, 18 trains have jumped the tracks since 2015, causing a total of nearly $1 million in damage.
Though oil remains a small fraction of what railroads ship, the industry is seeing the biggest annual increases this year in that category, as drillers tap into shale formations once more with oil prices rising 35 percent over the year.
U.S. railroads shipped 10,837 carloads of petroleum and petroleum products during the week ending Aug. 4, up 16 percent higher during the same week one year ago, according to rail traffic numbers updated Wednesday by the American Association of Railroads.
So far in 2018, rail lines have shipped 326,481 carloads for the oil industry, up 10 percent from last year, according to the Washington, D.C.-based trade group composed of the North American freight railroads, as well as Amtrak.
Consumer goods and crude oil boost busy freight rail lines in 2018 Freight shipments on U.S. railroads continue to increase this year, thanks to increases from intermodal containers carrying a variety of consumer goods. Crude oil, a small part of total rail shipments, is also sharply rising in 2018. U.S. carloads, by product, 2017 vs. 2018 (as of August 4)
Created with Highstock 6.1.19.5%9.5%6.1%6.1%3.8%3.8%3.1%3.1%3%3%2.5%2.5%2.1%2.1%1.9%1.9%-0.4%-0.4%-1%-1%-2.7%-2.7%Petroleum and petroleum productsTotal intermodal unitsChemicalsNonmetallic mineralsMetallic ores and metalsGrainForest productsFarm products, excluding grain, foodCoalMotor vehicles and partsOther0%10%-5%-2.5%2.5%5%7.5%12.…12.5%
Carloads in U.S., by product, 2018 year to date (as of August 4)
Created with Highstock 6.1.18 ,550 ,0008 ,550 ,0002 ,570 ,0002 ,570 ,0001 ,120 ,0001 ,120 ,0001 ,000 ,0001 ,000 ,000721 ,070721 ,070715 ,158715 ,158510 ,787510 ,787501 ,825501 ,825326 ,481326 ,481318 ,226318 ,226294 ,678294 ,678Total intermodal unitsCoalNonmetallic mineralsChemicalsGrainMetallic ores and metalsMotor vehicles and partsFarm products, excluding grain, foodPetroleum and petroleum productsForest productsOther1/202M4M6M8M10M12M14M16M18M
Source: American Association of Railroads weekly rail traffic report | James Hilston/Post-Gazette
Yet it’s been three years since oil shipments grabbed the attention of local and state officials.
In 2015, a push for safety measures seemed to reach a fever pitch after a string of fiery derailments across the continent, including an explosion in 2013 that killed 47 people in downtown Lac-Mégantic, Quebec.
In 2015, after an oil train derailment near Charleston, W.Va., forced the evacuation of 100 people, Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf hired a rail consultant to conduct a study that offered 27 recommendations for both state agencies and rail operators.
That same year: Sen. Bob Casey pushed for increased training of first responders. A day-long oil train safety conference at the University of Pittsburgh convened by the Heinz Endowments featured two dozen speakers from across the country. A report from PennEnvironment and FracTracker found 183,000 people in Pittsburgh lived within an evacuation zone of a crude oil route.
Then the issue virtually disappeared as oil prices fell precipitously and the oil trains pulled back.
Using tech to improve safety
That could be because derailments are becoming more infrequent as rail companies use technologies like ultrasound and software platforms that can comb through terrabytes of data to search for irregularities in rail, said Allan Zarembski, the researcher who Gov. Wolf hired in 2015.
“Railroads continue to employ very sophisticated inspection technologies, and they keep improving,” said Mr. Zarembski, a professor of civil and environmental engineering at the University of Delaware.
The rail industry has also taken other measures to improve safety, said Jessica Kahanek, a spokeswoman for the American Association of Railroads.
“Railroads are committed to moving crude oil safely and securely, and the vast majority of all crude oil shipments (more than 99.99 percent) reach their destination without incident,” Ms. Kahanek said.
Railroads have expanded rail traffic routing technology that determines the safest route for the longest crude oil trains based on 27 risk factors — including the hazards of the commodity, trip length, population density along the route and track quality.
The rail industry also developed a new curriculum and training on how to respond to a crude oil emergency at the industry’s Transportation Technology Center in Pueblo, Colo. More than 60,000 first responders have received hazmat training at the industry’s facility, according to Ms. Kahanek.
Railroads are also meeting deadlines set by a 2015 rule issued by the U.S. Department of Transportation that, in part, requires railroads to use newer models of tank cars to haul crude oil, ethanol and other substances the agency considers high-hazard and flammable.
A spokeswoman reported on Thursday that there had been “no issues meeting the phase-out of DOT-111s,” referring to the oldest legacy model of tanker car. Most recently, railroads met the March 1, 2018 deadline to phase out DOT-111 cars carrying crude oil and the most hazardous category of materials, according to the agency.
Rail operators are now working to meet the next deadline of April 1, 2020 to phase out a newer model, called a CPC-1232, that does not have an insulating layer — cars that are still hauling crude oil and the most hazardous materials.
Slowing down trains?
As for Mr. Zarembski’s report recommending 27 changes for both state agencies and rail operators, J.J. Abbott, a spokesman for Gov. Wolf’s office, said the Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency and Public Utility Commission had taken them seriously.
The state continues to work with the companies and local emergency planning committees to identify gaps in contingency plans, Mr. Abbott said.
Norfolk Southern and CSX did not heed a central recommendation: a voluntary speed limit reduction to 35 miles per hour from 40 miles per hour through cities with populations greater than 100,000.
“The state doesn’t have any authority to force the rail companies to adopt that rule because they are national companies regulated at the federal level,” Mr. Abbott said. “We continue to believe this reduction should occur.”
The Station Square derailment may once again put the issue front of mind.
Visiting the site earlier this week, Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto said the city “dodged a bullet on this one” and that it “could’ve been a catastrophe.”
The Port Authority of Allegheny County said that if the train had derailed just two minutes earlier, the cars would have tumbled onto a light-rail passenger train below.
The cause of the accident, in which no one was seriously hurt, is not publicly known. The Federal Railroad Administration is investigating.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.