McMahon Steel Supply’s Ronnie Smith is “discouraged, frustrated” by the U.S. Commerce Department’s decision to deny the company relief from the 25 percent tariffs President Donald Trump slapped on imported steel in March.
The family-owned Houston, Texas, steel supplier submitted about a dozen requests to waive the duties on imported steel used by the energy industry because two domestic producers — U.S. Steel and Timken Steel — said they couldn’t make it. In an email, Mr. Smith said two sets of attorneys looked at the detailed technical information on the applications before they were submitted to the Commerce Department.
Agency officials followed up, asking for additional information, which Mr. Smith said McMahon provided.
Yet Commerce denied the requests, saying only that the applications were incomplete.
“We are discouraged, frustrated and of the opinion this was all just a political exercise to blindly supplement the domestic steel industry and provide leverage for international trade negotiations,” Mr. Smith said in the email.
Some attorneys representing steel importers feel the same.
They question whether Commerce Department officials know enough about how different grades of steel are made and used to decide more than 20,000 requests for tariff relief. They also say the agency is not explaining the rationale for its decisions, leading to speculation that the agency is giving the benefit of the doubt to domestic steel producers. To importers, it seems that if a U.S. steel producer objects to their request, Commerce is more likely to deny it and make the importer pay 25 percent more.
“No one knows what their criteria are because they are not telling,” said one trade attorney who asked not to be identified.
When asked to provide a document or spokesperson to explain the criteria, including how the objections of U.S. producers are weighed, a Commerce Department spokesman provided Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross’ June 20 testimony to the Senate Finance Committee.
Mr. Ross, who formerly owned a U.S. steel company, told the panel the requests are being reviewed “on a case-by-case basis in a fair and transparent process.” The bulk of his testimony was on how imports threaten national security and the need to revitalize the U.S. steel industry.
Robert Shapiro, a Washington, D.C. attorney who represents importers seeking exclusions as well as domestic producers that object to them, said the agency’s reasoning is not clear to him.
“Their decisions really don’t give you any analysis on how they reached their decision,” said Mr. Shapiro, who works for the firm of Thompson Coburn. “If there aren’t objections, there is a greater likelihood that you will get [tariff relief].”
Mr. Shapiro was not surprised by what happened with McMahon Steel’s applications.
In its requests, the Houston company said U.S. Steel and Timken told them they couldn’t make the steel in question. But Canton, Ohio-based Timken objected to McMahon’s requests, telling Commerce officials the company and other U.S. producers can make the steel to the specifications and in the volumes McMahon needs.
“There is no basis to grant this exclusion request,” Timken said in objecting to McMahon’s request to waive the tariff on 88 metric tons of Japanese pipe and tube.
Mr. Smith was shocked by Timken’s objections because the company had told McMahon verbally that it could not make chrome-based steel or products more than 13 inches in diameter.
U.S. Steel did not object to McMahon’s application. But the Pittsburgh steelmaker has objected to other tariff relief requests that were subsequently denied.
Mr. Smith said his research indicates that when U.S. steelmakers object, most if not all of the requests to waive the 25 percent penalty have been denied.
Longtime metals industry analyst Charles Bradford questioned whether the Commerce Department officials reviewing the applications are familiar enough with how steel is made and used.
“Steel is a lot more complex than a lot of these people seem to understand,” he said.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.