As prices plummeted and U.S. tastes for fluid milk waned, the dairy industry’s optimistic refrain for the last few years has been: China loves our cheese.
It was true. In November, even as the Trump administration ratcheted up trade rhetoric with several countries, China lowered its U.S. cheese tariffs from 12 percent to 8 percent — giving American dairy farmers a competitive advantage against other major exporters in Europe and New Zealand.
In June, the goodwill evaporated as Chinese authorities imposed 25 percent tariffs on a long list of U.S. dairy products, including whole and skim milk powder, cream, butter, yogurt, buttermilk, whey and, yes, cheese — American, Gouda, mozzarella and blue among them.
China was hitting back just days after the U.S. had announced tariffs on $34 billion of Chinese goods.
Milk futures, after averaging $17 per hundredweight in April, have fallen to less than $15 this month — a drop that Jayne Sebright attributes in large part to the “trade wars.”
“We have seen the huge impact trade opportunities, or the lack of those opportunities, can have on our milk price,” wrote Ms. Sebright, executive director of the Harrisburg-based Center for Dairy Excellence, in an article that published this weekend in Lancaster Farming magazine.
Read More
But it seems many farmers don’t see that connection.
Ms. Sebright recalled a four-stop trip a few weeks ago in Western Pennsylvania, joined by Russell Redding, the secretary of the Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture.
The dairy community repeatedly brought up concerns about Obama-era regulations that banned whole milk from school lunches and discussed the industry’s effort to remove the word “milk” from cartons of liquids made from almond, coconut and soy.
“Not one person asked about what we could do to create more opportunities to move milk and dairy products beyond our borders,” she wrote. “The reason milk prices have fallen back so much since the trade wars began is because two months of our annual milk production is exported.”
Pennsylvania’s dairy industry includes 6,500 family farms, 52,000 jobs and $15 billion in economic benefits, according to the organization, which promotes dairies statewide.
The new tariffs have dimmed hopes for one of the few growing markets for the industry. Like many U.S. companies, dairy farmers have increasingly relied on the population boom and growing middle class in emerging markets like China.
April marked the highest-ever volume of U.S. dairy exports. American dairies sent abroad 213,115 tons of products — 19 percent of total U.S. dairy production — up 31 percent from the previous April and valued at $518 million, according to the U.S. Dairy Export Council.
“Farmers, after three years of mediocre prices, were very excited and looking at the fall ... prices were actually good,” said Jaime Castaneda, senior vice president of trade policy at the Arlington, Va.-based trade organization.
In addition to Chinese tariffs, Mexico and Canada have imposed trade barriers to retaliate against the new U.S. tariffs on steel and aluminum.
Mexico — Pennsylvania’s largest dairy export market with $23 million in exports in 2017 — recently slapped tariffs of 25 percent on most American-made cheeses. Canada has imposed tariffs on yogurt.
“We definitely believe retaliatory tariffs from Mexico and China have been the primary source of lower prices,” Mr. Castaneda said.
Since, as with other commodities, dairy is beholden to broad price swings caused by a number of factors — the global trade wars affect even those farms that have no business abroad.
“Farmers tend not to think past their backyard, even though global issues significantly affect the milk prices,” Ms. Sebright said in an email, adding that her column in Lancaster Farming was intended to encourage farmers to “think beyond their neighborhood and realize that dairy pricing is a global issue.”
Carissa Itle Westrick, the director of business development at Vale Wood Farms, a family-owned dairy processor in Cambria County, said she has been watching the markets closely. The farm in Loretto processes its own milk as well as milk from three neighboring farms within about an hour away.
“Tariffs that potentially decrease demand for those products will end up negatively impacting our price of milk, even though not one drop of our farm's milk leaves our little neck of the woods,” Ms. Westrick said.
“Even though we're processing our own milk, we have to price our products competitively — especially for wholesale accounts like schools or stores or retirement homes,” she added. “Factors that impact national market prices — export volumes, a strong dollar, potential tariffs — have far reaching impacts in pricing farm products, even locally.”
The trade problems are hitting at a tough time. Ms. Sebright’s statewide group had launched a unprecedented marketing campaign in late May.
The campaign of billboards, radio ads and social media was intended to ride public sympathy following Dean Foods’s decision to end contracts with dairy farms in Pennsylvania and other states.
The “Choose PA Dairy: Goodness That Matters” campaign aims to encourage consumers to buy milk produced from Pennsylvania dairies as a way to boost the economy. A new website, www.ChoosePADairy.com, features a map that plots milk distributors so consumers can find local brands.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.