Just when things were starting to look up for ExOne Co., CEO James McCarley suddenly announced he is leaving the North Huntingdon 3-D printing concern and joining the ranks of those pursuing other opportunities.
ExOne’s June 21 post-market announcement came as the company’s shares, which haven’t hit double digits since the market peaked in January, were rebounding from a $6.47 close six days earlier. After briefly topping $8, they finished Thursday at $7.16. That leaves them down 15 percent for the year.
Mr. McCarley, who previously held executive positions at RTI International Metals and Precision Castparts, was replaced by executive chairman S. Kent Rockwell, whose 28 percent stake in the company makes him ExOne’s largest shareholder. A venture capitalist and son of famed industrialist Willard Rockwell, Mr. Rockwell served as CEO before Mr. McCarley arrived in August 2016.
When it debuted as a public company in 2013, ExOne was one of the region’s greatest hopes for a manufacturing renaissance based on 3-D printing. The technology uses digital images to produce products or components from a variety of materials, including metals, plastic and fabric. ExOne specializes in industrial printing, with customers in the aerospace, automotive, foundry and other industries.
After going public in February 2013 at $18 per share, ExOne shares were fetching more than $75 six months later, riding a 3-D printing stock bubble that would soon burst. The stock has trended lower ever since, making ExOne the fourth-worst performing regional stock since the company’s initial public offering.
Financial results haven’t helped. ExOne has never had a profitable year, losing $14.6 million in 2016, $20 million last year, and $6.4 million in the first quarter this year. First-quarter sales rose 9 percent to $11.9 million. The results fell short of Wall Street estimates.
Nevertheless, Mr. McCarley was upbeat about adoption of ExOne’s 3-D printing technology during a May 10 first-quarter conference call with analysts.
“Every leading indicator we have observed over the last year, but particularly in the last six months, is showing positive trends,” he told them.
Mr. McCarley expressed confidence that ExOne can grow revenue faster than 20 percent “for the foreseeable future.” The backlog of orders at the end of the first quarter was $26.1 million, up 20 percent from year-end.
Mr. McCarley was the second RTI veteran to leave ExOne this year. Chief commercial officer Mark Cianci, who like Mr. McCarley worked at RTI and Precision Castparts, resigned in February.
The CEO’s departure took analyst Christopher Van Horn, who tracks ExOne for investment banker B. Riley FBR, by surprise. But he is maintaining his buy rating on the company, projecting a price target of $13 for the company’s shares.
“Overall, we remain positive on the stock and think a fresh vision for the company could drive shares higher,” Mr. Van Horn wrote in a June 22 note to clients.
Canaccord Genuity analyst Robert Burleson also has a “buy” rating on ExOne, albeit with a $12 price target.
Mr. Van Horn said ExOne’s binder jet printing technology can quickly print high-volume products.
“We also continue to view this company as the best candidate for a takeout within our 3-D printing coverage because it is laser focused on industrial printing applications,” he wrote.
Mr. Van Horn noted that merger and acquisition activity in the 3-D printing space is on the rise and that price tags on some recent acquisitions have been well above assumptions he used to set his $13 price target.
The analyst said ExOne’s earnings have never been strong enough to generate a surplus of free cash flow. Mr. Van Horn believes the company has enough cash to make it through this year and next. But he warned that if cash flow does not improve, “it is possible that the firm would face a liquidity crunch.”
ExOne addressed the potential need for cash in March when it laid the groundwork for offering up to $125 million in common and preferred stock, debt and other securities sometime in the future. In a U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filing, the company said proceeds from any future securities sales would be used for working capital, capital expenditures and other general corporate purposes.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.