Buy American proponents may want to think twice the next time they reach for a can of Pam cooking spray or Gillette Foamy shaving cream from their supermarket aisles.
Because U.S. steel producers can’t make the tin-free, laminated steel used to package the ubiquitous products.
Thus sayeth DS Containers, a Batavia, Ill., company that supplies cans to the makers of those products. DSC is asking the U.S. Department of Commerce to exempt the foreign-made metal from the 25 percent tariffs President Donald Trump imposed on steel imports in March.
“Not only do U.S. producers not manufacture the product, they have shown no interest in investing in the necessary production and test machinery,” DSC CEO Bill Smith told Commerce Department officials in an April 23 letter.
Mr. Smith told the agency that his company may cancel plans for a new production line or lay off workers unless it is exempted from the tariffs, which apply to the 650 metric tons it plans to purchase from Japanese steelmaker JFE this year.
Companies that rely on imports have asked that more than 5,000 different sizes, shapes and blends of steel be exempted from the penalties. U.S. producers and others have 30 days to object to the requests. The Commerce Department hopes to make a decision within 60 days after that.

Steel industry analysts and trade attorneys question whether the timetable is realistic.
That’s because the agency must determine whether the importers’ highly technical claims about not being able to buy or use American steel are legitimate or just a dodge to buy cheaper steel. The legitimacy of U.S. steel producers’ assertions that they can make the quality and quantity of steel that the importers need and deliver it on time also must be analyzed.
The requests are a stark reminder of steel that isn’t made here any more — and of the damage done by cheap, government-subsidized imports. They also raise questions about U.S. steelmakers’ willingness to modernize and invest in research and development, as well as their ability to deliver a quality product on time.
Mapes Piano String Co. of Elizabethton, Tenn., doesn’t want to pay tariffs on 400 metric tons of steel wire rod it expects to purchase from Japan’s Nippon Steel & Sumitomo Metal Corp. this year. Eric Wright, who works in Mapes’ purchasing department, said it has been years since extinct Bethlehem Steel and other U.S. producers have made the high carbon content steel needed to produce premium piano strings.
Independent Can Co. president Rick Huether said he bought only American steel until about 10 years ago. Since then, the Belcamp, Md., company has invested in more efficient equipment that uses 48-inch wide sheet steel.
U.S. Steel, Independent’s main supplier, doesn’t make sheet that wide, he said. The Pittsburgh steelmaker’s quality and on-time performance have also been problems, Mr. Huether said.
“U.S. Steel’s election not to follow through with planned capital investments in tin mill processing equipment has resulted in U.S. Steel not being capable of producing the material needed,” Mr. Huether told Commerce Department officials.
Independent is asking that 3,100 metric tons of steel it plans to import from Germany’s ThyssenKrupp be exempted from the tariffs.
U.S. Steel has objected to some of the steel importers requests. As of Thursday afternoon, the Commerce Department had not posted a U.S. Steel objection to Independent Can’s filing.
Union Pacific Railroad wants to import durable, 480-foot steel rails that the Omaha, Neb., railroad says American steel producers don’t make.
The long rails mean there are fewer welds along the track where defects can develop, leading to derailments and delays. Using the longer, harder rails has improved track safety, Union Pacific told Commerce in its request to exempt 120,000 metric tons of rail it expects to import from Nippon Steel & Sumitomo Metal.
The railroad told the agency that it buys about 30 percent of its rail from U.S. steelmakers. Most of that comes in 80-foot lengths, which means more welds and greater potential for track breaks.
Steel Dynamics of Fort Wayne, Ind. supplies 320-foot rails, but they are not as durable as the Japanese steelmaker’s 480-foot versions, Union Pacific told Commerce.
These are only a few of the problems that U.S. steel users outline in the thousand of exclusion requests they have laid at the Commerce Department’s doorstep. The growing stacks of digital documentation indicate that the import problem Mr. Trump is so eager to address may require a more nuanced solution than slapping on a 25 percent tariff and calling it a day.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.