When U.S. Steel announced Wednesday it was calling back 500 workers to restart a blast furnace at its Granite City, Ill., mill, the news was hailed as evidence of the restorative powers of the across-the-board penalties President Donald Trump is slapping on steel and aluminum imports.
However, the Pittsburgh steelmaker’s decision is one piece of a complex puzzle that many say requires a more nuanced solution than the blunt weapon Mr. Trump is using to fight the trauma U.S. steel and aluminum producers say they have suffered at the hands of subsidized, unfairly traded imports.
Critics warn the sweeping measure threatens far more jobs in metals consuming industries than steel and aluminum producers will create as a result of the new protections. They also contend it will anger major trading partners, invite retaliation in the form of tariffs on U.S. exports, and doesn’t address the main issue: China’s massive steel and aluminum industries.
Another piece of the puzzle lies one hour north of Pittsburgh in the distressed towns of Farrell and Sharon. There, Russian steel producer NLMK is worried that paying 25 percent more for the steel slabs it imports — the extra costs imposed by the new tariffs — threatens the jobs of its 800 Western Pennsylvania workers.
“We’re part of the industry he’s trying to help and he’s hurting it,” said Bob Miller, president of NLMK’s Pennsylvania operations. “To me, it all gets back to jobs and we’re going to be put in a position where we’re going to have to eliminate jobs.”
NLMK processes the imported slabs into sheet steel used by the construction, pipe, automotive and other industries.The mills were formerly owned by Sharon Steel, a twice-bankrupt producer whose woes devastated the community.
“We’re the largest employer in town,” Mr. Miller said. “We represent over 20 percent of their tax base. If we start laying people off, they’re going to have to reduce their budget.”
NLMK’s plan to invest $650 million in its Pennsylvania plants has been put on hold “because we don’t know whether we will get slabs at the right supply and cost to turn them into money,” Mr. Miller said.
Looking to Nucor
While the threat posed by the tariffs is very real to Mr. Miller and his 800 employees, the impact on many companies and the broader economy is harder to measure. The import penalties may not wreak as much economic havoc as opponents fear.
But they may not provide the magnitude of relief the White House is promising either.
“In terms of what they’re going to do to bring back employment in the steel sector, that’s just not going to happen,” said Duke University economics professor Allan Collard-Wexler.
Mr. Wexler said technology that allowed producers to make the same amount of steel with far fewer people — not globalization — was largely responsible for the 400,000 jobs the U.S. industry lost between 1972 and 2002.
Mills that melt scrap in electric furnaces now account for about 70 percent of U.S. steel production. The process is more efficient and low cost than the coal and iron ore consuming blast furnaces that U.S. Steel and other old line steelmakers rely on.
Preeminent among the electric furnace operators is Nucor, the largest U.S.-based steelmaker. The Charlotte, N.C., company shipped 24.7 million tons last year vs. just 1 million tons in 1979.
“Nucor is probably responsible for most of the job losses we’ve seen in the U.S. steel industry,” Mr. Wexler says.
Another influencer on the jobs front was U.S. Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross, who bemoaned a 35 percent drop in steel industry employment when he made tariff recommendations to Mr. Trump last month.
When a crush of imports sent a handful of major U.S. steel producers into bankruptcy in the early 2000s, Mr. Ross’ International Steel Group gobbled them up at steeply discounted prices. Hundreds of the bankrupt mills’ laid off workers were not called back.
Figuring out China
There also are questions about whether the measures, which include 10 percent tariffs on aluminum imports, will address China, which accounts for half of global steel production and more than half of global aluminum production.
Industry and administration officials largely blame China for a 700-million global glut of steelmaking capacity. They accuse the country of subsidizing exports and of avoiding penalties the U.S. imposes on dumped imports by shipping steel through other countries and using other evasive measures.
China’s 1.2-billion ton steel industry gives tariff proponents a ready answer when critics worry that Mr. Trump’s solution will spark a trade war.
“The reality is we’ve been in a trade war for over 20 years,” former Nucor chairman and CEO Dan DiMicco, a Trump adviser, told reporters last week. “If I had my way, we’d be doing a 50 percent tariff on really bad actors.”
China accounted for less than 3 percent of the 29.6 million tons of finished steel the U.S. imported last year, according to the American Iron and Steel Institute.
Major allies like South Korea, Japan and Germany, which exported much more to the U.S., will be hit harder by the import penalties.
The tariffs are a first step in addressing China’s misconduct, said Scott Paul, president of the Alliance for American Manufacturing Group, a coalition of union and companies concerned about trade issues. He said that while China directly exports a small amount of steel to the U.S., the tariffs will also apply to steel that China ships to the U.S. market through South Korea, Thailand and other countries.
Mr. Paul hopes the penalties will encourage other countries to join the U.S. in negotiating a deal with China to reduce its output.
“It’s been a pretty lonely role for the United States,” he said.
Looking for exclusions
Critics say negotiating with China should be the priority.
“The tariffs proposed will do little to address the fundamental problem of massive aluminum overcapacity in China,” Aluminum Association president and CEO Heidi Brock wrote in a letter to Mr. Trump last week.
She told the president the tariffs “may do more harm than good” when it comes to aluminum-consuming industries.
Companies that import steel they can’t get from U.S. producers because it costs too much or isn’t high enough quality are worried that — faced with a 25 or 10 percent metals price increase — customers they fabricate parts for will just import the finished part. The Trade Partnership. a Washington, D.C., consulting firm, estimates more than five jobs will be lost for every job the tariffs create.
But while critics contend tariffs will spark inflation, some are not as convinced.
Morningstar, a Chicago investment research and advisory firm, says steel and aluminum are such a small part of the costs of many finished products that price increases won’t be that significant. The firm’s analysts believe the tariffs will increase the average price of a U.S. car by roughly 1 percent.
President George W. Bush imposed similar import penalties on steel imports in 2002, when the industry was battered by the post 9/11 recession and a wave of import-induced bankruptcies. The U.S. International Trade Commission estimated in 2003 that those import restrictions had a $30 million impact on what was then about a $12 trillion U.S. economy.
The steel and aluminum industries were different then, as were the problem and remedy. So the price tag for Mr. Trump’s measures may bear no comparison to that.
One trade lawyer who asked not to be identified said a big determinant of the ultimate impact depends on how the tariffs are applied.
Mr. Trump has said the penalties initially won’t apply to imports from Canada and Mexico, two countries that received similar treatment in 2002.
Companies that rely on imports because there is no domestic supplier are expected to ask for exclusions. U.S. companies that face competition from imports of the finished parts they make from steel and aluminum are expected to ask that the tariffs apply to those imports as well.
“This happened big time in 2002. It was a nightmare,” the trade attorney said. “The government has got to know that everybody’s going to come out and request exclusions.”
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.
Steel import picture U.S. steel producers say China’s massive steel industry is why they need 25 percent tariffs on steel imports. But China accounted for less than 3 percent of U.S. imports of finished steel products last year. Countries that supply the U.S. with the most finished steel products: Sources of finished steel imported to U.S., by weight
Created with Highstock 6.0.73 ,753 ,0003 ,753 ,0002 ,191 ,0002 ,191 ,0001 ,504 ,0001 ,504 ,0001 ,405 ,0001 ,405 ,0001 ,245 ,0001 ,245 ,000987 ,000987 ,000813 ,000813 ,000796 ,000796 ,00016 ,864 ,00016 ,864 ,000TonsSouth Korea | -1.5%Turkey | -9.3%Japan | -16.4%Germany | +17.9%Taiwan | +14.9%Brazil | +20.0%China | -5.7%Russia | +156.9%All other | +20.1%010M2.5M5M7.5M12.5M15M17.5M20M
Sources of finished steel imported to U.S., by percent share
Created with Highstock 6.0.757.1 %57.1 %2.7 %2.7 %2.8 %2.8 %3.3 %3.3 %4.2 %4.2 %4.8 %4.8 %5.1 %5.1 %7.4 %7.4 %12.7 %12.7 %All otherRussiaChinaBrazilTaiwanGermanyJapanTurkeySouth Korea
Source: American Iron and Steel Institute | James Hilston/Post-Gazette






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.