President Donald Trump gave U.S. steel and aluminum producers the import relief they have been pleading for Thursday, but investors paid the price. Stocks fell along a broad front following the announcement.

Steel importers and other critics of Mr. Trump’s plans to levy across the board 25 percent tariffs on steel imports and 10 percent on aluminum imports say thousands of U.S. manufacturing workers and consumers also will eventually pay the price. Manufacturers that rely on imported metals because the products they need are not made in the U.S. say the trade action threatens their employees.

“These tariffs would undoubtedly raise costs for U.S. businesses that rely heavily on steel and aluminum for the majority of their products — and ultimately consumers,” American Petroleum Institute president and CEO Jack Gerard said in a statement.

Mr. Trump made giving U.S. steel and aluminum producers relief from imports a core part of his 2016 campaign. He met with industry executives Thursday to discuss his plans for imposing the penalties, scheduled to be formally announced next week.

Advertise with us

Domestic steelmakers have been pleading for import relief for years, saying they are being victimized by foreign producers that benefit from government subsidies and flood the U.S. market with steel priced at below production costs.

“It destroys our companies and our jobs,” Mr. Trump told the executives. “People have no idea how badly our country has been mistreated.”

“You’ll have protection for a long time in a while,” he told the industry officials.

Mr. Trump is basing the action on an obscure 1962 trade law that permits the White House to take unilateral action if imports threaten national security.

“Imported aluminum used to make beer cans is not a threat to national security,” Beer Institute president and CEO Jim McGreevy said in a statement.

Advertise with us

The industry group forecasts the tariffs will slap a $347.7 million tax on the beverage industry in the form of higher prices it will pay for aluminum. The tariffs will also result in the loss of 20,291 U.S. jobs, the industry group forecast.

The president of a group representing the air conditioning, heating and refrigeration industry said the import penalties are “injurious, rather than helpful, to our efforts to increase American manufacturing and create jobs.”

U.S. Steel president and CEO Dave Burritt, who was among the industry leaders who met with Mr. Trump, said the tariffs will provide more effective relief than trade complaints covering individual types of imports.

Domestic steel producers have long complained that foreign steelmakers routinely circumvent tariffs imposed on individual products after the long, costly complaint process. They do that by shipping the steel through countries the tariffs don’t apply to or by altering the steel slightly so the tariff no longer applies.

“We are not protectionists. We want a level playing field,” Mr. Burritt said during the meeting.

Advertise with us

White House action comes after U.S. Commerce Secretary — and former steel executive — Wilbur Ross recommended remedies to Mr. Trump last month ranging from across the board tariffs to country-by-country import quotas.

Mr. Ross cited the closure of 10 domestic steelmaking furnaces since 2000 and the closure of six domestic aluminum smelters since 2013. He singled out China as the major culprit, saying Chinese producers make nearly as much steel in the average month as U.S. steel producers make in a year.

“A strong steel industry is critically important to this country and our national security,” said Todd Leebow, president and CEO of Majestic Steel USA, a suburban Cleveland steel processor and distributor.

Mr. Trump’s threats to penalize imports have prompted counter-threats from major trading partners, who warn they will impose penalties on a wide range of U.S. exports. A spokesman for Japanese steelmakers said the response could be at hand.

“It will inevitably invite retaliation from America’s most reliable allies, ultimately hurting American non-manufacturing industries as well,” said Tadaaki Yamaguchi, chairman of the Japan Steel Information Center.

Advertise with us

Steel stocks jumped on the news, with U.S. Steel shares climbing nearly 6 percent to finish at $46.01, up $2.50. AK Steel, a West Chester, Ohio producer with operations in Butler, surged 9 percent to finish at $5.65, up 49 cents.

But the S&P 500 headed lower on the development, finishing at 2,677.67, off 1.3 percent. The Dow fell 1.7 percent to close at 24,608.98.

Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.