A lawsuit alleging that U.S. Steel shortchanged about 200 former nonunion U.S. Steel employees on incentive pay after they were let go in 2014 now charges that former general counsel Suzanne Rich Folsom was part of the plan to do that.

The amended complaint, filed Jan. 26, added Ms. Folsom, as well as Robert Garretson, another member of U.S. Steel’s law department, as defendants in the case. The lawsuit originally was filed in 2016 by Tina Anthony. a former paralegal, on behalf of herself and other employees who were laid off at about the same time.

The filing said Ms. Folsom and Mr. Garretson “made or actively participated in the decision to deny full and proper payments” to the workers, who either received smaller short-term incentive plan payments or no payments at all at the end of 2014.

Ms. Folsom resigned in December after three years as U.S. Steel’s top lawyer. Securities filings at the time that her departure was announced indicated she would receive $1.3 million in severance, $50,000 in lieu of reimbursement for outplacement services, and company-paid health care for up to 18 months or until she qualified for coverage at her next job.

Advertise with us

According to the lawsuit, the laid-off workers were to receive a prorated portion of their short-term incentive based on the portion of the year they worked. Ms. Anthony received “substantially less” than she was entitled to, according to the complaint.

In court filings, U.S. Steel said a six-page release that Ms. Anthony and other dismissed workers signed in order to receive severance benefits prohibits them from filing claims for the short-term incentive or other benefits. U.S. Steel also said that the payments are discretionary, based on performance, and that the company has the option of reducing or eliminating them.

A judge has not yet ruled whether to convert Ms. Anthony’s complaint into a class-action lawsuit, which would allow other dismissed workers to pursue claims.

U.S. Steel did not respond to an email seeking comment.

♦ ♦ ♦

Advertise with us

In case Pittsburgh Steelers fans don’t have enough reasons to root against the New England Patriots in Super Bowl LII, S&P Global Market Intelligence has provided few more.

The five times that the squad every red-blooded Pittsburgher is genetically constructed to hate has won the Super Bowl, the average S&P 500 return is 3.4 percent, according to S&P’s market research arm. The four times the Patriots lost, the average market return was 7.7 percent.

The Philadelphia Eagles are seeking their first Super Bowl title, having lost in two previous attempts. The S&P 500 advances an average of 9.4 percent in the years that a team wins the Super Bowl for the first time. The average advance is 15.9 percent if the first-time winner comes from a National Football Conference team like the Eagles, according to the S&P research.

And as all market pundits worth their puts and calls know, the S&P 500 generally performs better when an NFC team wins (14.5 percent return) than when an American Football Conference team triumphs (8.9 percent return).

However, there may be one reason why Steelers fans would consider holding their noses and rooting for the Patriots: the market returns 13.2 percent in the years when a defending Super Bowl champion like the Patriots wins the game.

Advertise with us

Appreciating the fact that investors need all the intelligence they can get as the aging bull market climbs a wall of worry, S&P provides a few lesser known Super Bowl indicators:

• The average S&P 500 return when the game is played in a cold climate like Minnesota (the site of Super Bowl LII) is 14.9 percent.

• The 17 times the game was played in a domed stadium or one with a retractable roof that was closed, the S&P 500 returned an average of 6.6 percent. The average return for the 34 games played in an open stadium or when a retractable roof was open was 14.3 percent.

• The median cumulative final score in the 51 Super Bowls to date is 46 points. When the teams combined to score 46 or more points, the average S&P 500 return was 16.6 percent. When they scored less, the return was 6.3 percent.

S&P cautions that these statistics don’t “represent a fundamental analysis of market trends” and are not “intended to be the basis for any investment decisions whatsoever.”

Advertise with us

In other words, be careful out there.

Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941